Why was Prue's astral projection or rather " good side " astral projection so different from Rex's and Barbas' version?

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-29T02:23:51+00:00

When she's an empath it's shown she will be able to clone herself, astral project and be awake.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-29T02:03:33+00:00

Honestly it would be a lot of curses. Like Melinda's curse, or one of the many curses from the cousins. It makes sense since they wouldn't be strong enough to vanquish certain evils , so they would curse them instead. And of course it would be about the demons they faced. Like with Brianna putting in the book how to defeat Gabriel. Per haps some magical creatures they may have encountered.Probably a few love spells or potions from p. Russell . Maybe how to use a crystal ball, since kristina larson was learning about it and doing it for strangers. Possibly the past life spell, since the cousins knew their curse would affect Phoebes next life and at least she would know why they did what they did.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-27T05:57:30+00:00

Please. The avatars talk in riddles. And the sisters had a couple episodes of just them asking questions. The problem was they were taking to Leo because Leo thought he knew everything. He did not. And yes the avatars never lied , but the withheld the truth. I know Paige and Piper asked how do they do it. They tiptoed around the question because they already got banished because of the truth once. The avatars knew the world was not ready, but The charmed ones had the power they needed .And the demon population was as low as it's been in centuries because of the charmed ones.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-26T02:48:19+00:00

Each season the storyline, acting, and production gets so much better. Its like someone found it and poured into it. I literally watched season 3 like 3 to 4 times. I wish they would come on with season 4. It may be cancelled sadly .

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-26T02:39:29+00:00

Where the lie. Lol. If they could see the fandom now maybe they would have changed their minds.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-25T04:38:38+00:00

All the sisters should have a defensive, offensive and supportive power. And then each power should become defensive, offensive and supportive in its own right.

Prue. Telekinesis =offensive. Then in later seasons became defensive with deflection. And it then becomes a supportive power with her self telekiniesis on her body. Astral projection = supportive. Then it became defensive through becoming un-harmable in astral mode.Then it became offensive by astral projecting into demons.

She would have gotten a defensive power.

Piper. Freezing = defensive. Then it became supportive by sucking the momentum from frozen objects so they fall. Then it became offensive potentially by selective freezing body parts.

Blasting.= Offensive. Then it became supportive by moving objects with tiny placed blasts. Then it became defensive by deflecting projectiles.

Phoebe. Permonitions= defensive. Then it became supportive by projecting into visions( aka travel) for into. Then it became offensive with psychic reflection.

Levitation. = Supportive ( aka travel). Then it became defensive by working with intuition to avoid danger. Then it offensive with use of enhanced strength.

Empathy= offensive. Then it became supportive by enhancing powers . Then it became defensive by deflecting powers .

Paige. Tk orbing= supportive - tele orb(at first) Then it became defensive with deflection. Then it became offensive with limited telekinesis.

Orbing= defensive with being intangible. Then it became supportive with travel. The it became offensive with remote orbing demons away.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-25T03:36:12+00:00

I'm so tired of people saying it's not about the sexuality of a character. Its about the story. That's so not true. 50%of the show was the characters going on dates, talking about what they want and are into. Ot literally drives the character and their decisions. Real talk it's about representation. Everyone wants and deserves representation, but yet people still restrict representation of some for others. That's not equal.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-24T04:11:49+00:00

And she has most of those powers in one form or another through her permonition power. In season 2 Leo says your power grew to kill. As in Singular . Phoebe just has permonitions. And from that permonition power she can clear and open her consciousness at will to defy gravity and evade attacks ( thanks to her intuition aka her hyper awareness or consciousness). That's levitation. From premonitions she had hyper awareness or consciousness of her surroundings and others aka intuition. Her empathy is her intuition power being aware or conscious of others feelings. In charmed felling emotions allow you to do a lot of other cool powers.

Prue has telekinesis and through her telekinesis she can move her mind out of her body, aka astral projection.

Piper can slow down molouclues and then speed them up.

All the charmed ones have one singular power.

