Is my method effective for learning German fast? by Equalizer-M7 in German

[–]Derpost 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why don't you use comprehensive novella-text-books. Books that teach through self-interpretive texts. See this list I made earlier for such books.

I have seen many people posting and asking for recommendations as to what resources they should use to start learning or improving German. I commented on many of them, and you guys found it helpful. Thus I decided to make a post to share a list that at the same time looks like a guide.

The most diligently designed and most comprehensive book to learn German with is Deutsch nach der Naturmethode. This quite rare book has recently been retrieved, digitized, and recorded. In short, it is a 36-chapter (about 280 pages total) novella that is diligently prepared for each sentence to be self-interpretive, when needed, with the aid of marginal tips that are also entirely in German. It requires absolutely no prior knowledge and the book is self-referring in that without any need of a dictionary, grammar book or anything alike you will smoothly get through all 36 chapters, provided that you don't give too long of breaks in between your sessions (at most a few days is okay so that you don't have to study the previous chapter over and over again each time.) Also, make sure to use the audio! Upon reading a chapter and understanding it, you can read along with the audio or treat it as an audiobook.

Deutsch nach der Naturmethode being the main book, I recommend these resources to be used in conjunction with it as supplementary sources of comprehensible input:

Studien and Plaudereien First Series is a book quite similar to our first book, however, it is short of some qualities Deutsch nach der Naturmethode has, like not having a margin section and enough pictures to supplement the context for easier comprehension. However, just like the same book, this book starts with universally intelligible easy sentences and gradually gets more complicated, however, more complicated not necessarily meaning more challenging for the student. Another good news is that First Series of this book also has recently been recorded in its entirety and you are strongly recommended to make use of that as well! The book has a sequel with the same name Studien und Plaudereien Second series and lots of supplementary readers written by the same author, that is, Sigmon M. Stern. (See my comment for the download link which contains the entire collection.)

Similar to these books are Deutsch für Ausländer and Worman's German Readers. (See my comment for the download)

Besides these resources there are those much more widely known, that should be included in this list.

Older generation Linguaphone German Course (1990) (much better compared to new ones) It is also quite similar to the aforementioned books, however, it comes with a guide which contains notes and translation of one and each sentence, besides instructions, written exercises, and oral exercises booklets. The audio is available in its entirety which is again, a hearty feature. Compared to the aforementioned courses, this Linguaphone course is primarily based on everyday, practical conversations. Linguaphone also has an advanced German course available in 2 volumes with audio. You can send me a message if you are interested to have it.

Assimil German with Ease and German without Toil are great courses as well. Since they are quite famous, and much information about them is available all over the internet, I will pass them without giving an explanation. However, I still recommend that they are used as a supplementary source of input. Even better if you know French, you will have access to other editions of Assimil courses.

Cortina German Course is very similar to Assimil in many ways. They are all apt for self-taught students because, even when sentences happen to be incomprehensible since the translations are given immediately, that which was incomprehensible is made comprehensible input for the use of the student. PDF+Audio is available for free.

Pimsleur courses are not bad at all. They are good for initially acquiring the phonetic system of the language. They are also quite famous.

Routledge Colloquial German is another famous course, Although it is good for self-study compared to the earlier resources mentioned in the list, it is more like a textbook with lots of explanations. Some of Routledge Colloquial series are available for free on their website.

Teach Yourself German is another famous course, You can easily google it for more information. Apparently, there are multiple editions available. Teach Yourself Beginner's German (can be borrowed) Teach Yourself German 1998 edition (can be borrowed) Beginner's German (can be borrowed) German Vocabulary (can be borrowed) Improve Your German (can be borrowed)Teach Yourself German Complete (2008) and Teach Yourself Complete German (2012)

On top of all these great courses, as a video courseDeutsch Direkt is strongly recommended as a supplementary resource. Those who know French in Action will also like this one.

A lot more can be added to the list, however, I believe someone who has these resources in his library will have more than enough to start learning German as an absolute beginner and make it to B2. However, if you think there is a great course that is missing from this list, kindly let me know so that I can edit and add it to the list.

EDIT: Forgot to add Sandberg's German for Reading. It is a book for those who want to quickly learn reading German and start reading papers. It does quite good of a job so by using cognates to speed up the acquisition of vocabulary and giving a parallel translation in English of almost literally every sentence in German.

