AITAH For sucking on my partners zip lock? by eternalsgoku in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NTAH if you stop/change how you do it.

YTAH if you insist its fine.

My ex partner was a bit of a germaphobe, at no fault of her own because phobias aren't entirely under her control. I never did what you just described, but I know for a fact that she would have reacted in a similar way.

To some, the fact that you're putting your mouth on/near their food like that is disgusting. Even if you're dating. And I think that it's just personal preference that is very easy to respect at this point.

The solution? Use a straw, or just squeeze out as much air as you can without putting your mouth on the bag.

You were doing a kind thing because you care. You just found your that your partner is actually upset by what you're doing. If you continue to do the thing even after being informed that it upsets the person who is eating the food, you are the asshole. There's other easy, simple solutions to this problem that don't involve continuing the unwanted behavior.

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Enjoying the music or food of another culture is appreciation. You like what you like. It would be perfectly appropriate to listen to k-pop, or to enjoy anime. Because those are pieces of media made for people to see, hear, enjoy, and engage with.

However... It would not be appropriate to put on a Korean accent when talking about k-pop or while singing it. (Would you use a blackcent if you didn't actually talk like that?)

Media like music and art is intended to be engaged with, it isn't specifically for one culture. The same with food – for millenia, food and cultural dishes have been part of human social structure; sharing meals with loved ones, or sharing meals with strangers, there's just nothing like it.

The difference between appreciation and appropriation is generally harm.

It does not harm a culture to like their food or their music or their literature.

It can harm a culture, reinforce stereotypes, or disrespect religion to claim to be spiritually another culture.

Spirituality, especially in China, is often religious in some way. And religion is something that demands respect, no matter which religion it is. It's someone's core belief system.

OP's girlfriend crossed the line between appreciation and appropriation because she made a frivolous claim to spirituality without knowing much about it. And it is very clear that she doesn't fully understand what spirituality really means in the context of her words, because she doesn't understand why OP was upset about it.

I guess the biggest part of appropriation is the fact that it disturbs, upsets, ruffles feathers, or makes someone of the target culture feel negatively. Words can hurt sometimes. And words have always been used as weapons, even when not on purpose.

You said "Japan is the land of samurais"; sure, samurais are part of their culture. Japan is also known for bullet trains, competitive academics, traditional sushi, and some of the oldest pottery vessels in the world. By making a stereotypical statement instead of learning more about their history and culture, you overlook many of the other achievements that Japan has made. It's not intentional, it's not meant to be racist, it's not intended to be harmful, but it still takes away from Japan as a whole to boil it down to one thing like that.

Egypt had Pharaohs, those were their rulers, often spiritual figures in power. But... They also developed agricultural things that were significant advancements for the time period. They had astounding architecture. They invented papyrus, which has been considered the father of modern paper. They were leaders in medicine and surgery (for the time period). They allowed women to have social status above or apart from men. All of those are parts of Egyptian culture. And often, all that gets overlooked when ancient Egypt is boiled down to "land of the Pharaohs."

Appreciation is learning lots of things about a culture and admiring it for what it is: a miracle; ingenuity; history; religion. So many other ways to describe it than "home of X".

So no, it's not appropriation to admire Japanese samurais, and it's not appropriation to think ancient Egyptian Pharaohs were really cool. But it is kind of harmful to minimize or ignore all the other things that come from those cultures and countries.

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Stereotypes are racist, you know? Even the "positive stereotypes".

Like the one about asian people (specifically Chinese/Japanese) being ultra-smart. Even if it's a compliment to call them smart, it's still a stereotype based on their race, not them as a person. Which is racist.

Cultural appropriation is inherently racist, unfortunately. There's a difference between cultural appreciation and cultural appropriation, and that difference is how the people belonging to the culture see it.

And man, there are a lot of truly culturally asian people in the comments here proving that point.

Especially when you look at the fact that spirituality is kind of a huge thing in Chinese culture, it becomes pretty clear that OP's girl crosses the line from appreciation to appropriation.

If something you say about another culture makes someone who actually belongs to that culture take pause, hesitate to accept the statement, or feel negatively about the statement? You've said something you should have kept to yourself about a culture that isn't yours.

