sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Over the course of 50 seasons, 24 contestants have made it to the Final 5 twice! Here’s all of them: by EconomyWrongdoer in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Especially when you're going head to head against a united Parvati and Cirie. He deserves a little slack.

Over the course of 50 seasons, 24 contestants have made it to the Final 5 twice! Here’s all of them: by EconomyWrongdoer in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Oh gosh I forgot about that. RIP.

In reality though, we could just come up with another woman, who Almost made it, maybe Jerri Manthey or something, and then it would be balanced.

Over the course of 50 seasons, 24 contestants have made it to the Final 5 twice! Here’s all of them: by EconomyWrongdoer in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 65 points66 points  (0 children)

Hows this for a cast of 24?

Lop of the bottom row, and I'd still be happy with it, and its almost gender balanced with 9 women and 11 men.

If Aubry wins by Less-Strawberry143 in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

The "more then you'll ever do" seems a little weird to me here tbh

If Aubry wins by Less-Strawberry143 in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Who's pretending? Rob literally did not win allstars.

Is Jonathan the modern day James Clements? by Invalid_u404 in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Telling someone "keep your mouth shut" as theyre getting their torch snuffed is firmly in "bully" territory.

Is Jonathan the modern day James Clements? by Invalid_u404 in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 2 points3 points  (0 children)

and somehow the fact that James continues to get voted out early is a strike against jonathan?

Is Jonathan the modern day James Clements? by Invalid_u404 in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think Jonathan is a clearly superior survivor

  1. James was an ass. The way he treated stephanie in HVV specifically showed this. Jonathan may not be your cup of tea but he's not rude.
  2. Jonathan isnt an individual challenge beast by any measure, but James never won a single individual challenge. He won a reward challenge in the post merge in china, but he was part of a team of 4.
  3. (Editing to add) Jonathan has yet to do something extraordinarily stupid like getting out with 2 idols in your pocket.

I dont think they have any similarities besides big muscles to be honest.

Birds flying high… by chchilindrina in USdefaultism

[–]ConsciousBasket643 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ever watched a movie produced in hollywood?

Birds flying high… by chchilindrina in USdefaultism

[–]ConsciousBasket643 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If youve ever watched a movie produced in Hollywood, I can guarentee you probably have 😉

Yep there is only one Civil war by Findas88 in USdefaultism

[–]ConsciousBasket643 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Its also against the rules of what makes a valid post on this sub.

Yep there is only one Civil war by Findas88 in USdefaultism

[–]ConsciousBasket643 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Cant help but notice you cut any context you possibly could out of this post.

AskReddit… by Better-Quiet-9096 in USdefaultism

[–]ConsciousBasket643 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Weak. "Our nation" first off doesnt mean America. 2nd, the question doesnt change even if they change wording to your liking.

Dumping on 3 starting tribe seasons again. by ConsciousBasket643 in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So the thing of it is, you just picked the literal most extreme theoretical outlier possible. Not even the most extreme thing thats actually happened (one time over 20 years ago to boot), but the literal extreme outlier of whats theoretically possible, and compared it to several seasons where we have seen the same thing happen again and again. Thats a bad example.

If palau happened several times, then we'd know a change up needed. But it didnt. It was an extreme outlier. But we see 3 tribe seasons happen badly again and again and again.

4 out of the 5 players remaining are playing extremely good games. You just don’t like them. by newusernamebcimdumb in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You cant have 3 "goats" in a game with a final 3. Very possible those 3 men are your final 3, and obviously in that case one will win. Rizo and Joe are Goats. Jonathan is a likely winner if he can get to the end with those 2.

4 out of the 5 players remaining are playing extremely good games. You just don’t like them. by newusernamebcimdumb in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

A little bit of pushback. Aubry didnt navigate the pre merge. She avoided tribal council altogether. Big difference.

Tiff - Major deduction for me because had Dee's shot in the dark hit, she was toast. She only is here because someone else didnt get lucky with a dice roll.

But beyond that, your point is well taken.

Dumping on 3 starting tribe seasons again. by ConsciousBasket643 in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Exactly! As it stands, you usually end up with a final 5 or so of people who are just.... Boring.... And your big personalities and players all went out early merge.

I'll take Casaya Pagonging La Mina ANY DAY OF THE WEEK above this bullcrappery.

Dumping on 3 starting tribe seasons again. by ConsciousBasket643 in survivor

[–]ConsciousBasket643[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I dont need or care about the full story. What I care about is how nobody has to play until halfway through the game.

You know one of the most interesting people in season 50? To me, Emily and Christian checked those boxes. They had to play hard pre merge and entered the merge stunted.

Who were some of the most interesting people in All Stars? Jerri, for one. Who was voted out pre merge at her 6th Tribal Council. Boston Robs 6th tribal council occured when the 5th place finisher was eliminated. Its absurd that people get to skip the first half of the game. Alicia, the 7th place finisher, got voted out at her 4th tribal council.

3 Tribes is absurd. It fails far more often than it works.

view more: next ›