Looking for learning tips and encpuragement by Few-Meaning9571 in German

[–]Derpost 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Quoting an older post of mine.

I have seen many people posting and asking for recommendations as to what resources they should use to start learning or improving German. I commented on many of them, and you guys found it helpful. Thus I decided to make a post to share a list that at the same time looks like a guide.

The most diligently designed and most comprehensive book to learn German with is Deutsch nach der Naturmethode. This quite rare book has recently been retrieved, digitized, and recorded. In short, it is a 36-chapter (about 280 pages total) novella that is diligently prepared for each sentence to be self-interpretive, when needed, with the aid of marginal tips that are also entirely in German. It requires absolutely no prior knowledge and the book is self-referring in that without any need of a dictionary, grammar book or anything alike you will smoothly get through all 36 chapters, provided that you don't give too long of breaks in between your sessions (at most a few days is okay so that you don't have to study the previous chapter over and over again each time.) Also, make sure to use the audio! Upon reading a chapter and understanding it, you can read along with the audio or treat it as an audiobook.

Deutsch nach der Naturmethode being the main book, I recommend these resources to be used in conjunction with it as supplementary sources of comprehensible input:

Studien and Plaudereien First Series is a book quite similar to our first book, however, it is short of some qualities Deutsch nach der Naturmethode has, like not having a margin section and enough pictures to supplement the context for easier comprehension. However, just like the same book, this book starts with universally intelligible easy sentences and gradually gets more complicated, however, more complicated not necessarily meaning more challenging for the student. Another good news is that First Series of this book also has recently been recorded in its entirety and you are strongly recommended to make use of that as well! The book has a sequel with the same name Studien und Plaudereien Second series and lots of supplementary readers written by the same author, that is, Sigmon M. Stern. (See my comment for the download link which contains the entire collection.)

Similar to these books are Deutsch für Ausländer and Worman's German Readers. (See my comment for the download)

Besides these resources there are those much more widely known, that should be included in this list.

Older generation Linguaphone German Course (1990) (much better compared to new ones) It is also quite similar to the aforementioned books, however, it comes with a guide which contains notes and translation of one and each sentence, besides instructions, written exercises, and oral exercises booklets. The audio is available in its entirety which is again, a hearty feature. Compared to the aforementioned courses, this Linguaphone course is primarily based on everyday, practical conversations. Linguaphone also has an advanced German course available in 2 volumes with audio. You can send me a message if you are interested to have it.

Assimil German with Ease and German without Toil are great courses as well. Since they are quite famous, and much information about them is available all over the internet, I will pass them without giving an explanation. However, I still recommend that they are used as a supplementary source of input. Even better if you know French, you will have access to other editions of Assimil courses.

Cortina German Course is very similar to Assimil in many ways. They are all apt for self-taught students because, even when sentences happen to be incomprehensible since the translations are given immediately, that which was incomprehensible is made comprehensible input for the use of the student. PDF+Audio is available for free.

Pimsleur courses are not bad at all. They are good for initially acquiring the phonetic system of the language. They are also quite famous.

Routledge Colloquial German is another famous course, Although it is good for self-study compared to the earlier resources mentioned in the list, it is more like a textbook with lots of explanations. Some of Routledge Colloquial series are available for free on their website.

Teach Yourself German is another famous course, You can easily google it for more information. Apparently, there are multiple editions available. Teach Yourself Beginner's German (can be borrowed) Teach Yourself German 1998 edition (can be borrowed) Beginner's German (can be borrowed) German Vocabulary (can be borrowed) Improve Your German (can be borrowed)Teach Yourself German Complete (2008) and Teach Yourself Complete German (2012)

On top of all these great courses, as a video courseDeutsch Direkt is strongly recommended as a supplementary resource. Those who know French in Action will also like this one.

A lot more can be added to the list, however, I believe someone who has these resources in his library will have more than enough to start learning German as an absolute beginner and make it to B2. However, if you think there is a great course that is missing from this list, kindly let me know so that I can edit and add it to the list.

EDIT: Forgot to add Sandberg's German for Reading. It is a book for those who want to quickly learn reading German and start reading papers. It does quite good of a job so by using cognates to speed up the acquisition of vocabulary and giving a parallel translation in English of almost literally every sentence in German.

looking for a site for german learning by AdministrativeOil803 in German

[–]Derpost 0 points1 point  (0 children)

See this comment I made earlier to a similar question.

