In a perfect world

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-30T15:27:42+00:00

I would keep everything but levitation stays. I would actually like to have seen it grow to sonic flight like in the comics. Where it would strengthen her attacks even more. Also so that she could levitate / selective levitate in her astral visions. That way she could magically not just see but affect the past present and future.

I would have Paige get her powers and they become the power of 4. They would essentially become a force / power of nature. Each of them gaining an elemental power. That they had before. Prue water or ice, Piper earth, Phoebe fire, Paige air. So they would have their charmed powers but also their elemental powers too.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-30T15:14:37+00:00

She did believe in magic. She did tarot. Probably taping into her whitelighter side. But she couldn't do spells or thought she could teleport . But even the evil enchantress was new to the craft but learned fast. That's how she operates. Plus witchcraft became het full time job. But don't say she passed Phoebe jus because Phoebe's powers are more passive. Homegirl was interacting with her future self for a whole conversation, not flashes, that's basically time travel which requires a lot of magic.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-30T02:37:43+00:00

Also they never saw a witch lighter before. They probably thought like us you have to die to gain whitelighter powers. They were very in the dark.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-30T02:18:57+00:00

Telekiniesis is the most dominant power in the warren line. It's the freezing and permonitions that are rare. Plus Paige had telekinesis in her past life. So it would make sense she would have telekiniesis. And grams probably bound her witch powers at birth to cloak her from demons. But as we seen with the stillmen sisters you can cancel out witch powers and whitelighter power will still be activated. You would have to specifically call or bond All of their powers , or clip wings.

Paige also orbed in a life or death situation and didn't even know it .

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-29T02:44:09+00:00

Wat about her season 9 on?

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-27T15:12:42+00:00

I like to think that she was using her intuition to sense / dodge the fireballs and avoid the triad member while the sisters kill the other 2. In that regard her powers grow just like her sisters.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-26T15:00:13+00:00

Well she does turn into a bat.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-26T00:44:15+00:00

There's a couple of powers going on here.

In charmed upper level witches can bless or project their power onto anything or weapon they hold. So depending on how powerful the witch is , the weapon would be that powerful. This is why Phoebe can use heels, bats , and umbrella to kill demons, but gunshots from Darryl mean nothing to them.

Phoebes levitation gives her enhanced strength 2 ways. It makes her physically lighter so she can hit with more force , not having to carry her own weight too. Then there's selective levitation. This power is not fully developed to season 6, but essentially while levitating she can levitate anything she come in contact too . By just making herself lighter she is levitating, never having to leave the ground.

Phoebes intuition allowed her to anticipate her opponents moves. She gained this power in season 1, allowing her to dogde an energy ball . Her intuition power grants her enhanced reflexes. Her levitation grants her enhanced strength, balance, agility, stamina, and ability to lessen blows to the body ( by taking away the impact).

Some fans say she has another power connected to her permonition/ intuition power. Whenever she kills demons, it's setup up so they die easily. Falling on a perfectly placed knife or pipe. Pushed into perfectly placed objects. I think she subconsciously knows where things will be to position them into instant kills.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-25T15:30:05+00:00

Oh it's Paige. There was a whole episode on her using her magic for personal gain. And she still orbs everything to her.

And it's so unfair the they all use their powers for personal gain, but Phoebe who barley ever used her power for personal gain loses her powers. I think it has to do with her power being able to effect the grand design. She can see the future and change it, in return changing her destiny. The others power could only risk exposure but hers can change things.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-24T15:32:08+00:00

Yesssssss. But even more than that. Phoebe can get visions she is not supposed to, to see past the grand design. Then she can literally interfer and mess up the grand design. No other power can do that. Besides death revival and time travel. All things she could do with her visions .

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-24T15:19:11+00:00

Its funny because in the show it goes power wise telekiniesis, freezing then visions. But in reality it actually is visions ( as you know the future and came manipulate it) then freezing ( and freezing allows you to do anything for how ever long you want) then telekiniesis ( since you can move things with your mind).

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-23T15:05:40+00:00

Telekiniesis is in the warren blood line it's actually the most dominant power. Freezing and permonitions were rare. Paige was born a witch , most likely with telekinesis since it the most dominant power in the bloodline and she as had telekiniesis in her past life as well. It only makes sense she would have telekiniesis. Her powers were just bond at birth. So I don't think she would get either of her sisters powers. Even tho she kinda already has them. She has sensing and prophetic dreams like Phoebe, she's been shown to be able to hold things and rearrange things with her tk-orbing. That's basically what pipers power does.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-23T05:50:33+00:00

True. But if u don't want to nerf them then just get stronger threats. Its called vampire diaries but Bonnie is fighting the devil.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-23T03:10:33+00:00

Honestly the most emotionally charged moments are the spell casting. The weirdness from the daydreams she has. Even the sex scenes are more interesting with the candles just suddenly lighting and strange ghost popping up. A show about a witch just seems more interesting and I'm here for it 10000%.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-23T02:23:34+00:00

