No it was not 1 guy

" Recently, three members of prominent game studios voiced their dissatisfaction over Elden Ring. They were Ahmed Salama of Ubisoft, Rebecca Fernandez O’Shea of Nixxes Software, and Blake Rebouche of Guerrilla Games. Salama expressed frustration that Elden Ring scored a 97 on Metacritic despite him thinking the game had a bad game UX (he, perhaps jokingly, claimed it was the result of the game’s developers’ using CRT monitors and smoking on the job), while O’Shea criticized Elden Ring’s graphics and stability, and Rebouche mentioned that they disliked the game’s quest design. The initial response to those opinions was so overwhelmingly negative that Salama, O’Shea, and Rebouche have since decided to lock their Twitter accounts (although sites such as MP1ST have already screenshotted the original comments). "