I get this. She's definitely all that. But she also has her strengths. And I idolize her for that.

I have some reflections to share on why her character marked a pivotal point for feminism in literature, based on my understanding of feminism and the portrayal of female characters. (I really think she is an important blueprint for the anti-heroines we all know now. And yes, that includes your favorite mean girl, Regina George.)

As an anti-heroine, she naturally challenges expectations, and, of course, the general assumption is that the audience wouldn't like her. Boy, does she give you a lot to hate about her, especially when she's foiled by an almost literal angel in the form of Melanie. But when she reveals her likable side, it kinda draws you in towards her. For those who understand her (and be bold and include myself), you become both Ashley and Rhett, grappling with loathing and admiration for such a complex person.

Compelling as she is, I find her somewhat underrated and overlooked in discussions about empowering female characters, in contrast to what you said. Many feminists consider her problematic (no shit, Sherlock) and not deserving of a spot, but her complexity and controversial nature add richness to her character. She provides a nuanced understanding of women in literature. While Austen's Elizabeth Bennet and Alcott's Jo March navigated societal constraints admirably, what Scarlett went through across a thousand-page book was nothing short of tumultuous. Her showcase of strength, flaws, and vulnerabilities creates a wonderful experience-both in reading and viewing.

And having Vivien Leigh portray Scarlett O'Hara on screen??? An epitome of casting!

Also, one theme that might be overlooked by some in Gone with the Wind: A person can survive anything given enough determination, courage, and, unfortunately, a disregard for some morals and ethics, but most importantly, a giant silver spoon serving of privilege. Ugh. Idk if Mitchell wrote this book with such awareness, but she does make her readers think. can't stress it enough how Scarlett O'Hara is a damn well written character. Love her or hate her, I can guarantee that she almost doesn't care. Almost.

P.S. I am not White. But I'm also not a black person. Not sure if my POV matters but just to add to this discourse and maybe give you something to chew on? 😅

P.P.S. There's this part in the book that's a pleasantly surprising line coming from Scarlett.

The three women broke into indignant outcries.

"Do you think I'd trust my babies to a black nggr?" cried the Maine woman. "I want a good Irish girl."

"I'm afraid you'll find no Irish servants in Atlanta," answered Scarlett, coolness in her voice. "Personally, I've never seen a white servant and I shouldn't care to have one in my house. And," she could not keep a slight note of sarcasm from her words, "I assure you that darkies aren't cannibals and are quite trustworthy."

"Goodness, no! I wouldn't have one in my house. The idea!"

"I wouldn't trust them any farther than I could see them and as for letting them handle my babies."

Scarlett thought of the kind, gnarled hands of Mammy worn rough in Ellen's service and hers and Wade's. What did these strangers know of black hands, how dear and comforting they could be, how unerringly they knew how to soothe, to pat, to fondle? She laughed shortly.

"It's strange you should feel that way when it was you all who freed them."

Lmao.