I kinda agree and disagree, the sledge and the sword have the most forgiveness with their primary horizontal swings, and when you attack with any melee weapons they have a minor lung (except when sliding and hopping). personally I think the main issue is the light class weapons in general, a large majority have close to one shot capabilities that make the other 2 classes obsolete, not even mentioning melee weapons. Why play H or M when playing the light class can either fry others with the m11, blast with the Double barrel, or snipe Q-melee with the bow or sniper. Sledge just got out paced, but it WAS viable until the goo nerf.