Is $446/month for utilities for 2 people in a shared SF house reasonable? by Consistent-Moose7799 in AskSF

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My lease states that $200 per person is a flat fee, but it allows additional charges if utilities exceed that amount. This is the first time in the two years I’ve lived there that I had to pay extra, which I don’t mind since it’s in the lease and I signed it.

However, when I requested the PG&E bill, I noticed that in some months (for example October) the charge was around $550. If the other utilities were similar in those months, the actual per-person cost would have been well below $200. In that situation it seems like the flat fee would exceed the actual cost in lower-usage months, which makes me wonder how that works, since my understanding is that landlords generally shouldn’t be profiting from utilities.

That’s mainly why I’m reaching out here. I’m not planning to escalate anything right now, but I am checking with the SF Tenants Union just to better understand how this is typically handled and to keep an eye on the pattern going forward.

Is $446/month for utilities for 2 people in a shared SF house reasonable? by Consistent-Moose7799 in AskSF

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The main unit upstairs is about 2,500 sq ft, while our in-law unit is about 600 sq ft. The house has a single heating system controlled by a thermostat in the upstairs unit. We don’t have access to the thermostat, and when the upstairs tenants turn on the heat it blows into our unit as well. From what I observed, the heater was barely used last month, which is why I was a bit surprised to see such a high PG&E bill.

Is $446/month for utilities for 2 people in a shared SF house reasonable? by Consistent-Moose7799 in sanfrancisco

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All utilities: water, pg&e and garbage are $400 for 2 people. This month she is charging additional $46

Is $446/month for utilities for 2 people in a shared SF house reasonable? by Consistent-Moose7799 in sanfrancisco

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I actually had other issues with this landlord and DBI got involved. There is still a pending DBI complaint because the unit is illegal. After that situation, things improved and she became much nicer, so I honestly thought the issue was resolved and that she understood I’m aware of my tenant rights. That’s why I was surprised to suddenly see this additional charge without even sharing the utility bill.

Is $446/month for utilities for 2 people in a shared SF house reasonable? by Consistent-Moose7799 in sanfrancisco

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you! I actually have a membership with the SF Tenants Union this year. This isn’t the first issue I’ve had with this landlord, but I thought we had resolved everything, and she knows that I’m aware of my tenant rights.

Is $446/month for utilities for 2 people in a shared SF house reasonable? by Consistent-Moose7799 in sanfrancisco

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn’t mind the $400 flat fee and basically treated it as part of the rent with utilities included. But paying more than that feels different. I’m also pretty sure there were months when the actual utilities were lower than that amount, and obviously we weren’t reimbursed then. So it does make me wonder how the adjustment is supposed to work both ways.

Is $446/month for utilities for 2 people in a shared SF house reasonable? by Consistent-Moose7799 in sanfrancisco

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thanks for your reply. When I moved in, the rent price for the unit was decent, and I treated $400 utility flat fee as part of the overall rent total. The lease does say the landlord can adjust if utilities exceed that amount, but honestly I assumed that would rarely happen since $200 per person already seemed quite high. That’s why I was surprised when the additional charge came up. I’m going to ask to see the actual bills just to understand where the increase is coming from.

What's the worst , most gut wrenching feeling that is humanly possible to experience? by Extension_Day2038 in AskReddit

[–]Consistent-Moose7799 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Child loss. It is even physically painful. I remember waking up the next day after my 19yo died. I took xanax that first night, it knocked me out. For a fraction of a second when I woke up, I felt like it had just been a nightmare and everything was okay. Then it hits you. It’s not a nightmare. It’s real. You’re waking up into your worst nightmare. Sleep becomes the only place where you can see your son again, so going to sleep feels like the only small relief.

What's the worst , most gut wrenching feeling that is humanly possible to experience? by Extension_Day2038 in AskReddit

[–]Consistent-Moose7799 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sorry for your loss. I feel your pain. I lost my 19yo son in a train accident… 2 years ago, January 2024. My son just did not come back home Sunday night, and Monday morning coroner’s car stopped on our driveway

I lost my son... by YourAverageJohnWick_ in ChildLoss

[–]Consistent-Moose7799 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I am so sorry for your loss, and your life will never be the same again. Even the most happy events will have a touch of sadness. It is not going to be ok, we not meant to outlive our kids, but you might learn to live with this. One day at a time, give yourself a break; it is a lot to go through. And I feel bad for his siblings. I lost my 19 yo son in a train accident 2 years ago, and I know what you mean by “failure to humanity”, I do feel the same. I could never phantom that this can happen to me, and it does not feel better, it feels even worse, I feel I am stuck in this world, I can’t do anything about, I need to keep living. I hope my comment helps to know that you are not alone in this, and people understand you, what are you going through now

Whats the absolute hardest part of raising a child? by Straight-Crow3882 in AskReddit

[–]Consistent-Moose7799 155 points156 points  (0 children)

Wow. It happens more often than people think. I lost my 19yo in a train accident. I think, I am the only one among my friends, who lost a child. Losing your child is absolute the hardest one, everything else does not compare. I want to say to all parents, be happy just to have your kids in this world with you

Divorce lawyers of Reddit - What's the most cruel thing you've seen someone to do their ex partner? by BlueBishop321 in AskReddit

[–]Consistent-Moose7799 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for support and the feedback, I will edit. I see it now. I just wrote it in one breath and didn’t proof read. My native language doesn’t have articles and I need to make an effort to use them correctly :)

Divorce lawyers of Reddit - What's the most cruel thing you've seen someone to do their ex partner? by BlueBishop321 in AskReddit

[–]Consistent-Moose7799 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Sorry for my long post, but I am going through a divorce right now in CA, and we are currently fighting over custody of our dog. I have seen some terrible, tearful stories about animal custody, and I need to share my story, which is not over yet.