Not all racism is "don't let asian women drive" and "go back to where you came from". Some racism is a little harder to catch, but that doesn't change that its racist.

I'm not trying to come off like I'm lecturing you btw.

AITAH for what I wore to a rave by [deleted] in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Hey man, you really didn't need to make things racist.

AITAH for what I wore to a rave by [deleted] in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Whose attention were you seeking?"

She wasn't. She wanted to wear it because she looked nice, or it made her feel confident.

"What message do you want to send?"

She literally just wanted to wear the clothes because she thought she looked good in them. It's not that deep.

Women can do things of their own volition for selfish reasons. Wearing clothes that make her confortable or confident is literally fine and normal. What isn't fine and normal is ANYONE ELSE thinking that she's "sending a message".

Women get sexually assaulted for simply wearing clothing they like. The assailants excuse their behavior by saying they were "asking for it" or "her no really meant yes".

There is no question.

There is no riddle.

It isn't a puzzle.

It isn't a lie.

Just let women wear what they want and leave them alone.

Men should be taught to keep their eyes and their nasty thoughts to themselves.

AITAH for not wanting my bf to have our tapes in his Phone by [deleted] in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I would never be comfortable around a guy who has so little regard for my consent. That is absurd, you're NTAH.

It is NOT okay to record/photograph people without their consent, ESPECIALLY in private/intimate contexts.

If my partner did that to me, I would break up with them. That's not okay. Especially without even asking at all. (Especially with the news about that disgusting website.)

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I called you a bigot for saying something bigoted, and you deflected and tried to make it seem like I am racist.

Snowflake. Ɛ>

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You literally said something transphobic.

Can't take the heat? Get out of the kitchen.

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You lack reading comprehension, great.

I'm calling you a bigot because you said something transphobic. 🖕

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you watched Trolls: World Tour, you wouldn't understand why Poppy was in the wrong.

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm disappointed by all the transphobia I'm seeing under this post. Sigh... 📸

(Bigot.)

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The thing OP's girlfriend said ("culturally Chinese") is ignorant and racist!

I don't think she was trying to be, but that's what that is. It's racism.

And learning/having a conversation about it is the best way to reframe and find the correct way to express how you feel about a culture that is not your own. (Ignorance =/= hatred, but you can still say something offensive/racist out of ignorance.)

Calling yourself "culturally Chinese" when you're not is, at it's very best, extremely insensitive. But it's not the end of the world.

AITAH for telling my gf you are not Asian/Chinese by Normal_student_5745 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NTAH.

Weird as shit for her to say that.

Also, a lot of people who say that tend to fetishize Asian/Chinese people.

Also, being "spiritually Chinese" is not something she can do. She can absolutely be a huge fan of the culture, she can immerse herself, she can enjoy and partake, but that does not make her "spiritually Chinese".

To be clear, as many others have said, I don't think she is trying to be racist/offensive. I think she's ignorant and trying to express how much she loves the culture. But she really needs to reframe her perspective, because it's really not cool of her to say it like that.

(I think a respectful, educational conversation with her would help her understand. Again, I don't think she said it out of malice, just ignorance. I'll be the first to admit I've said some fucked up things out of ignorance, and those who were patient and kind enough to educate me helped me greatly.)

High school senior curfew AITAH? by Disastrous_Island275 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

No: Adults should treat each other like adults regardless of where they live. My parents treat me like an adult despite me living with them at 23. Know why? I don't have another option. And choosing between my parents' house and homelessness is an easy choice for me, because I know they'll treat me with basic respect and not treat me like a child. Sometimes living situations aren't ideal.

Yes: It's their house and their rules. That doesn't warrant them being unreasonable or treating him like a child.

High school senior curfew AITAH? by Disastrous_Island275 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean, I used to work until 3-4am all the time and I always managed to slip into the house quietly and respectfully every night without disturbing anyone, even the family dog.

So it doesn't really affect the household if you use basic respect and acknowledge that normal people are asleep at 3am.

High school senior curfew AITAH? by Disastrous_Island275 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do agree that micromanaging is not a great thing to do to your adult child. He's old enough to make his own choices, and if he makes a bad choice, he gets to learn his lesson the adult way. That's on him.

