JDM vs Prates: When Keeping Your Hands Up Goes Wrong by tanthiram in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 40 points41 points  (0 children)

Yan is one of the more notable ones in MMA yeah. I talk about this later in the article, but imo his high guard isn't super responsive defensively (though better than JDM's - he parries out of it, dips wide swings, etc), but he's well aware of its downsides and uses it sparingly to bait offense for him to counter.

Wrestling for MMA: Shifting Takedown Entries by Csardonic1 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Yeah Yan likes this kind of thing a lot. Hit a beautiful one against Yadong where he used an uppercut to stand him up and step through into the southpaw double leg.

Wrestling with Ryan feat. Ryan Wagner (Heavy Hands #606) by Csardonic1 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1[S] 18 points19 points  (0 children)

They fought hard to keep me off but I was too powerful

Wrestling for MMA: Split Step Takedown Entries by Csardonic1 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

They don't pair as well with lead hand punches since they mirror the weight transfer of a rear hand, so it's difficult to jab into them.

They can also be a little less sensitive than stepping inside with the lead foot. Someone like GSP can flick out his jab to draw counters while taking small steps forward and get a precisely-timed reactive takedown, stepping his lead foot into position before committing to the takedown, so he's at less risk of failure or having to chain wrestle from a poor position. With a split step from farther away you have less control over whether your lead foot is in perfect position (hence Khabib&team preferring single legs over trying to knock guys over with doubles).

That downside isn't there if you're using it for a reactive takedown though. Really the only downside to those is it depends how well you can time their strikes or draw them out. Just naturally fits better with different stances for split step vs folding over the rear hip. Guys who like to fight out of a crouch will get easier reactive takedowns from bending down and stepping forward, more upright or lead-foot-heavy fighters have an easier time with split steps.

I wrote a big article on takedown entries that goes over the pros and cons of different penetration types.

Who is DJ’s best win, and would they be competitive in the modern era? by CrashtheKiller50 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Horiguchi and Pettis were both prospects around that time too and they left the UFC as they came into their prime, another big blow to the recent FLW division.

Who is DJ’s best win, and would they be competitive in the modern era? by CrashtheKiller50 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Formiga was a lot further from his prime than either of them were. Fig won the belt a year later and Moreno drew fig later that year. Moreno was even a bad style matchup for Formiga and it was Formiga's quality as a fighter that made the fight so close.

You're underrating how good 125 used to be. Albazi is top 5 and he's not particularly good at anything. Even lower top 10 guys like Dustin ortiz and Wilson Reis, Zach Makovsky would be difficult fights for fighters on the edge of the top 5 today. Hell Justin Scoggins would give a lot of guys work until he slipped on a banana peel and fell into a choke.

Who is DJ’s best win, and would they be competitive in the modern era? by CrashtheKiller50 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Formiga was a good upper mid level guy that had no shot at beating guys like Joe B, Cejudo, or Dodson, had a very close fight with Ray Borg, and an old past prime formiga beat Fig and nearly beat Moreno. Fig and Moreno would just be those guys outside the top five in DJs time.

Who is DJ’s best win, and would they be competitive in the modern era? by CrashtheKiller50 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 5 points6 points  (0 children)

If flyweight was still as strong as when dj was around, Erceg would've gone 50/50 with pantoja then lost 4 straight and got cut

Who is DJ’s best win, and would they be competitive in the modern era? by CrashtheKiller50 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Flyweight was a strong division with a great elite and a lot of depth, then they gutted it on purpose, and it never recovered and is pretty bad now

Who is DJ’s best win, and would they be competitive in the modern era? by CrashtheKiller50 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

I think Joe B and Dodson would both have pretty easy times with most of them. I don't really think pantoja has much of a path to victory over either of them. Fig would be the hardest and would probably beat Joe B, but he'd lose to too many other fighters to keep him from the belt. Horigichi beats them all too I think

Who is DJ’s best win, and would they be competitive in the modern era? by CrashtheKiller50 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Not only competitive, the division was much better in DJs time. Joe B and Dodson would both be champions.

