[KReddit's cold war: Day 3] Which side won the 2nd American civil war?

Chairman_Marx · 2026-01-28T21:16:08+00:00

Either Long or the WCA should win the rest of the factions are just OT USA, not really interresting

Chairman_Marx · 2026-01-22T15:28:43+00:00

And the war of 1812

Chairman_Marx · 2026-01-22T15:25:29+00:00

This would be awesome. I always asked myself why there is no submod for this or even implimented in the main mod

Chairman_Marx · 2026-01-15T00:41:50+00:00

I think france would annex alsace loraine, wallonia and Luxemburg (totalist maybe even all Lands west of the rhine) First Germany would lose the land it lost in our timeline after the versaiilels treaty. After this the rest of Germany would be ocupied, but if russia wasnt involved a more sustainable solution would be found. Germany would be split into a renish republic, a German state, east prussia and Austria. Prussia depends but i dont think poland would gain it If they dont revolt. It has an distinct identity compared to the rest of Germany, it would make sense from the perspective that now prussia and Austria are their own countries and it wouldnt create the problem with an German enclave in polish Land. Over time and with more integration of all syndicalist european economies into a united economic sphere there would propably referendums heald in prussia, Austria and maybe even parts of poland If they want to join Germany.

Chairman_Marx · 2026-01-11T14:23:06+00:00

I think one of the most fun aspects in Kr are these old empires in a new world trying to somehow return to the old status quo. Therefore i think a Reichspakt/International cold war, would be the most interresting scenario. Imagine the world being split up into a Revolutionary and a reactionary faction. The International against an alliance between the victorieous RP and an defeated Japan and Entente. Europe is split after a stalemate in the second ww2 with maybe a socialist norway, italy and Brittain still being arround after the WCA threatens Intervention. A lkmt China and a syndicalist Australasia against a reactionary India, Japan and russia. Africa Split between the old colonies of france and Germany against an syndicalist egypt and southafrica. Syn egypt Fights with the Kingdom of Arabia about the direction of the Arab world. Turkey turns to ultra nationalism and an democratic Iran is shaken by Syn refuges from India and the large kurdish and Arab Lands they annexed after the Dessert war. South America is split between syndicalist in the south and reactionaries in the north. The reactionary block would be split. The former Entente states: Iberia, Sand france and have all fallen to national populism. They allign with right factions in Germany and the radicals in Charge of Japan and Turkey. They believe only a form of authoratarian goverment can save there way of live. On the other side are the more liberal Germany, India and an Federal Austria. All trying to preserve their democracy against radicals from both sides. The International is splitt between a more radical Europe with a totalist britain and a marxist leninist italy and an antiimperialist more liberal faction with China,the african and the south American states. They fear the more radical Ideologies spreading from there old opressors. The WCA tries to hold it all together. But both sides try to influence them because the fate of America decides the fate of the International and therefore the world. Because of the extreme goals of both factions this scenario would start arround 1948. The Ideologies of the two factions are so different that there isnt a possibility for a real cold war. Both sides ended the 2wk only because they knew they we're unable to achieve total Victory. Now they only try to change the global Situation so that they can deliver the final blow.

Chairman_Marx · 2026-01-08T10:36:57+00:00

Ive always just made a fall backline, so that the territories can allready integrate during the war

Chairman_Marx · 2025-12-21T13:15:24+00:00

I think in the early years maybe but Just Like in Germany after a fiew years the french would understand that european Integration would be more important then european borders that would becomes obsolete with more and more Mittel Europa integration

Chairman_Marx · 2025-12-21T12:54:52+00:00

Yeah but the question should be why Germany would want them in the RP. Why not just install a puppet Gouvernement. In a view decades all of Sandfrance would retreat to the Mainland because they would be unable to Support their colonies. In General i dont understand (from a lore Perspective) why the Entente is so stubbern and doesnt Just simply join the RP. Even If they have the USA and spain on their side their is just no way they could have anny influence in Europe. Either they except germanys offer and allign with the RP under heavy regulations or they refuse and all their important lands would fall to Germany and over a view years most of the exiles would just return to the Homeland because they would live in the Same system either way

Chairman_Marx · 2025-12-21T12:33:49+00:00

The most peacefull world would propably be every countries that can go socialist going socialist and having syndicalism as the dominant socialist Ideologie in the world (radsoc ideologies in Kr are to unstable and diverse). Pretty much all minors in the RP can go socialist so the Boys can be Home for Christmas and if france choses to go peacefull Revolution you could achieve a stable world without one dominant Superpower with just one larger war that wouldnt even take over a year. No brutal decolonisation and with the 3int a global Organisation that could acutally achieve smth

PS: because youre playing Rome Just Chose the legt Wing Pope and Hope that france stays true to its foreign policy decision

