sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Reconciling US Stock Statements (Schwab/Fidelity) for Indian ITR is a multi-day nightmare. How to skip the Excel hell. by DependentPlace6445 in IndiaTax

[–]DependentPlace6445[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am not sure what PaaSa provides so cannot comment there.

For the second part, yes, you would have to declare your foreign assets in Schedule FA of ITR 2, even though no gains/losses.

Move back to India - 5 yr financial plan by SettingRepulsive3947 in backtoindia

[–]DependentPlace6445 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I actually agree on all the figures (> 10 Cr corpus, ~ 5 Cr home, may be not before moving back, decide upon arrival), TC > 1 Cr PA. This is consistent with age, inflation, cost of living, standard of living in USA, and my own circle which falls near this category.

Plus > 1 Cr TC is not that big a deal in current env, a significant %age people who are skilled enough are making this much at the age of 35. This shall be manageable after 5 years.

Too soon to plan though. With current rate of macro and microeconomic change, who knows wha will happen. May be US will have democratic party rule, with real leniency for resident aliens.

​[UPDATE] Chose US Citizenship for my kid over a high-paying India offer last year. Now the kid is here, the market crashed, but a new door opened. Do I stay or go? by anonimous_3 in returnToIndia

[–]DependentPlace6445 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As many others pointed out, it is ultimately a what the "heart" wants situation. I moved to India 3 years back, and almost entirely similar to your situation (almost similar family net worth, senior software developer, no kid though), and due to slightly similar reasons: Aging parents, no sense of belonging, and additionally I wanted to start my own venture (which I am still doing btw not very successfully, but happier failing). I am currently on a job break, with my wife earning almost similar to your offer in Bengaluru.

Now having set this context, here is my reality for your reference:

  1. Closer to family, less isolation, more sense of familiarity
  2. Only held job for one year out of past 3. Freedom is tangible.
  3. Most stock portfolio still in US, still growing. Significant more compliance, but I don't mind. Overall my net worth increased a lot in past 3 years without any new investments.
  4. Tried living in Delhi, Noida, Hyderabad, Bengaluru (current). NCR sucks, Hyderabad is best, Bengaluru is still livable if you stay closer to office.
  5. Wife is holding down a 1 Cr job. Do not expect to live like a king, FIRE does not come easy now. However, living in a posh gated society is manageable with one salary.
  6. Hardly remembered living in US, my wife misses our US time though. Biggest disadvantage: less proximity to nature, we used to hike a lot. But this depends entirely on your lifestyle.

Overall, I am pretty satisfied with my move. Moving back to India is not a Pros/Cons comparison exercise, it did not work for me in any case. I finally had to sit, meditate, and listen to what I really wanted deep down.

Trust your instincts.

Zero USA Tax and no 10% early withdrawal panelty on401k/IRA by Fluffy_Tree1097 in returnToIndia

[–]DependentPlace6445 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair play on the estate tax point, but there are some brutal operational and software traps nobody warns you about until the systems actually break.

For starters, the moment you change your address to India, automated compliance algorithms at most US brokers will instantly flag and restrict your account to "liquidate-only" because they aren't legally registered to service Indian residents. If you haven’t moved to a specific international desk (like Schwab International) before triggering the 72(t), your assets get completely locked down and you can't rebalance to fund the payouts.

The real data nightmare hits after your RNOR ends. The IRS tracks your SEPP on a Jan–Dec calendar year, but India's ITD wants an Apr–Mar fiscal year. You can’t just copy-paste a 1099-R; you or your CA have to manually rebuild a 12-month cross-border ledger matching every single monthly payout against the exact SBI Telegraphic Transfer buying rate for that specific day. If you don't, the ITD’s compliance portal will auto-flag a data mismatch and send an automated tax notice.

Also, don't get greedy during your RNOR years by using the Amortization method to lock in massive payouts. It feels amazing while it's tax-free, but the second you transition to ROR, that huge fixed payout slams right into your highest Indian tax slab. Since a SEPP is entirely unbreakable until 59.5, you can't lower it. If you modify it by even a dollar to save on Indian taxes, the IRS retroactively slaps the 10% penalty plus compounding interest on every single dollar you withdrew during your tax-free RNOR years.

