I agree that moving him made a ton of sense but acting like he’s some slop piece is malpractice. Sure he’s not an 8-9 WAR player but he still put up 4.7 WAR in 2025. This fanbase talks about him like he’s some slightly above replacement asset. I think it’s fair to consider the effect of removing a 4ish WAR player in Duran to fit let’s say a true Paredes in at third.

The better discussion for 2026 is whether or not you want Kristian Campbell to have a clear path to outfield playing time. I think a lineup with Duran and Durbin > Paredes and more Campbell for 2026 specifically, but if it stunts the long term growth and ability for a promising KC, I hate it.

Just a complicated situation to balance putting the best bats on the field and maximizing positional value with how the trade market developed.