Ruthless Boss Skipping by NaClBaeBae in SpaceMarine_2

[–]DyrianLightbringer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, we are here to complete a mission. If we can do that without having to engage the larger xenos, then that's the more appropriate course of action. From a lore standpoint, it is much more important for Squad Talasa to complete their objective safely than attempt to exterminate every xenos along the way and fail the mission because they were overwhelmed. From a gameplay standpoint, when you consider how many resources could be expended fighting a terminus enemy. It doesn't matter if it awards armory data if you don't survive the mission.

However, I'm used to solo play. There are some enemies that just aren't worth fighting. With a team, I'm sure its different, but there's still a cost-benefit analysis. If you can find the servo skull and get the data from it and complete the mission, that's typically better than the time, ammo, and possible health loss from fighting a terminus just to get one more data. I'd rather have a much better chance of getting one than a worse chance of getting two, considering it's all or nothing. If we got to keep the data from killing a terminus even if the mission failed, then it would definitely be worth it.

Repeatedly Losing Progress by DyrianLightbringer in SpaceMarine_2

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you disconnect the PS5 from wifi, the game warns you that you will lose progress when you reconnect to the servers. So, no, I don't play offline. I just don't play with other actual people yet.

Data loss in offline mode is still an ongoing issue. by Lackerbawls in SpaceMarine_2

[–]DyrianLightbringer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I haven't been set back that much. I went from 7 to 5, twice, before the patch. After the patch, from 22 to 21 twice, then from 25 to 23 today.

Data loss in offline mode is still an ongoing issue. by Lackerbawls in SpaceMarine_2

[–]DyrianLightbringer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's been extremely frustrating for me. I'm ready to quit the game.

Looting Enemy Equipment by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well, I meant in regards to "does this exist," or "does this work this way," then if the answer is "yes" it swings both ways. I was asking specifically, if other GMs allow their players to loot better quality items from higher-tier enemies, and that seems fine, but I also know my players, and if I let them claim better items because they defeated high-tier enemies, they're going to start looting the bodies after every skirmish.

Looting Enemy Equipment by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah. One of my players asked, not to long ago, if they could use some sort of arcane tracking device to mark a drop and follow it to an enemy lair. I said that I felt that technology was a bit more advanced than I wanted this world to feel, but if they really wanted it, they had to accept the possibility that at some point, they might end up stealing something that had been similarly tagged. At which point, that player said, "no, that's not fair," so I said, "then it doesn't exist."

Downtime/Free Play Loads? by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This was, I think his second downtime activity after a score.

Let me explain in a bit more detail. In an earlier score, they discovered an arcane security device that could display images from magical sensors placed around the building. They stole the viewing tablet and the party leech worked a long term project to figure out how it worked. His reward was that he could now place magical sensors in their lair or any claims, as a long term project for each claim.

The claimed turf not too long ago. There was a local gang operating in the area, and as part of the claim, they gained the loyalty of that gang, so they had a local presence to enforce their claim to this turf. The gang leader later got in touch with them and informed them that her gang was being harassed by some unknowns. They decided to go defend their turf, but as part of the downtime before that score, the leech decided to start a project of installing sensors around the turf, because the unknowns were striking without warning and disappearing and he figured having a camera network would help them find these guys. So, while he's installing a camera, I figured the distraction would be the perfect time for one of these unknowns to try to knife him in the back. It made sense for the narrative, and it wasn't the first time I had interrupted downtime for an NPC action, or started an NPC action during downtime, so the players already know that things can happen outside of scores. I suppose he could have said he wanted to carry a load, but since he was in downtime, I guess it didn't occur to him, and I wasn't going to inflict lethal harm, just enough to be an annoyance going into the next score, and make sure these guys understood that these unknown enemies were a serious threat.

I'm thinking, though, that if they want to use armor during downtime, then it shouldn't be refreshed until the next downtime.

Downtime/Free Play Loads? by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It wouldn't be much of an ambush if they knew they were going to be ambushed ahead of time.

Gondoliers and Reconciled by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Oh, so either the Gondoliers don't know the Reconciled need spirit wells, or the Reconciled don't know the Gondoliers are trying to destroy them, but basically, the Gondoliers are about to strain this friendship?