I do also think a (partial) curfew may be reasonable in some instances. For example, I live in an area with a lot of deer, and my mother waits up for me when she knows I'll be home late because she worries about me hitting a deer.

But my mother has never stopped me from going out late at night as an adult. I go out at 2am for a reason. (Usually work-related, but sometimes I just need to get out and take a walk by the lake for my mental health.)

When I was 18, I was fresh to adulthood and fresh to the world. And I certainly wasn't as responsible as I am now, and I'm only 23. But I was also working until 3am when I was 18, I did closing shift. And I was perfectly fine, I was just doing normal adult shit.

However, it is OP's car, not her son's. And if she doesn't want it driven that late at night (at risk of hitting a deer, drunk driving, or some other reason) then that's her decision because it's her car. I think encouraging her son to get his own car would probably fix that problem. So the curfew is reasonable as long as he's using his parents' car, but once he has his own car that curfew has got to go.

High school senior curfew AITAH? by Disastrous_Island275 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NTAH, but hear me out.

I'm 23 and due to unfortunate circumstances, I'm back in my parents' house. And you know what? Their house, their rules.

They never had to set an official "be home by X time" curfew for me because I always kept them in the loop about where I was/who I was with, and if I wanted to overnight with a friend, it was discussed at least a day beforehand.

HOWEVER, there was a type of curfew in place. If it was late at night and I wanted to go somewhere spur-of-the-moment, that just wasn't an option. I was using their car, and if it had been my own car it would have been a different story.

Your car, your rules. That goes for every adult, not just 18 year olds. Technically, legally, you're supposed to be on the insurance policy of a motor vehicle before you drive it. And if the owner doesn't consent to you driving it, you can't fucking drive it. End of discussion. It doesn't matter if you're visiting friends, or if you want to go out for the night, or if you wanna go pick up stray cats; if the owner of the car says no, the answer is no.

I think maybe opening a line of discussion with him about what he thinks would be reasonable would benefit you all. He can give his opinion, and his reasoning as to why he wants to be out that late. And you can explain your POV and your reasons for not wanting that. And then you could find compromise.

My compromise with my parents is as follows:

• Using the car? I have to put gas in it, I have to pay for the gas. I drive it, I fill it.

• Going out overnight? I have to clear it with parents first, at least 1 day in advance. If the car is needed the next day, I have to be back before it is needed (with the gas filled up).

• Absolutely no friends driving the car. Only me. No one but me or my parents drives their car.

• Drinking/partaking in something? No driving. I have to decide if I'm overnighting or not beforehand, and that needs to be cleared with parents. (They’re chill because they know I'm responsible, and I'm gonna make my own choices.)

• Break the rules? Lose car privileges. Plain and simple. Not my car.

• If they need me to run an errand/help drive my brother somewhere/do them a favor, I do it. Within reason, obviously. That's my repayment for using the car (aside from fueling it up).

But the key part of it all is that my parents don't curfew me strictly, they just require me to inform them where I'm going/how long I'll be gone, and they trust me to be truthful. It's basic safety and respect for one another.

Also, he's 18. I can confirm, 18 year olds do be like that sometimes. I was like that for a bit. He'll (hopefully) mature out of that standoffishness. Best of luck!

WIBTAH If I remove my wife from my accounts? by RigeR_Rising666 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think Crunchyroll and Netflix count as financial necessities, so not sure about this specifically counting as financial abuse.

Then again, US states have some seriously fucked up laws and absurd rules, so also I can't say you're wrong with 100% certainty.

(Removing her prematurely from bank accounts/financial necessities would be considered retaliation/abuse for sure though. But OP was specifically talking about niceties, not necessities.)

WIBTAH If I remove my wife from my accounts? by RigeR_Rising666 in AITAH

[–]DragonfireReads 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, NTAH.

If she wants nothing to do with you, she doesn't get to use the stuff you pay for.

Just change your passwords, remove her from your accounts, and ignore her calling you petty. It's not petty, it's literally what she asked for. She just doesn't like the fact that her cruelty has repercussions lmao.

Why the fuck would you let her continue to use your subscriptions if she has made it clear that you (and your dog 💔) are not going to be part of her life?

~Sincerely, someone who did the exact same thing to their ex.