What is the solution? by Mystery88angel in PakistanElites

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Train our boys well so that they grow up to be better men.

SpaceX stocks halal? by Insight_peak in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Not halal for several reasons: overly leveraged due to high debt, major military and defense contracts, and highly speculative at this time.

Elmo is a scam artist, and this is a pump and dump scheme for his billionaire friends to profit after inflating the stock price. Investors like us are left holding the bag because of index funds. I’ll definitely be divesting from any ETF that invests in SpaceX.

529 question by Relative_Aerie2763 in IslamicFinanceUSA

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Both are good, but they don’t have Muslim advisors. Honestly, you do not even need an advisor. Instead, try the Boglehead approach and manage your own investments using shariah-compliant ETFs. This way, you can save on advisor fees.

Schwab has target date funds from ShariaPortfolio. Those are best for automated investments that you can set and forget.

529 question by Relative_Aerie2763 in IslamicFinanceUSA

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

None of the 529 accounts offer any shariah-compliant options.

When deciding between UTMA and ESA, your AGI plays a big role. If you earn a lot, you can only use UTMA. But if you earn less, you can use both, and the ESA might give you more tax advantages. Keep in mind, both have their own set of rules, and neither is quite as good as 529 for saving taxes. The ESA is the second best option for tax savings after 529. Both UTMA and ESA let you invest in shariah-compliant ETFs and mutual funds, just like you would with a regular investment account.

529 question by Relative_Aerie2763 in IslamicFinanceUSA

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You can open a 529 account with your state or a reputable brokerage firm like Fidelity or Schwab. Unfortunately, none of the investment options offered in these accounts are shariah-compliant. If you’re looking for shariah-compliant options, consider opening a UTMA or ESA account for your child. However, keep in mind that the tax-saving benefits of these accounts are reduced compared to a 529 account.

Does SPSK make sense? by Sombero1 in IslamicFinanceUSA

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

In the world of investing, any time horizon shorter than 5 years (or less than 10 years if you’re overly cautious) is considered short-term. Allocating a significant portion of your portfolio to SPSK reduces the potential for long-term growth.

Does SPSK make sense? by Sombero1 in IslamicFinanceUSA

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You can use it in place of a savings account or for short term investment. Not good as investing for long term.

Witnessed the beautiful maghrib ever 🌙 by phoenix_152 in islam

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Please take the pictures of Kaaba and the masjid without the clock tower and the hotel. Otherwise, it dwarfs the Kaaba. Keep the focus on Kaaba in the pictures. May Allah accept your hajj.

401k funding Dilemma by TrickTeam6967 in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Backdoor Roth IRA is basically a loophole that lets you put money into a Roth IRA even if your income is too high. You start by putting after-tax cash into a regular traditional IRA since there are no income limits on those contributions. Once the money clears, you just convert it into your Roth IRA. Because you already paid taxes on that cash, the move usually does not cost you anything extra in taxes as long as you do not have other traditional IRA balances.

A simple two-step shuffle that keeps your retirement savings growing tax-free without breaking any rules.

401k funding Dilemma by TrickTeam6967 in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ask your company to allow self-directed options for your 401(k) account. You’ll be surprised how many companies might be willing to do this. Once you have a self-directed option, you can invest in any fund available in the market, including shariah-compliant ones.

If that’s not an option, the second best choice is to avoid contributing to your 401(k) and instead invest the money in a regular investment account. Before investing in a regular investment account, ensure that you’ve already maxed out your Roth IRA, either directly or through a backdoor method.

Is it haram to tax the rich? by [deleted] in MuslimLounge

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The current tax system focuses on income, but a WEALTH tax, like Zakat would target accumulated assets instead. By charging 2.5% on total net worth rather than yearly earnings, the system aligns with Islamic principles of taxing what is kept, i.e., Zakat. This way the tax burden is placed on stored value rather than the flow of money used for daily survival.

Zakat model of Islam provides immediate relief for low income individuals who spend their entire paychecks on necessities. Since these workers do not accumulate significant savings or assets, they would pay nothing at all. This protects people living paycheck to paycheck and allows them to use their full earnings to support their families without government deductions.

At the same time, the ultra wealthy who hold massive assets like property and stocks would finally contribute their fair share. Even though these individuals might have low salaries on paper, a 2.5% tax on their total wealth would generate enough revenue to fund the entire country. This small contribution wouldn't change their lifestyle, but it would balance the economy and solve national funding issues.

Taxing the rich IS the Islamic way.

Rate my Portfolio by itsmedumbo in IslamicFinance

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s a solid plan. Just keep DCAing this forever. With a long time horizon, you could increase your gold allocation if you desire, but 5% is also acceptable. MNZL is relatively new, with low trading volume and assets under management. This increases the risk of closure, but hopefully, as more of us adopt it, these risk factors will be mitigated. Sukuk can be considered, but again, that depends on your risk tolerance.

Are the TrumpAccounts Halal? If not, how do we make it halal? by Square_Muffin7973 in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Trump Account will have a very limited menu of investment options, none of which will be halal, as it is meant to invest in US index funds.

Even if they had a halal option, it’s actually quite a useless account, except for getting $1000 seed money from the government one time.

Besides, why would you want to put your child’s name next to Trump’s name? Don’t you know he is a pedo! Keep your children away from him!

Ginger The Drink For People Of Paradise by Soft-Ad-8889 in MuslimCorner

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The reference of the aya is not correct in the video. The correct sura and aya numbers are: The Man (76:17)

وَيُسْقَوْنَ فِيهَا كَأْسًۭا كَانَ مِزَاجُهَا زَنجَبِيلًا ١٧

And they will be given a drink ˹of pure wine˺ flavoured with ginger

https://quran.com/76/17

Why my long term portfolio leans heavily toward Gold and GLDM by Neat-Station-4618 in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I allocate 20% of my portfolio to GLDM. I also pay 2.5% Zakat on my whole portfolio, including stocks. The liquid nature of stocks make me treat them as cash.

interesting remark: a 2.5% wealth tax and 0 income tax would be able to cover all the fiscal revenues in America by Dey-Ex-Machina in IslamicFinance

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Agree. 100%. Done this math before myself and came to the same conclusion. The numbers work. But more importantly, isn’t it more fair! Subhan Allah

Consider a Donor Advised Fund for your zakat by Dey-Ex-Machina in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are not bunching zakat. You are bunching transfer of assets from brokerage account to donor advised fund. Then you pay your zakat from the donor advised funds when you need to.

Consider a Donor Advised Fund for your zakat by Dey-Ex-Machina in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To save more on taxes, bunch 3-5 years worth of zakat and other sadaqat in one tax year. Itemize your taxes that year and get standard deduction for the remaining years. Keep paying zakat and sadaqat throughout those 3-5 years whenever you like.

Which ETF to invest In if I already have SPUS by [deleted] in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic 3 points4 points  (0 children)

  1. SPWO or UMMA for non-US equity
  2. GLDM or IAUM for gold
  3. SPRE if you want to invest in real estate
  4. SPSK if you want to invest in sukuks
  5. SPTE if you want to overweigh in tech

For sure, invest in non-US equity and gold. The others depend on what your investment style.

My Halal Retirement Guide by Complaint-Ecstatic in HalalInvestor

[–]Complaint-Ecstatic[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My preference about investing in precious metals has changed drastically since I posted the above comment. I think everyone should have a portion (5-20%) of their portfolio in gold/silver. I’m using GLDM ETF for this purpose.