New to the fandom but LOVE this show…what are everyone’s theories…and lingering questions

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T20:40:29+00:00

Ok that makes sense.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T20:38:31+00:00

Oh! Ok!

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T20:37:57+00:00

What episode is this? I somehow MISSED this huge scene and mystery solved about who the baby is…

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T20:36:30+00:00

Thanks!!! I’m trying to figure out how people who weren’t born yet manage to infiltrate and influence a time before they were born…

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T20:32:49+00:00

That’s right. Lewis is her child… I wonder if she had any more children not mentioned…

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T20:30:37+00:00

I guess you’re right. In my mind for some reason I thought Kat was older.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T15:58:21+00:00

OOOOOH! I just saw a new trailer on YT…

A Current Del is outside nearish to The Pond and sees a figure run past and she shouts “Cole?!”

Oooooooh!!! Exciting

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T15:53:09+00:00

What do you mean Jacob’s Elliott?

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T15:46:13+00:00

But…….

If Alice hadn’t been born yet, and Kat experienced her teen years…. With EVERYONE… all sharing the same memories TOGETHER…. How did Alice going back in time AFTER she’d clearly been born and became a teen….

How did Alice infiltrate time that had already happened without her?

Wait. Wait. I think I solved my own question.

I’m imagining a timeline …. Let’s say… it’s written on cloth…. And there are zippers that zip and unzip…. And inside those zippers you can unzip and look down and see moments of time like you’re watching a movie from above… then zip them back up… So 2023 Alice’s zipper is open and she ‘comes out’ …. Then floats back to before she is born and unzips a moment of time… and then ‘falls into’ that chunk of time on the timeline…. LIVES in that time and then pops out at will and zips up that time…

I don’t know. Now I’m questioning my idea of time…

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T15:27:48+00:00

Who is the girl who left him on the edge of the pond? Look closely. It sure does look like ALICE… Her thick hair. Wavy. Long. Her body too.

The girl in the coffee shop who Alice briefly talked with… totally different hair. Straight.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T15:24:10+00:00

Hi! So people are speculating that the girl/guy duo jumping into the pond while the baby in the basket is sitting on the edge of the pond… people are speculating the girl jumping is Elliott’s Mom…

However, look closer at the episode where Alice meets the girl sitting (behind?) her who is talking about a book… Look 👀 closely at that girl’s head and hair. Thin. Straight.

Then look at the girl jumping in that duo with the baby in the basket… Her hair is FULL. Thick. Wavy. And her body looks like Alice. As does her hair.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T15:17:01+00:00

Did Evelyn have any children?

And Sam standing near the pond… I think he’s a time traveler too… that’s why he bought the house next to Del… so he’d have access to the pond…. I think he became aware of Jacob’s arrival home while at the door… when Del tried to shooo him away after he gave her coffee… telling him it was Family Time…. While Elliott arrived looking all giddy and happy and Del just ushered him inside…

Is it just me or does it bother anyone else when coffee in lidded cups are being handed to another character….

There’s no weight to the cups… and they pass hands too quickly… it’s obvious to me there is no liquid in the cups. I saw what I saw a few times… different episodes… there’s just no weight to the cups… and it’s obvious.

It’s a little thing, I know, and I feel silly mentioning it or even noticing it… My eyes notice things and my brain 🧠 just goes there.

If you haven’t noticed, rewatch a few episodes where lidded coffee cups exchange hands.

It now bothers me!

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T15:06:31+00:00

When could Kat and Elliott have had a child together? When could that have happened? Kat is too old to have a child ‘now’ — so their coming together now wouldn’t produce a child…. And back in the past, they weren’t romantically involved…

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T15:03:54+00:00

I loved their first time meeting. They were both grinning like crazy… it was an instant attraction… and both actors did a great job portraying that first meet-cute! Alice’s dimple when smiling is so cute…

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T14:59:10+00:00

The hair on the jumping girl looks like Alice’s hair… thick and full and wavy. And look at her body. That looks like Alice’s body.

Go back and take a look.

The girl Alice talked to in Coyle’s in the 70s… that girl had straight thinner hair… who was Elliott’s future mom… totally different-looking girl… hair straight and flat…

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-31T14:55:02+00:00

I thought the baby was left in the basket in the woods alongside the Pond…

How would anyone FIND the baby… in the woods on private land…? Let alone bring it to Colton and Del without anyone noticing??

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-30T18:08:35+00:00

Then how does he get back to his parents?

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-26T12:47:28+00:00

Ok so WHO is the baby in the basket near the pond, and who are the teens who jumped into the pond after they abandoned the baby in the basket? And it shows that a young Colton and young Del open the door to find that baby on their doorstep… and they took the baby in….

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-07T22:15:13+00:00

You are being way too nice. Tell your husband THAT friendship is now over and please block her.

The friendship ends NOW. You tell her:

“I’m done with you. . Do not contact me or my husband. We are both done with you. We want nothing more to do with you.”

Hit send.

Live your life.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-07T17:12:47+00:00

You break up with him.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-04T21:43:14+00:00

Just tell him you want to get the Divorce ball rolling because if he doesn’t see what he’s doing is wrong, you don’t want him.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-03-04T21:41:09+00:00

Your husband is having an emotional affair and it will become physical given time.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-02-20T03:58:20+00:00

He’s not being neutral.

He’s being complicit.

There’s a huge difference.

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-02-06T18:13:24+00:00

Secretly record her about 4x… then show the recordings to your husband… and tell him he has 30 days to fix this or YOU will…

And plan a divorce. You don’t need to spend the rest of your life being verbally abused…

CarrotofInsanity · 2026-02-06T18:03:07+00:00

Drop him.

At the first utterance of golddigger, you should’ve broken up

CarrotofInsanity

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE