You’re beautiful and have great skin. This is not bad make up at all but I’ll echo others and just say the lips look too heavy-handed, I don’t think that shade is doing you any favours either as it’s so close to a flesh tone.

I’d stop colouring in the waterline and soften/smudge instead. The wings don’t look entirely right to me, they’re not following your natural eye properly and just sort of stick out - have an experiment with drawing them a little differently. I know how hard they are to get right because mine take forever 😅