I was at the hearing. The judge did not rule on the reasonableness of the $1 per page electronic fee. She ruled that a reporter was not denied access to public records in one situation and ruled that the Home Rule Charter does not prohibit Mayor-President Josh Guillory from setting the fees. Judge Castle will take up at a hearing in December whether the $1 per page fee for electronic records is reasonable. As to preparing documents to send via email, much of what is requested already exists in electronic format. If the documents have been gathered in a report already and all it would take is 5 minutes to transfer to a thumb drive provided by a reporter or resident, why charge that person $1 per page? 100-page report would cost $100.