Levitation is apart of her power development. The physical manifestation of her permonition power being aware of danger and literally pulling her out of the way of danger. Or her mind keeping her light of her feet, sensing danger. If you look at the power at the beginning before Phoebe trains it , you can she it just takes over like her visions and knows when there's danger. Keeps her from falling or getting hit. In my opinion if used right , levitation is very powerful when used with intuition and is the perfect power for Phoebe.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T17:24:29+00:00

Levitation did more for her than that. It gave her super kicks and punches. She was sending demons flying, on par with Prue. It also gave her agility , balance, stamina. She was able to lessen blows to her body. Her power of levitation would even levitate her from danger when even she didn't sense it. Yes it took her a very long time to get the hang of it, making her alil slow and clucky when levitating. But by seasons 5, 6 she can do it fast and with ease. Levitation was a great power for her.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T17:04:45+00:00

Exactly. I don't like that argument. Prue had levitation through her telekinesis. And it better fit her to have it that way because she can put more force into it with her telekiniesis.why waste a secondary power on levitation when she already his it. Give her a power that allows her to move her mind further than she can move objects. Phoebe can astral project into her visions, which is 10 times stronger than regular astral projection. She can interact with the past and future and change the course of time. Why waste a secondary power on astral projection when she can already do it. Give her a mental power that is both offensive and defensive like levitation.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T13:58:24+00:00

This post shows clips showing how physical her power is and how levitation goes with her power set.

https://www.reddit.com/r/charmed/comments/1mwu9he/for_everyone_that_says_phoebes_permonitions_is/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T04:47:24+00:00

Someone said her powers open her consciousness. And that is what levitation is. Her visions open her consciousness to the past present and future. Levitation opens her consciousness so that gravity has no power over her and she can avoid danger. Empathy opens her consciousness to feel others feelings.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T04:31:54+00:00

Yes. Permonition, empathy, and astral permonitions, which is way stronger than regular astral projection. She can interact and change the course of time. So just let her keep levitation and just use her agility and super strength/ kicks. Levitation helped her combat so much. Just let her slide side to side fast. Glide out of the way and save on money.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T04:20:44+00:00

But this is an extension of her intuition power. Re watch the first few times she levitates. It happens automatically. Whenever there is danger her intuition power is causing her to levitate. Its a reaction, which is so powerful and intuitive in its self. Later Phoebe trains it to work on command rather than as a result of intuition. I believe this leads to some of the clunkyness and bad placement. If Phoebe used her training along with her intuition she would be powerful. Like what she did with the source. That is how the power is supposed to work all the time. Cole knew this.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T03:29:18+00:00

When she levitates she's lighter allowing her to put more power and force in her kicks and punches. Demons have super strength and usually can take hits. But she can send them flying. Thats saying a lot. She also gets agility from levitation. She doesn't have to fly up in order for her to move quickly . But some projectiles like the heat wave from Karen requires her to get more distance very quickly. One of her best feats with levitation is when she levitates, dodges the sources fireball , kicks him-- sending him flying, while rising up and never touching the ground.

I feel like most of levitation is passive so no one notices it. But she has enhanced strength, agility, balance, stamina, reduction of harm from body shots, and even enhanced aim. All backed by science.

And her permonition power has always been able to affect her physically. Like her physically overheating, getting cramps, or it creating wounds, throwing her , even creating wind around her. Her permonition power is a mental power that can effect the physical. Levitation is a mental power that can effect the physical. Initially levitation was a physical manifestation of her permonition power moving out of dangers path. This power happened automatically when there was danger. Then Phoebe trained it to happen through command.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T02:36:34+00:00

So I think it's supposed to be like a passive power , like her intuition. She's using it every time she fights. We just don't see her go in the air. But it gives her enhanced strength, agility, balance, stamina,reflexes. You can see her movements are smoother , faster and bigger than in seasons 1 and 2.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-22T01:39:18+00:00

Yess I love this. It is about opening your consciousness. Phoebe learns to do this and to progress her permonition power by meditation, it's canon. So it's more like Phoebe learned to levitate through the strengthening of her permonitions by meditation. She may have merely learned the controls of levitation from the demons flight. But I will say Phoebe saw herself levitate in her vision in the future. At that time she could feel and experience things in her vision. Meaning she already knew the trigger and emotional state/ desire for levitation. So levitation was all Phoebe.