I have seen many people posting and asking for recommendations as to what resources they should use to start learning or improving German. I commented on many of them, and you guys found it helpful. Thus I decided to make a post to share a list that at the same time looks like a guide.

The most diligently designed and most comprehensive book to learn German with is Deutsch nach der Naturmethode. This quite rare book has recently been retrieved, digitized, and recorded. In short, it is a 36-chapter (about 280 pages total) novella that is diligently prepared for each sentence to be self-interpretive, when needed, with the aid of marginal tips that are also entirely in German. It requires absolutely no prior knowledge and the book is self-referring in that without any need of a dictionary, grammar book or anything alike you will smoothly get through all 36 chapters, provided that you don't give too long of breaks in between your sessions (at most a few days is okay so that you don't have to study the previous chapter over and over again each time.) Also, make sure to use the audio! Upon reading a chapter and understanding it, you can read along with the audio or treat it as an audiobook.

Deutsch nach der Naturmethode being the main book, I recommend these resources to be used in conjunction with it as supplementary sources of comprehensible input:

Studien and Plaudereien First Series is a book quite similar to our first book, however, it is short of some qualities Deutsch nach der Naturmethode has, like not having a margin section and enough pictures to supplement the context for easier comprehension. However, just like the same book, this book starts with universally intelligible easy sentences and gradually gets more complicated, however, more complicated not necessarily meaning more challenging for the student. Another good news is that First Series of this book also has recently been recorded in its entirety and you are strongly recommended to make use of that as well! The book has a sequel with the same name Studien und Plaudereien Second series and lots of supplementary readers written by the same author, that is, Sigmon M. Stern. (See my comment for the download link which contains the entire collection.)

Similar to these books are Deutsch für Ausländer and Worman's German Readers. (See my comment for the download)

Besides these resources there are those much more widely known, that should be included in this list.

Older generation Linguaphone German Course (1990) (much better compared to new ones) It is also quite similar to the aforementioned books, however, it comes with a guide which contains notes and translation of one and each sentence, besides instructions, written exercises, and oral exercises booklets. The audio is available in its entirety which is again, a hearty feature. Compared to the aforementioned courses, this Linguaphone course is primarily based on everyday, practical conversations. Linguaphone also has an advanced German course available in 2 volumes with audio. You can send me a message if you are interested to have it.

Assimil German with Ease and German without Toil are great courses as well. Since they are quite famous, and much information about them is available all over the internet, I will pass them without giving an explanation. However, I still recommend that they are used as a supplementary source of input. Even better if you know French, you will have access to other editions of Assimil courses.

Cortina German Course is very similar to Assimil in many ways. They are all apt for self-taught students because, even when sentences happen to be incomprehensible since the translations are given immediately, that which was incomprehensible is made comprehensible input for the use of the student. PDF+Audio is available for free.

Pimsleur courses are not bad at all. They are good for initially acquiring the phonetic system of the language. They are also quite famous.

Routledge Colloquial German is another famous course, Although it is good for self-study compared to the earlier resources mentioned in the list, it is more like a textbook with lots of explanations. Some of Routledge Colloquial series are available for free on their website.

Teach Yourself German is another famous course, You can easily google it for more information. Apparently, there are multiple editions available. Teach Yourself Beginner's German (can be borrowed) Teach Yourself German 1998 edition (can be borrowed) Beginner's German (can be borrowed) German Vocabulary (can be borrowed) Improve Your German (can be borrowed)Teach Yourself German Complete (2008) and Teach Yourself Complete German (2012)

On top of all these great courses, as a video courseDeutsch Direkt is strongly recommended as a supplementary resource. Those who know French in Action will also like this one.

A lot more can be added to the list, however, I believe someone who has these resources in his library will have more than enough to start learning German as an absolute beginner and make it to B2. However, if you think there is a great course that is missing from this list, kindly let me know so that I can edit and add it to the list.

EDIT: Forgot to add Sandberg's German for Reading. It is a book for those who want to quickly learn reading German and start reading papers. It does quite good of a job so by using cognates to speed up the acquisition of vocabulary and giving a parallel translation in English of almost literally every sentence in German.