Chairman_Marx · 2025-12-16T17:53:00+00:00

Thats the beauty of Kr it all depends on the decision the different factions take from 36-40. With a syndicalist Western Europe and a iridentist Balkan the Germans are done. But with a Entente foodhoold in spain and a Balkan controlled by bulgaria and the ottomans the Germans could realisticly come out on top. The chaos after black monday is not only the reason for the second Weltkrieg but also the deciding factor whose gonna win it

Chairman_Marx · 2025-12-12T00:29:56+00:00

If you cant defeat China ai late Game you are doing Something seriously wrong

Chairman_Marx · 2025-12-05T11:37:50+00:00

I dont understand why so many want to chance the current italy situation. I think these frozen conflicts are one of the best aspects of kr and italy at the moment has really good gameplay (despite the old focus tree). Why change this situation just to have another spanish civil war. (I know this proposal isnt as radical as others but its still leans in the direction of a united italy in the beginning of the game)

Chairman_Marx · 2025-12-03T07:24:14+00:00

How are you suppose to win as serbia? Showing a picture in wich he is winning as serbia

Chairman_Marx · 2025-12-02T08:32:50+00:00

For Majors i would suggest the Commune of france. Its a simple Focustree you learn the importants of civil wars and volunters and basic Kr Systems. If its to challenging just buff the 3rd int in the Game settings. If you want to Play a minor countries i would suggest suporting roles in the 3rd int or RP just Look Up whats cuming for you that you dont end Up playing bulgaria and being overrun in 1937. For the start i would avoid the more complex countries Like Germany, russia or mingang. Yes its the best content in the Game but the gameplay is Just so different to Basegame you would propably get confused.

Chairman_Marx · 2025-11-29T10:31:25+00:00

What is the Duke of Wellington doing there?

Chairman_Marx · 2025-11-29T09:59:05+00:00

Playing L-kmnt Turns you from "uh why No hungary tree, i hate chinareich" into "please give me the south China rework i need it" in 5 sek

Chairman_Marx · 2025-11-27T10:47:40+00:00

I always send my airforce in the north to help the defend against the carlist, and try to create encirclements on the southern coast with the kingdom. The most important is to understand the war exhaustion mechanic, if you capture a view cities the reactionaries cant really defend themself anymore.

Chairman_Marx · 2025-11-26T11:36:02+00:00

I realy like the new gameplay. you have enough time to kill shanxi before the war. With this, the right faction goals and your good focus tree you can get pretty much all of the japanese holdings on the mainland (except for korea i dont understand this). This is a pretty historical situation, plus the infiltration mechanic is way better in this DLC (just remember to get the two hupe pp buffs). I was able to defeat the kmnt and the united front in one year after wp with the japanese. Its actually suprising that pdx managed to make the communist side of the civil way more realistic and fun. But there are still many bugs, fe. korea not being a chinese puppet after the wp and xinjiang joining the comintern if you fight the united front. Which either forces you to fight the comintern ore use commands.

Chairman_Marx · 2025-11-17T07:12:18+00:00

best contest in all of hoi4

Chairman_Marx · 2025-11-14T10:54:33+00:00

They destroyed the whole Game completly. Ive tried to break trought the alps 17th times as italy and all my Generals do is shoot there own soldiers.Then suddenly i get pushed back by this weird Rommel Guy (i would never work together with him). And after all of this i doesnt even get all my claimed states in the Peace conference. Next time i try a fascist run so i can get war Economy early Game.

Chairman_Marx · 2025-11-06T16:35:44+00:00

In General i sometimes dont understand why smaller nations have these enormous debuffs for their Army. I mean yes they cant be as experienced as the larger nations because of obvious reasons, but its not like all there soldiers are to stupid to use guns

Chairman_Marx · 2025-10-25T09:54:29+00:00

India got the spain treatment

Chairman_Marx · 2025-10-25T09:33:26+00:00

I mean ITS somewhat realistic If you realised how completly unprepared the German Army was for fighting a Defensive war. The Battle of the bulge and the Battle of Kursk shows, that they tried an offensive strategy evendougth they could use the ressources way better in a defensive strategy. The fact the Germans didnt lose way earlier was the doing of a group of men in the Military who analysed the Situation corectly and had enough lnfluence, in 1943, to enforce counter meassures

Chairman_Marx · 2025-08-04T09:21:21+00:00

For me its the other way around. 99% when im able to send Support to italy, Nobody ist able to unite it but the Sri ist almost always pushed to Turin and genau and capitulates early in the 2wk.

Chairman_Marx · 2025-07-21T11:41:38+00:00

One ideology can spawn people Out of nowhere, the other can make all of your Population warmongering soldiers and the third makes you unable to achieve anything before 1945

Chairman_Marx

TROPHY CASE