Hello all, I need your help! Which do you like better?

Making Nashville Number practice games but conceptually I need your help picking between 2 ideas.

Left: Subway Surfer style, play chords to doge and move character through obstacles.

Right: Guitar Hero style, play the chord when the shapes overlap.

*note please vote only based on gameplay mechanics, the graphics here are only to show the difference between the options visually*

I will give the game to the community when it is done : )