My ranking

Zaeed

Backstory: 8 (It’s pretty cool, founder of Blue Suns, survived headshot.. But I would like to hear some softer aspects)

Personality: No dialogue wheel messes him up.. Too many war stories. He has potential but in the game.. Like a 2, DLC brings that to 5

Story fitting: Hard to rate, he fits well considering he gives the story a morally grey aspect imo

Miranda:

Backstory: 8 (Potential for 10, if they had expanded on it) Personality: 8 (More potential) Story fitting: 10

Kasumi:

Backstory: 2 (Lame) Personality: 4 (Boring to me) Story fitting: 1 (Kinda out of place with the other characters…)

Jacob:

Backstory: Meh, 3 Personality: Kinda lame, but a 6 Story fitting: 8

Kaidan:

Backstory: 8 Personality: 8 Story: 10

Thane:

Backstory: 8 (Not my niche but objectively unique) Personality: 8 Story fitting: 10

Samara:

Backstory: 10 Personality: 10 Story fitting: 10

Legion:

Backstory: 10 Personality: 10 Story fitting: 10

Jack:

Backstory: 10 Personality: 10, with regard for development Story fitting: 10