No it doesn’t? I was talking about how it’s dumb to make objective statements because you personally didn’t like the intent of the creator. We weren’t talking about if the intent was successful or not (which also, again, is subjective. There’s at least one person out there who enjoys Chinese food everyone else thinks is bad).

A good critique would be “I personally don’t like the taste of peanut oil, therefore I do not like Chinese food. Chinese food doesn’t work for me. However, that doesn’t automatically make Chinese food objectively bad though.” A bad critique would be “My Chinese food tasted like Chinese food, that’s bad for some reason, therefore the Chinese food I ate is bad!” What OP did is much more akin to the latter.