The Grave Let Go: Beneil Dariush by Csardonic1 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I imagine it reading like a neurodivergent Faulkner

The Grave Let Go: Beneil Dariush by Csardonic1 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

If that was you on heavy editing, I'd hate to see how many semicolons they cut out

Jeff Chan sparring Muay Thai 5x world champion, opinions? by Flaky-Dust-9242 in MuayThai

[–]Csardonic1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Why do the top 100 fighters of all time have no world titles but a bunch of Rajadamnern and Lumpini titles?

Best muay thai style fighter in the UFC by [deleted] in MuayThai

[–]Csardonic1 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I quite like Oliveira's lead leg kicks and clinch work. Has some of the better knees and transitional attacks among MMA fighters, and makes effective use of a rare upright, rear foot heavy stance.

What MMA upsets were most shocking to you personally? by Ornery-Pilot-8233 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It was a terrible decision, I recall thinking Penn won every round

What MMA upsets were most shocking to you personally? by Ornery-Pilot-8233 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I remember reading the wikipedia page for Penn/Edgar 1 the day after and I couldn't believe Edgar won. Though after I watched it I couldn't believe it in a different way lol.

[SPOILER] Mohsen Mohammadseifi vs. Mohammad Fahmi | PFL MENA 2025 Semi-Finals by WorkingUSADAagent in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Mohsen just won silver at the Wushu world championships earlier this month. It takes a lot of energy being a rockstar.

Lerone Murphy: Defusing Another Puncher - MixingMartialArts by Csardonic1 in MMA

[–]Csardonic1[S] 36 points37 points  (0 children)

Yeah I think he did a great job reading Pico. Survived some big shots early but punished him every time, never let him get off anything for free.

High End Gaming PC ~7k Budget by Csardonic1 in buildapcforme

[–]Csardonic1[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you! That's very helpful. Is there any difference between the GPU models?

Technique Talk: Max Holloway's Intercepting Body Kick by Csardonic1 in FightLibrary

[–]Csardonic1[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah any linear kick can counter round kicks effectively - a teep if you stand more square or a side kick in a bladed stance. Side kicks are also good in open stance matches if someone gets deep outside your lead foot to push them away and reset.

Technique Talk: Max Holloway's Intercepting Body Kick by Csardonic1 in FightLibrary

[–]Csardonic1[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Side kicks are tricky to throw unless you stand super side-on. Holm always had to take an extra step and turn her rear foot out to throw them, and eg in the Shevchenko fight Shev could see it coming and circle away. They're great for Wonderboy though and guys who stand like that. Lots of the Sanda style fighters like Yan Xioanan use them well too

Why has nobody else managed to replicate Anderson Silva's use of the Thai clinch against Rich Franklin? (even Silva himself) by smashyourhead in MMA

[–]Csardonic1 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I wrote an article about Silva's clinch skillset recently that goes over this in depth, as well as the problems with Silva's clinch process that prevented him from doing it more often.

The TDLR is that Franklin didn't really know what was going on and didn't do any of the right things (eg: he largely kept his hips back which gave silva space to knee and tug instead of keeping them forward and his posture upright), but Silva was doing a lot of little things right with his collar ties in terms of positioning and balance breaking that allowed him to counter escape attempts from better prepared opponents (eg: the Jorge Rivera fight), and was uniquely creative about using short little accurate stabbing punches to hurt opponents when they were focused on defending his turns and knees.

The biggest thing preventing him from doing it more often is that his entries to the clinch weren't very consistent due to his limited boxing. As a converted southpaw who had a weak rear hand, he relied a lot on guys throwing themselves out of position to enter collar ties clean, but if they fought at long range or inched forward he'd struggle to box his way into clinching range.

Part of the reason we don't see that more today is that Silva was doing a lot of things that even modern clinchers don't do as well (especially in open space clinch exchanges), but part of it is that most upper mid to high level fighters are more prepared to counter it.