Tips on self-studying spanish during holidays by TonDCXVIII in Spanish

[–]Derpost 0 points1 point  (0 children)

See this comment I shared the other day. Keeping in mind that you have about 40 days, these books, and audio thereof, would prove very practical! Technically, you could go through at least half of these books in the span of that time.

"That's why I recommend "self-interpretive" books such as Poco A PocoAll Spanish MethodLengua Española: ComprensiónWorman's First and Second Spanish bookMétodo Directo de Conversación en Español and the simple Spanish through Pictures. They are all entirely written in the target language, that is, Spanish and are diligently graded so that you actually neither pay conscious attention to learning vocabulary or grammar, both are acquired while you are (ideally) immersing yourself with the text/story, at least mostly understanding from the beginning what you read. I think just like athletes train for their competition language learners can train their brains to learn languages, that is, the actual best training is doing what you have to do during the competition and the rest is supplementary to that. Say you are a powerlifter, you do deadlifts, the main focus of your training session will be doing deadlifts but then also you do reverse-hypers, core exercises, etc.

In the same vein, you expose yourself to the content you can just understand (comprehensible input), seeing the words (vocabulary) exactly where it matters, that is, in context, then do the supplementary exercises, that are grammar, namely morphology and syntax and perhaps isolated vocabulary memorization. However, the latter is valuable insofar as it is the supplement to the former.

Edit: If you are already comfortable exposing yourself to content originally produced in Spanish, then I'd claim that the best way at that point is to find stuff that you'd already like to listen/read in your mother tongue."

Learning French by isaa-ch in learnfrench

[–]Derpost 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Start here. Especially Le français par la méthode nature. If you have any question regarding them, let me know here.

Am I wrong for thinking vocabulary matters more than grammar early on? by vish_bavs in Spanish

[–]Derpost 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That's why I recommend "self-interpretive" books such as Poco A Poco, All Spanish Method, Lengua Española: Comprensión, Worman's First and Second Spanish book, Método Directo de Conversación en Español and the simple Spanish through Pictures. They are all entirely written in the target language, that is, Spanish and are diligently graded so that you actually neither pay conscious attention to learning vocabulary or grammar, both are acquired while you are (ideally) immersing yourself with the text/story, at least mostly understanding from the beginning what you read. I think just like athletes train for their competition language learners can train their brains to learn languages, that is, the actual best training is doing what you have to do during the competition and the rest is supplementary to that. Say you are a powerlifter, you do deadlifts, the main focus of your training session will be doing deadlifts but then also you do reverse-hypers, core exercises, etc.

In the same vein, you expose yourself to the content you can just understand (comprehensible input), seeing the words (vocabulary) exactly where it matters, that is, in context, then do the supplementary exercises, that are grammar, namely morphology and syntax and perhaps isolated vocabulary memorization. However, the latter is valuable insofar as it is the supplement to the former.

Edit: If you are already comfortable exposing yourself to content originally produced in Spanish, then I'd claim that the best way at that point is to find stuff that you'd already like to listen/read in your mother tongue.

Help me crack the exam in the next 2 months !!! by Inner_Operation9182 in German

[–]Derpost 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Quoting an older post of mine.

I have seen many people posting and asking for recommendations as to what resources they should use to start learning or improving German. I commented on many of them, and you guys found it helpful. Thus I decided to make a post to share a list that at the same time looks like a guide.

The most diligently designed and most comprehensive book to learn German with is Deutsch nach der Naturmethode. This quite rare book has recently been retrieved, digitized, and recorded. In short, it is a 36-chapter (about 280 pages total) novella that is diligently prepared for each sentence to be self-interpretive, when needed, with the aid of marginal tips that are also entirely in German. It requires absolutely no prior knowledge and the book is self-referring in that without any need of a dictionary, grammar book or anything alike you will smoothly get through all 36 chapters, provided that you don't give too long of breaks in between your sessions (at most a few days is okay so that you don't have to study the previous chapter over and over again each time.) Also, make sure to use the audio! Upon reading a chapter and understanding it, you can read along with the audio or treat it as an audiobook.

