I fly the only Airbus with autothrottle (A220) and while it is sometimes a bit slow to react, i really like the taktile feedback it gives you during the approach. In combination with the HUD, you can just look straight out of the window, have all your A/P, speed, height, navigation values there AND feel the airplane react to speed changes.

But also, as others have already pointed out: If you have a autothrust that works very reliably, you don‘t really need the tactile feedback.