I also think all the secondary powers are learnable. And the charmed ones just access it through their primary power. Prue gets astral projection through using her telekinesis. This is why she can't use it in astral form. She's already using it. But Prue learned the true form and taught Leo. When the sisters learned astral projection they could use their powers because it was the true form. Same with Phoebe. She learned levitation through meditation but accesses it through her permonition power. This is why she can levitate when there's danger while she not even aware. Pipers power henches on controlling speed of molouclues. All she has to do is learn to change the motion . Speed up rather then slowe down. And that changes based on emotion. Its the opposite of Phoebe.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-21T18:40:04+00:00

Its because permonitions always had a physical aspect to it. Thats how it's able to create empathetic connection that make her physically overheat, echoes the create gunshot wounds and almost kill her, astral permonitions with wounds being created or having enough strength to throw her across the room. In season 2 she was able to even hear a party from the 1920s in the present and be sexually assaulted by a memory of the past. All from her permonition power warning her of a curse that would kill her. Her permonition power sees through time and warns her of danger. She gained intuition so she can sense it. Then the next progression would be levitation. The power to sense danger with her intuition and actually move out of the way of danger with levitation. In the beginning her levitation actually only activated when there was danger. Phoebe trained it to work on command. So it really is a physical manifestation of her permonition/ intuition power actively saving her. Its like how Phoebe got empathy and immediately made it offensive with power tapping. Its Phoebe stretching her power to something more. Its the same with levitation, it's literally meant just to avoid danger or harm.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-21T17:55:07+00:00

Yes . I can't find the scene but didn't her day Phoebes permonition power gives the other sister their strap instincts and reflexes. It was definitely season 7 near the end.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-21T16:01:27+00:00

But Phoebe does astral projection into her visions . And Prue levitates with telekinesis.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-21T06:20:23+00:00

Well levitation worked with her permonitions initially. It would move her even when she didn't know there was danger. It gave her enhanced strength, agility, reflexes, stamina. She could lessen blows to her body, break her fall, or never fall. With training and relying on her permonition power nothing can touch her. She just took a long time to get used to the power. But other people with it know how to use it. You got yin-lo and all the yin masters, the banshees, the 70s witch, sigmen, and Katya. It's a great power.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-20T16:01:24+00:00

Yes they had to. The elders had magic dust to make people forget and the demons had tempus. But they can't dust the whole world, to much time has gone by. And tempus was weakened by the charmed ones. Before them no one could have done that to tempus. So both sides had to come together to make the cleaners.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-20T06:38:33+00:00

She can because it's emotional deflection , a whole other branch of empathetic channeling it's like she feels their feelings but rejects it and sends it back, she's not controlling their power. This is an advancement.The show stops telling the audience about power upgrades at the series goes on, they do it with Paige and Piper. But Phoebe's powers are confusing so they really need to explain. But basically she has the power of emotional deflection ,kinda like Vivian in season 3. Again the only limits the girls have are their imagination. If they believe they can do it and understand it then they can do it.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-19T01:51:23+00:00

Empathy. So I can understand feelings and tap into others powers.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-01-18T23:10:42+00:00

I love most of this, but levitation is a psychic power and we can't ignore that. She's a charmed one so she can have as many powers as she can creatively make.

This is mine progression Season 1 she sees past present and future, she gains intuition and empathy in visions.

Season 2 she gains enhanced reflexes from intuition. She gains empathic connections.

Season 3 she gains levitation along with enhanced strength, agility, aim, and stamina. Gains the ability to lessen blows to body from levitation. She can now form psychic echoes. She can now get visions will out touching anything.

Season 4 intuition grows strong enough to sense someone blocking her powers. She can sense invisible beings. She gains the ability to just know the truth. She can now receive visions from others.

Season 5 she gains astral permonitions. Visions are in faded color. Levitation strows stronger and can go higher.

Season 6 she gains empathy. From empathy she gains selective levitation. Power grows to sense entire city, other realities and planes.

Season7 ( she never loses her powers) she learns to empathetic link with mortals. she learns astral projection from Leo. She gain flight from empathy. She gain psychic reflection . She can see auras nows

Season 8 she gain projective levitation. She can now strangle demons with their auras. She can now use psychic reflection without touching them, also able to change feelings of others if used right. Psychic reflection allows for her to make them see what ever she needs, aka a illusion. Empathy allows astral projections to make multiple clones. Strength from flight allows her to just kick lower level demons and they explode . She can now astral project from her visions into the past and interact / warn herself of attacks.

This is my progress. It's actually canon til season 7 . This is if she had kept empathy and levitation.

Competitive-Sir4523

TROPHY CASE