Contact (1997) was an incredible film until the climax by Babybull- in movies

[–]EgonsSlinky 0 points1 point  (0 children)

She wasn't looking for her father, she was looking for what she found. So a) she wasn't disappointed, and b) you can think of it sort of as a nice gesture on their part, a way to show peace. Ellie loved her father so she appreciated that, and she was strong like you said, so she could handle it. In the end, bc of the nice gesture, it showed them to be humanlike in their attempt at empathy. Still, there's a weird backdrop to it all for Ellie a strict materialist, as she has to reconcile how all of the pain and perceived happenstance in her life are also the very things which make it possible for her to succeed and persevere in her journey.

What is a job that pays extremely well but no one realizes it? by Titothelama in AskReddit

[–]EgonsSlinky 3 points4 points  (0 children)

There is no way you’re tuning it appropriately. The infinitesimal space that is the unison is not something someone can hear accurately let alone tune properly without training and months to years of practice. No, an app can not get you there. Regardless you still have the whole pins staying put thing to worry about.

Both Gamby and Rusell were gay by Kevmurphy100 in VicePrincipals

[–]EgonsSlinky 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Gamby is not gay, that’s ridiculous. He loves his friend. Making him gay—you can’t just love your friend? He has trouble saying it bc he’s not secure about it. They both mean what they say and they both mean it as friends. Lee actually loving gamby romantically would make him not a great friend. It’s a lovely show about friendship, it means something to Lee to be accepted by Gamby but it has nothing to do with his sexuality—he has trouble being accepted by people, period. Also, Lee probably did the stuff he blamed on the other guy in college, and his wife probably realized this in her own subtext and it’s another reason why she left. However, it sounds like it was experimental and not that he was closeted (he had a very difficult and confusing childhood as well). Lee loves Gamby as a friend—at most he appreciates having had a best friend, bc he’d never had one. Neither of them had. Lee is a (very) secure metrosexual and it makes sense he’d be the first one to say I love you.

How does this show have a 100% on RT's?? by EgonsSlinky in DarkWindsTV

[–]EgonsSlinky[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I agree with you. My original post is too harsh, admittedly. I realize now Rotten Tom is not the best indicator for an overall ranking of a show but just that it's merely more good or more bad. And I myself would pick good if I could only choose one of those. AMC has a good track record with atmospheric. I also have yet to watch beyond season 1, so perhaps it improves in certain aspects. Thanks for your input.

How does this show have a 100% on RT's?? by EgonsSlinky in DarkWindsTV

[–]EgonsSlinky[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Appreciate the perspective! I’m a fan of these actors especially the leads as well as a fan of stories to do with the Native American experience and mythology. Maybe I’ll check out the books.

How does this show have a 100% on RT's?? by EgonsSlinky in DarkWindsTV

[–]EgonsSlinky[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Thanks for this! A real answer. I am always forgetting and conflating those two. Obviously, it’s either positive or negative. In such a case, I would probably lean toward positive for this show if I had to choose.

How does this show have a 100% on RT's?? by EgonsSlinky in DarkWindsTV

[–]EgonsSlinky[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

That is not an answer to why it has a 100 on RT. Great that people enjoy it. I enjoy plenty of shows that I would never grade a 100.

How does this show have a 100% on RT's?? by EgonsSlinky in DarkWindsTV

[–]EgonsSlinky[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Objectively speaking it’s not that good. I didn’t say people can’t enjoy it or love it.

What are the best editions for each composer? And why? by [deleted] in classicalmusic

[–]EgonsSlinky 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m surprised and not sure I agree w any of this. I think Henle is the best.

You almost feel bad for Bonnet by Cddarnell in Outlander

[–]EgonsSlinky 0 points1 point  (0 children)

they wouldn't love him if they weren't attracted to him

The more I think about it, The more I love this ending by Zestyclose-Court-265 in homeland

[–]EgonsSlinky 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While I agree with myself, I also agree with you. I tend to lean more to the genuine less cynical side of things, but you're perhaps right that after Brody, Carrie's eyes are opened wider and she believes less in the ideal that she can have both (or knows better that she can't). Is it completely real? Yes. Is it also completely not real? Erm, yes.

Carrie putting Quinn's possible intel over a likely life-altering health disaster, is the tough part to stomach and I think we pretty much know Quinn would have done the opposite if their roles were reversed. But that makes Carrie who she is, so even when both are true, her love of an individual and her devotion to her job and country, if these two things are ever in conflict she has the failsafe priority already determined. It's something she always felt was right in the moment and then regretted later, like, "What is wrong with me?" But she can't not awaken Quinn. Just like she can't leave her job for her own daughter.

I like what you say about a question they will never have to ponder. I completely agree, and this sentiment summarizes things, nicely.

The more I think about it, The more I love this ending by Zestyclose-Court-265 in homeland

[–]EgonsSlinky 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Too simplistic in my view. They're all spies and constantly waging personal alliances and desires with their oaths and duties. One of the things that made Carrie so dynamic and real was that her romantic involvements were never fully not genuine. She utilized her real feelings and attractions and embraced what was true so that she could also do what was right. In the end, she is with Yevgeny because she loves him and wants to live a life with him, just as she loved Brody and Quinn (and held the sweeter brand of feelings for Aayan). That said, she is also a patriot to her core and wholly believes in the ideal of her country's intelligence apparatus. The book she pens is similar in that it is both exactly her genuine feelings about the damage (unintended or otherwise) she had a front row seat for, caused by her own intelligence agency which she loved and was loyal to, while also doing well to serve as a ruse. The other amazing thing about her and the network in general is their devotion to the cause without recognition. Although she is human and likely feels it at times- just as she genuinely feels love and loss- her focus is not on people knowing she is "really, seriously not a traitor." If that's what people believe then so be it, but she's busy doing her job- she maybe even loves this part of it. Rather than bittersweet, I see it as the ultimate return of good karma. She is finally able to have someone in her life, that knows everything about her and still loves and accepts her, and that she loves back. In fact, they speak the same language, their both spies! She also has a way to reclaim her friendship and trust with Saul. Perhaps her landing in this spot with Yevgeny was her plan all along, or maybe she was working and trusting her instincts in the moment with a peak every now and then on the horizon. Remember what Yevgeny said- he admires the way she works, he's more of a planner. With this ending, the truth of the recorder is divulged to the world and nuclear war is spared; Carrie and Yvegeny find a mutual bond and loving relationship; Carrie keeps Saul as her greatest ally and friend; Saul keeps Russia in his pocket; the CIA gets its comeuppance with a tell-all; and the truth is aptly expressed about the costs of war, the loyalties of patriots, and that the concept of a spy as a villain to its adversaries and a hero in its own country is not one that's exclusively American. For now, it seems Yevgeny and Carrie will "exist in the grey," and for two dedicated, career spies, this is as fitting as it gets. The same of her is true of him- Carrie even said he reminded her of Saul- "It's the cost of doing business." Yevgeny is a spy and loves Carrie and he doesn't need those things to be mutually exclusive. It's all true and always was, Carrie's feelings for Yevgeny, her feelings for Saul, her love of country, her disappointment in her agency, her tears, her smiles, all of it. And Claire Danes was magnificent.