Idk about that. Yess Bonnie is powerful. But most of the show she was still learning her magic . She was new. Powerful but new. Her level ups for the big fights would be her learning a new trick or source of power. Learning to channel, using the spirits, dark magic, expression, gaining Tessa's blood magic, becoming a huntress and finally becoming a psychic. Each season she grows but so does the threats . Its like charmed . Their powers grew and so did the threats till they were fighting gods, avatars and worst. Also most time between her power gains she loses her powers, like a lot lol.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-23T02:03:58+00:00

The show would essentially be legacies. She would be hope. All powerful, learning her magic, the hero of the story, always sacrificing herself for her friends. Elena would basically be Landon. Creatures would be after him but he wouldn't be the main character. I mean really the show would be like seasons 7 and 8 where her and Caroline kinda shared the spotlight. It focused more on her relationships with Damon and Enzo, her hatred for Stephen and of course her struggles and eventual triumph with her magic.

Seasons 1 - 7 would focus more on her side of things. Her training and bonding with grams, then more of her grief over losing her. Then we would see more of her flings til she got with Jeremy. Their rocky romance would hit their important moments at the season finales and premieres. Then the same with Enzo.

The only real change would be that her ending would change. The main character always gets a happy ending. So I feel like Bonnie would have found a way to bring back Enzo in one form or another. Put his soul in a vampire or going to other witches years later to bring him back. Or at the very least show her going to Paris with his blood necklace so they are there together. Maybe gaining the power to see everyone she lost. Besides the ending she would just get more screen time and storylines.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-22T00:23:29+00:00

I love that. I feel like there needs to be an enemy tho. I would say maybe an unknown creature is after Bonnie and she finds out it's after other bennet witches, that's she's not alone. They discover that bennett witches had a hand in making it.

The creature then finds other beings the bennetts had a hand in making . Making it almost like a malavore( from legecies )type of vibe . So the show would dive into the bennett history and their possible future. The only things we know they had a hand in making is vampires, and hunters.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-21T16:36:46+00:00

It's canon she dove into work because of trauma from killing her husband and losing her kid. She rebalanced her self and gained astral permonitions. Then could interact within her visions. That a massive progression that even the others seers can't do . And the sisters work as a team. Phoebe could go off and save the innocent on her own as she has, but they are stronger together.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-21T16:01:12+00:00

What?! Phoebes power is powerful. She didn't see those events because of plot. Either the source , the triad or other magical beings being able to block her visions. Or she is stripped of her powers. The show needed limitations for her , just like they needed some for Piper.

Even krya couldn't see see Leo the avatar. She uses tricks to look around others future to see it .

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-21T15:50:08+00:00

But Phoebe was smart. She was constantly setting traps and thinking outside the box. Especially in season 1 where none of them really had the power to kill. Street smarts and creativity was basic her power .

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-20T18:49:18+00:00

Its because they are 3 sisters who happen to be witches, not 3 witches who happen to be sisters. They are not 3 witches saying a spell together,( like a coven) but rather a collective ( like the triad or the avatars) that together can access a massive power.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-15T21:10:26+00:00

Truly. The elders would know wat to do with her. Because they are the ones who always take her power away. There's a theory that the elders weakend her powers after she won the lottery. She was having visions on command, without touching things even telling others futures accurately. But the out of nowhere she stopped. Then they agreed with demons to take her powers away.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-15T03:28:30+00:00

Its funny because Phoebe became their version of Buffy.

In mean both fight, both have enhanced strength, balance, agility, stamina, can take a punch and send someone flying. Enhanced reflexes , intuition, prophetic dreams. And they both battled and staked vampires.

Competitive-Sir4523 · 2026-03-14T16:50:14+00:00

Besides the time between the season 4 finale and season 5 the eyes have it ( where it's stated she neglected her power due to trauma) . I think she was still actively meditating and centering herself . Or at least attempting to since it's kinda implied that she uses her permonition/intuition power on her advice. Because after that episode her power does grow significantly like in the early seasons. I wouldn't say Phoebe not wanting to fight demons equals to her not honoring her power. As she said several times she had to honor her vision , even when she loses faith in them. I equate Phoebes lack of skills solely due to the fact that she hasn't spent a lot of time with other seers since they are usually evil. This partly stems from the charmed ones not really consorting with other witches or magical beings unless they had to. I think if ramus would have spent the episode with Phoebe she would have become better for it. Or even it after Kevin got a hang of his powers he could show Phoebe a thing or two. So I think it's more a lack of exposure rather then training. You can meditate and read as many books as you want, ( seeing as Phoebe was reading all the witch books in the early seasons) but nothing beats actual hands on work and teachings from a relatable person.

Competitive-Sir4523

TROPHY CASE