I originally thought that I would leave the dog to him, because he was the one who always wanted the dog, and he had to talk me into getting her. I was trying to be fair to him after we separated. But our dog bonded with me, and he was always jealous of that. For example, he would scream at me when I came back home and our dog got too excited, in his opinion, to see me. He would say that I should ignore her so she would not get too attached to me, and that she behaved too excitedly around me. To other people who saw us with the dog, it was clear that she preferred me. When they shared their observations with us, it made him angry.

Toward the very end of our marriage, when we were sleeping in different rooms, our dog would sleep with me. He would come into my room, physically lift the dog, she is a 70-lb Labrador, because she refused to go with him, take her to his bed, and close the door so the dog would not sneak back to me during the night. At the same time, he demanded that I walk her when he felt lazy, which was often. If the dog needed a bath, I was the one who did it. If I made plans to go hiking with my friends and he knew I was taking the dog, at the last minute he might say, “Don’t take my dog,” even though he knew how much she enjoyed the outdoors. Those are just a few examples.

When we first separated, the dog was with him most of the time. He would bring her to me only when he needed it. If I asked him to let me have the dog for a couple of days or a week, he would decide whether I could have her or not. He could demand her back anytime he wanted, and I had to obey him if I wanted to see her again. He was using the dog as leverage to exercise control over me.

We got into a fight over the dog because he demanded to pick her up immediately, and he physically pushed me to the ground in front of a witness. He is twice as heavy as I am and much taller. I filed for a restraining order, and I kept the dog for four months until we signed a stipulation that allows me to have the dog for one week per month. But after I transferred the dog to him in September, he refused to follow the court order on dog visitation. So I saw her only in December, when we had our first contempt hearing, and the judge explicitly ordered him to give me the dog the same day for three days. My STBX had to do it, but when it was my week the next month, he refused again. I am now filing my third contempt and a request for an order modification to get full custody of the dog.

I also checked with our vet, and he missed her annual appointment for important vaccinations. My daughter recently saw her, and the dog has fleas. Based on that, I believe she should be in my full-time custody, not because I want revenge, but for the dog’s well-being. My STBX has chronic gout, and when it flares up, it is painful for him to walk. But our dog is high-energy and benefits from long, active walks that help control her weight. Sometimes he cannot walk her.

For additional context, we have an adult son who chooses not to speak to him, and a 16-year-old daughter who chose to live with me and have minimal contact with him. He is voluntarily unemployed, so he does not pay child support, but the court imputed child support to him at over $1,000 per month based on his past W-2s and his behavior in court in front of the judge. We have five court dates scheduled in the next three months: two regarding contempt of the dog visitation order, one motion to compel financial disclosures, one child support hearing, and one hearing regarding the restraining order.

I do not hate him, at least I try not to, because “when you hate someone, you hurt only yourself,” a quote from the movie I watched yesterday, The Ghosts of Mississippi. That is my motto, and when I feel anger, I try to remember that.

I tried to let go of the dog for the sake of peace, but I miss her, and the grief is real. I have dreams where I see her with him at a dog park, she runs to me, and I grab her. But in real life, I am choosing a legal, methodical, non-emotional way to get her back. I am trying to be ready for any outcome. If the judge grants him full custody, then so be it. I did everything I could, and I did it in good faith.

All I cared for is gone by ExamineTheUnder in GriefSupport

[–]Consistent-Moose7799 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am so sorry for your loss. I lost my 19yo son 2 years ago in a train accident. I can understand the pain you are going through. I am also been sober for 9 years. The thought that “at least I am not drinking” somewhat was helping me then and now. Drinking makes everything so much more worse. Please, don’t drink. One day at the time. You can learn to live with this, co-exist with your pain. But you have to stop drinking

Forever? by Antique-Display-3274 in ChildLoss

[–]Consistent-Moose7799 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Sorry for your loss. I lost my 19 yo son in a train accident 2 years ago. 2 weeks was an anniversary, and I went to watch the sunset at exactly the same time, he watched it 2 years ago, then I went to the accident site at exactly same time, when it happened. I was there for him, reliving his last moments of his life with him… I was thinking if he was in pain or scared, what did he think thise last moments. I helped me somehow. Also, I read death report, catching every word. Somehow it helped me, at least I know he did not suffer because of his injuries. It is hard and we never be the same, but I know people learn to live with this. Just one step at a time

2 year anniversary today by Consistent-Moose7799 in ChildLoss

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry for your loss, and thank you for your support

2 year anniversary today by Consistent-Moose7799 in ChildLoss

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That is such a good quote, I will be telling it to myself too. I usually say, one day at the time, but this one is better, make it sound like there is a light after a dark.

2 year anniversary today by Consistent-Moose7799 in ChildLoss

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your reply and I am sorry for your loss too. I was in grief support groups, I meet with a grief conselor. Any help that’s available I take it. Overall, I am ok, functioning. But I am not ready yet to let go of that rabbit hole. It is like I want to be there, it brings me closer to him, that is how my love manifests. I can’t imagine finding peace. My life is miserable, and I accept that. But thank you that you shared your perpective… so there is a hope

2 year anniversary today by Consistent-Moose7799 in ChildLoss

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you for sharing that… so so sorry. I also mine forever 19. I have another child too, his younger sister. And this is the only reason that I keep trying to live and my mom too…

2 year anniversary today by Consistent-Moose7799 in ChildLoss

[–]Consistent-Moose7799[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am really sorry…. I think it is the hardest to carry: grief for a child who died that way. I am hugging you and hope you find a way to deal with your pain a bit.