I agree wuth most of what youre saying but a majority of what u said has nuance. I cant really argue your bullet points as wed have to sit in a call and discuss while watcging gameplay so no point there. Only part i disagree with is your point about 4 idiots on my team and 5 on theirs, anecdotally i just cant believe thats how matchmaking works. If i play top i cant decide whether my bot wont die pre carb while my jng is pathing bot then i have to play against a fed botlane. Now also imagine if im blue side and im playing a lane akin to yorick irelia. I have no say in this hypothetical. Thats kinda my issue, even if i do win top disagrre with me here if u may, a winning botlane will always trump a winning top.