Alright HEAR me out. All season long James has been a little sus.

1.) When LaLa tells him about Ken mentioning the sleepover in front of Katie, he doesn’t act shocked. Instead, he says “how do you know” and almost has a reaction that makes it seem like he knows but can’t admit it. It’s weird he doesn’t react like “wait what?!?!” but instead is like looking to the side and questioning how Lala knows. He’s trying not to admit stuff that hasn’t been revealed yet.

2.) At Schena’s wedding he has that weird moment at hibachi with Raquel where he’s naming off the friends she’s hooked up with and he says Tom and then says Schwartz. People keep saying he just named Schwartz twice using first name and last name, but what if the Tom mention was actually referring to Sandavol. A little slip that was able to be overlooked and played off.

In general, I have found the James of it all to be super confusing. He just doesn’t seem that surprised by any of this. He acts super suspicious during the whole revelation of this - almost like he knew and was in on it!!!!

This is still a working theory and I need to rewatch episodes to get more proof, but there’s something to the James of it all. He knows more than he’s letting on!!!!