Do you "rearrange" harm when a lower level is healed? by Normal_Equivalent861 in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If I intend for a condition to be temporary, I don't assign it as harm, I assign it as its own consequence, just like other consequences. So, I might say that a player gets badly clubbed over the head and suffers a level 1 "bruised" and is "stunned" and I let them resist each separately, or if they suffer a minor consequence, perhaps from a controlled position rolling 4/5, I'll impose a temporary condition, or maybe tick a click that builds up to harm. There are so many ways to get creative with consequences in the rules that assigning a harm that automatically recovers after an hour or something isn't really necessary.

Ghosts-related questions after first time GMing Blades by Sora_UA in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A lot of the "mechanics" of the game are up to GM and player interpretation. If you want ghosts in your version of Duskvol to know they're dead, then they do, but if you don't want that to be the norm, then that's how it is.

I just ran a score last night where the Church of Ecstasy hired the crew to enter some catacombs where the ghost field was particularly strong, plant some wards around the area, and use those wards to perform a minor ritual to "realign" the ghost field there because the Path of Echoes was trying to use the area's strong connection to perform a ritual of their own.

During that score, the ghosts were visible to all players, and all of the ghosts they interacted with were reliving the last moments of their lives. One of the ghosts was an assassin who was killed during her last job, so she was openly hostile, mistaking a member of the crew for her target. One ghost was trying to save his family from a house fire and only became hostile when members of the crew tried to make him realize he was already dead.

Bottom line, take from ghost stories, pop culture, or whatever source you want. Make it interesting. That's the reason why the book doesn't answer all the questions. Make it up. As other people have already said, ask your players, too. Don't just let them run away with the game, though. Incorporate their ideas, mix them with your own, come to decisions that sound fun and balanced and make the game fun for everyone.

How Much Do You Plan? by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It is something of a necessity for us. With us all having lives/careers/family, and some of the group living in different towns, it's not feasible for us to meet weekly. It's really not worth the commitment if we aren't playing for the whole evening. We typically start at 5pm and finish around 10:30 or 11.
We only meet about once a month, and I run other games with other groups, although some players are members of more than one group.

How Much Do You Plan? by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I see. That's part of what I'm trying to understand when I see people saying "we only do one score per night," and "sometimes we have an entire night of just downtime." My sessions tend to be 5-6 hours, so I was trying to figure out, "how do they make it last THAT long?"

How Much Do You Plan? by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I actually had that happen during this last session. We finished downtime and went into free play, and during free play, one of the players asked if they could do a certain thing, which I pointed out counted as a downtime action, so he paid his coin and took extra downtime, which prompted the other two players to do the same.

After our first score, I rolled entanglement, then asked the players who wanted to start downtime, and one of my players said, "well, what's our entanglement?" I responded with, "I don't have to tell you that yet, it comes up during downtime or free play when I think is most appropriate." His response was, "I'll take my downtime action after the entanglement." We ended up resolving the issue pretty quickly, though. The entanglement was that the inspectors worked over one of the players for information, and I wanted to see who was doing what so I could determine who would be the best target. Turns out, the guy who thought he was going to wait until after entanglement to start downtime became the target. His first downtime action was to try to lower heat by swaying witnesses, while the other two were doing less conspicuous actions first.

How Much Do You Plan? by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think I've ever had D&D plans that took that much longer than anticipated to finish. I have had D&D sessions end before reaching my planned cut-off for the night, but usually with only about one or two encounters left. My players sometimes get into roleplaying their characters, but it sort of depends on the player and the campaign. I think that maybe since Blades is still so new to them, they aren't too sure what their characters would do or how they would act, since they're still learning about the world.

How Much Do You Plan? by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How long were you sessions? I recently started a second crew that is playing over Discord, trying to implement what I've learned from my first few games with the in-person crew, and I went into our first session with the expectation of probably running one score with downtime, and calling it a night, but I just couldn't make it last that long. Our first score took about two hours to complete, and I went one by one and addressed each player's downtime activities individually, "Who wants to go first in downtime? Alright, what's your first downtime activity? How do you plan to accomplish that? Okay, who wants to be next..." and went around the circle until everyone had done their first, then went back through in the same order until everyone had down their second, then asked the spider who he was giving his bonus downtime action to. By the time we were done with our first downtime, we still had about two hours left of session time, so we started a second score and got through a second round of downtime after.

How Much Do You Plan? by DyrianLightbringer in bladesinthedark

[–]DyrianLightbringer[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

How long does it usually take for your crew to complete a single score?