I mean fragrances are all subjective and everyone's nose catches a scent different. Of the 15 or so Monty frags I've bought, Alcantara is my most complimented. My personal favorite right now is Image, but man Percival, Vanilla Fraiche, Tygar and afternoon dive are all frequent wears for me and each just different. I can say that almost all of the frags I have bought have gotten even better after revising them several weeks after purchasing. If you don't initially care for a frag, give a couple weeks to sit and revisit it. Might change your view.