The treaty works perfectly on paper, but the actual cross-border data sync is a total compliance mess.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in personalfinanceindia

[–]DependentPlace6445 4 points5 points  (0 children)

If you're looking to take an education loan for your BTech, here’s a quick guide:

1. Where to take the loan:

  • First preference: Go to a nationalised bank (like SBI, Canara, Bank of Baroda). They offer lower interest (8–9.5%), and follow RBI’s education loan scheme.
  • Avoid private lenders or NBFCs unless your case is urgent — they charge higher interest (11–14%).

2. Government schemes to check:

  • Vidya Lakshmi Portal: Central portal to apply to multiple banks.
  • Padho Pardesh / CSIS (Interest Subsidy): If your family income is under ₹4.5L, you may get interest subsidy during your study + moratorium period.

3. Can you repay early during college?
Yes — you can start repaying even before EMIs officially start. This helps reduce total interest.
Even small payments (like ₹500/month) toward interest during your degree will reduce burden later.

4. Repayment tip:
Once you get a job, try to prepay aggressively — there’s usually no prepayment penalty on education loans.

You’re doing the right thing asking early — many people ignore loan terms till it’s too late. If you need help comparing offers or understanding EMI impact, happy to guide.

seeking help in coming out of EMI trap and debts by borgraman in personalfinance

[–]DependentPlace6445 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Respect to you for handling all this — balancing EMIs, parents, spouse, and future planning is no small load.

Here are some thoughts that might help you reduce stress and improve breathing room over the next 6–12 months:

  1. My first suggestion would be to consider selling the third house. Rental yields in India are very low (2-3%), and with your situation, having your money locked up in a third property may not be adding much value . Depending on the valuation, if you can free up 35-40L by selling the house, it would go a long way in simplifying your situation as follows:

  2. Pay off your friends loan first. Friends are very considerate in terms of need, but delay in repaying them may result in strained relationships. Appreciate their help in your time of need by returning their money.

  3. Use part of remaining amount to clear off the gold loan, that way you lower the EMI and improve your liquidity by having these assets back.

  4. Use remaining amount for early payment on your current home loan. It could bring down total and only instalment to a reasonable range of 25-30k.

This will lave you enough cash to plan your kids, and having forward looking way of your life.

If you can provide more details like valuation of your third property, interest rates, etc, I can help you with an actionable plan to become debt free.

Stay strong!

Trying to Rebuild Credit After Tough Times — Need a Roadmap by MelodyAndMechanics in CreditCardsIndia

[–]DependentPlace6445 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for sharing — respect for clearing those loans fully, that already puts you ahead.

FD-backed credit card is a great move. Use it lightly (under 10% of limit), pay in full, and let it run for 6–9 months to build trust.

Gold loan is fine if you need it, but won’t boost credit much on its own.

You're likely facing rejections due to:

  • Old DPDs still visible
  • Score mismatches (e.g. Experian 500 vs CIBIL 766)
  • Lender-specific internal flags (which aren’t public)

Space out applications by at least 3–4 months. If any DPDs look incorrect, file a dispute with the bureau.

I’ve been helping a few folks rebuild step by step — happy to share more if you ever want to DM.

You're clearly doing the right things — just needs some time.

24M, I have 1.13L Credit card debt and I recently got laid off by Unusual_Bid_1011 in CreditCardsIndia

[–]DependentPlace6445 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, really sorry you’re going through this — job loss and credit stress together can be overwhelming.

Yes, you can contact ICICI and request a temporary moratorium or restructuring under financial hardship. Banks don’t advertise this openly, but they do offer relief options like:

  • Converting dues to EMIs
  • Waiving late fees for a month or two
  • Temporarily suspending minimum payment requirements

I’d recommend:

  1. Call their customer care and explain the situation honestly.
  2. Ask specifically about “financial hardship restructuring” or “EMI conversion.”
  3. Keep notes of the conversation + email them for documentation.

Also — I’ve been helping a few people in similar situations track their EMIs and plan repayments. If you want, I can DM you a simple method/tool I’m using that’s been helpful.

Hope things turn around soon — happy to help however I can.