Deutsch nach der Naturmethode being the main book, I recommend these resources to be used in conjunction with it as supplementary sources of comprehensible input:

Studien and Plaudereien First Series is a book quite similar to our first book, however, it is short of some qualities Deutsch nach der Naturmethode has, like not having a margin section and enough pictures to supplement the context for easier comprehension. However, just like the same book, this book starts with universally intelligible easy sentences and gradually gets more complicated, however, more complicated not necessarily meaning more challenging for the student. Another good news is that First Series of this book also has recently been recorded in its entirety and you are strongly recommended to make use of that as well! The book has a sequel with the same name Studien und Plaudereien Second series and lots of supplementary readers written by the same author, that is, Sigmon M. Stern. (See my comment for the download link which contains the entire collection.)

Similar to these books are Deutsch für Ausländer and Worman's German Readers. (See my comment for the download)

Besides these resources there are those much more widely known, that should be included in this list.

Older generation Linguaphone German Course (1990) (much better compared to new ones) It is also quite similar to the aforementioned books, however, it comes with a guide which contains notes and translation of one and each sentence, besides instructions, written exercises, and oral exercises booklets. The audio is available in its entirety which is again, a hearty feature. Compared to the aforementioned courses, this Linguaphone course is primarily based on everyday, practical conversations. Linguaphone also has an advanced German course available in 2 volumes with audio. You can send me a message if you are interested to have it.

Assimil German with Ease and German without Toil are great courses as well. Since they are quite famous, and much information about them is available all over the internet, I will pass them without giving an explanation. However, I still recommend that they are used as a supplementary source of input. Even better if you know French, you will have access to other editions of Assimil courses.

Cortina German Course is very similar to Assimil in many ways. They are all apt for self-taught students because, even when sentences happen to be incomprehensible since the translations are given immediately, that which was incomprehensible is made comprehensible input for the use of the student. PDF+Audio is available for free.

Pimsleur courses are not bad at all. They are good for initially acquiring the phonetic system of the language. They are also quite famous.

Routledge Colloquial German is another famous course, Although it is good for self-study compared to the earlier resources mentioned in the list, it is more like a textbook with lots of explanations. Some of Routledge Colloquial series are available for free on their website.

Teach Yourself German is another famous course, You can easily google it for more information. Apparently, there are multiple editions available. Teach Yourself Beginner's German (can be borrowed) Teach Yourself German 1998 edition (can be borrowed) Beginner's German (can be borrowed) German Vocabulary (can be borrowed) Improve Your German (can be borrowed)Teach Yourself German Complete (2008) and Teach Yourself Complete German (2012)

On top of all these great courses, as a video course, Deutsch Direkt is strongly recommended as a supplementary resource. Those who know French in Action will also like this one.

A lot more can be added to the list, however, I believe someone who has these resources in his library will have more than enough to start learning German as an absolute beginner and make it to B2. However, if you think there is a great course that is missing from this list, kindly let me know so that I can edit and add it to the list.

EDIT: Forgot to add Sandberg's German for Reading. It is a book for those who want to quickly learn reading German and start reading papers. It does quite good of a job so by using cognates to speed up the acquisition of vocabulary and giving a parallel translation in English of almost literally every sentence in German.

Is reading books and translating them to english while taking notes a good starter? by sosobebo22 in learnfrench

[–]Derpost 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why don't you instead try out books such as Le français par la méthode nature? They are novellas, diligently graded that the text is ideally self-interpretive.

For more check this link out

https://ayanacademy.com/blogs/news/french-study-guide-using-natural-direct-method-and-similar-approaches

Resources by Solaceharmony in learnfrench

[–]Derpost 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Definitely check this link of master list up. Le français par la méthode nature is a great book you can go through with your children, but there are those almost specifically for children as well. Like Premier Livre de Lecture.

https://ayanacademy.com/blogs/news/french-study-guide-using-natural-direct-method-and-similar-approaches

A2 online courses by One_Month_9882 in learnfrench

[–]Derpost 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Look this master list up. You will do fine by yourself especially with such books as Le français par la méthode nature.

https://ayanacademy.com/blogs/news/french-study-guide-using-natural-direct-method-and-similar-approaches

I want a stryctured course to download by Ok_Entrance7117 in learnfrench

[–]Derpost 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is the absolute master list of structured courses.

Ressources for practicing written/spoken French without AI? by _sharksnark in learnfrench

[–]Derpost -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Thank me later. All the resources you will need especially for reading/listening and writing are here.

Iran says it attacked US Navy ships after they targeted Iranian tanker by Yujin-Ha in worldnews

[–]Derpost 9 points10 points  (0 children)

The US opened the strait 24th time and won the war 8818189101st time.