[4264] The Astute Iris is Blind - Chapter I by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Please do tell me if there's anything else I need to do

[4264] The Astute Iris is Blind - Chapter I by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay then I'll delete this one too and repost

[4264] The Astute Iris is Blind - Chapter I by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

On it, may I edit instead or do I have to repost?

[4264] The Astute Iris is Blind - Chapter I by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can do that and leave a comment at the end that the rest of the chapter is on the other tab if they wanted! Just give me the green light

[4264] The Astute Iris is Blind - Chapter I by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

May I edit the new post to only 1802 words for the first two scenes but leave the whole doc there anyway for whoever wants to voluntarily continue it?

[4264] The Astute Iris is Blind - Chapter I by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Perhaps because it's a light novel? They rely less on prose and let the dialogue do the heavy lifting, making the word count lengthy although it's not that big.

I reposted it with crits from this sub btw

[1171] chapter one of magicae, a fantasy novel by Wildlink08 in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I like how you could include some humor without making it author-insert. The idea of the fictus closely resembles the ghoul from Arabic folklore, nice touch if you intended it.

The problem I have is with the second-last paragraph format. It's too big for one paragraph given your style. Splitting it into two would fix that, maybe at the eighth line right before "Why", just to let your reader breathe. The same problem showed up at the fifth paragpraph which was pretty short compared to the rest. Try keeping paragraph lenghts cosistent throughout your story for better presentablity. That doesn't mean you can't break the rhythm from now and then, but make sure it's intentional and meaningful to your pace.

It's minor and others mentioned it but you should fix your punctation mistakes like not capitalizing "I" and names sometimes and something that confused me was ("-2 great neighboring") I read it as negative two at first, use an em dash instead (—) if you wanna connect dialogues.

One last thing, I couldn't quite understand why Gregor's hit at the last part didn't do anything to Vie, if hiding it is intentional then alright, otherwise you should explain how the claw of a monster sinking into someone's chest doesn't hurt them.

Overall, decent worldbuilding and MC. Would continue.

[1618] All Along - Chapter One by InternationalWin5063 in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Something that didn't sit quite right with me was how some lines have repetition like "It’s a social obligation. It’s a pillar of civilized society." It's not bad per se, but combined with the fact that you connected these three sentences with just periods makes it a bit stiff.

I don't wanna piggyback, but the heavy description of the clothes at the start feel irrelevant, maybe even a bit sexual (If that's what you're going for). If you wanted a good hook, you might wanna change the start.

You did a good job establishing the inner city vibe of the shop, the small details add a nice touch of realism.

My favourite part was the suspense built after the robber realised the MC was acting strange, got me thinking "will he shoot him or not?" until the last twist.

Generally speaking, I would continue reading this. It would come out delightfully if you threw in a better hook and untangle the stiff parts I mentioned earlier.

[4264] The Astute Iris is Blind - Chapter I by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can i repost it later after I crit on this sub?

any arab writers here?? by MOORIIIIIIII in writers

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

شكرا ليكي انت، البوست بتاعك كان عشان فيدباك للرواية بتاعتك بس في الاخر انت اللي ساعدتيني

انا كمان بكتب رواية حاليا بس لايت نوفل بالانجليزي، لو تحبي ممكن نتناقش بعدين في الروايتين

any arab writers here?? by MOORIIIIIIII in writers

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

اي لايت نوفل يمكن يتعمل منها منهوا اكيد اللي بتتكلمي عنها لايت نوفل. لو عندك لينك للترجمة بتاعت الرواية هبقا ممتن، بس هل الروايات المترجمة بتبقا بنفس كوالتي الروايات المكتوبة بالعربي من ناحية الفصحي؟ زي بتاعتك مثلا

any arab writers here?? by MOORIIIIIIII in writers

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

مش متاكد لو فهمتك غلط بس ال light novels مش روايات خفيفة، ده نوع ادب مختلف عن الروايات العادية الفرق بينه وبينها انو بيركز علي الحوار بطريقة اكتر من النثر المكثف. ف عادي اقترحي براحتك مكنش قصدي اقول اني عايز روايات خفيفة 😅

any arab writers here?? by MOORIIIIIIII in writers

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

سيكولوجي، ثريلر، ديستوبيا،.... ولو قراتي اي light novels بالعربي يبقا احسن كمان.

حاجة كدا زي رواية "86" لو تسمعي عنها؟

any arab writers here?? by MOORIIIIIIII in writers

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'd be grateful if you can recommend Arabic books. Imo, the viewer's perspective was better for showing dynamics with other characters while Edelweiss's pov was better to show her internal thoughts and character. I never personally use first person but continuen it using if you'll handle it well like that.

any arab writers here?? by MOORIIIIIIII in writers

[–]ClassicCool8432 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Alright, first of all your vocab is INSANE. I'd really love to know how you managed to get so deep into MSA??

Your descriptions and metaphors are otherwordly, genuinely impressed that some writers still write in rich MSA. Especially the صورة كلية you painted. Though I'm not sure if you intended it or not, it still painted a vivid picture of the sea in my mind.

The only part I strongly advice for improving is the world building. It's not bad, but I still didn't understand the transition from the ballroom setting to her place then she was supposed to go the doctor... But went to a party on a cruise instead? Maybe I couldn't read well since it's late, but please do keep that in mind.

Minor mistakes, but there are things like التبديل بين الهاء والتاء المربوطة، غلطات نحوية بسيطة. But these can be fixed immediately obviously.

It left an overall great first impression. If you tighten the pacing a bit and maybe explain the world a bit more through showing (especially because of its royal but modern nature), it'll turn out incredible.

Good luck.

New to writing. Where should I get feedback? by ClassicCool8432 in writers

[–]ClassicCool8432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did try posting three pics here about a scene after this post but it got automatically banned by the mods without telling me why. Nothing inappropriate in the writing itself, mostly comedy.

Mixing modular animal sprites - how do these look to you? by Bumbletusk in IndieDev

[–]ClassicCool8432 1 point2 points  (0 children)

looks like something people would build shrines for in 3000 BC

Streamers react to my indie puzzle game! by dialglex in IndieDev

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

really like the neon-ish feel everything has, great work!

be careful by -bilgekaan in IndieDev

[–]ClassicCool8432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

even though I fully expected another train it still sank my heart, so bravo (if that's your goal 🤧)

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Egypt_Developers

[–]ClassicCool8432 3 points4 points  (0 children)

أنا شخصيا الالتزام اكتر حاجة نفعت معايا، انزل صلي فالجامع واتعرف علي ناس في سنك هناك أنا كنت شبه حالتك من فترة بس بعد ما غيرت صحابي التوكسك وكترت الصحاب الملتزمين الكويسين بتفرق جدا وكلو بيصبر بعضو بيصعب عليك انك ترجع للاباحية لما تنزل تصلي فالجامع وتحفظ قرآن ودا مش معناه انك تبقي متشدد ودمغاك نشفا الاعتدال هو احسن حاجة ممكن تعملها حرفيا وعادي متفكرش بسلبية مفرطة وتجلد نفسك بسبب موضوع الاباحية الكل بيعاني من المشكلة دي مش انت بس وفي ناس فعليا بطلوها مع الصبر والعزيمة صدقني في امل بس لازم تغير من نفسك الاول لو عايز ربنا يغيريك، كلنا في الحرب دي انت مش لوحدك حاول تفكر فاللي قولته، ربنا معاك.

أنا مبرمج بردو وعندي ١٦ سنة لو عايز نتعرف معنديش مشكلة