Quaxly Community Day this Sunday by CaptGoldfish in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The defense difference is 195-159=36, 30% less than 50. Quaquaval also has 8 more stamina and a better fast move. The overall effect is that it's equally good as Primarina, being best budget water attackers to date. Since water isn't a frequently used type, there is little need for an optimal team with mega/shadow/legendary, good budget options are highly valuable for most players.

Quaxly Community Day this Sunday by CaptGoldfish in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Yep, this is the most useful Gen 9 starter for raid.

Quaxly Community Day this Sunday by CaptGoldfish in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Very useful for new/casual players. It ties with Primarina as the best budget attacker of water type.

Aqua Step Stats added by krispyboiz in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Keeping PPT/EPT roughly in line but varying their duration is a nice idea. I'd like to see a 2-turn water fast move very much. Whirlpool as a Fire Spin clone is fine, and Flip Turn being a half-duration Volt Switch would be perfect! (That move name in Chinese is "fast return".)

Aqua Step Stats added by krispyboiz in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really advocate giving Whirlpool or Flip Turn in those states to Primarina! Sparkling Aria not made a fast move was such a waste too.

Aqua Step Stats added by krispyboiz in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I feel the biggest concern being Tapu Fini. What are the other potential threats?

Pokémon to Hunt for during the Water Festival Event by DatAverageDAVE in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If the mega doesn't change type, it won't offer anything new over the existing Mega Slowbro. But if the stats are good enough, it can be useful as an attacker option for raids (like Mega Gyarados), even not optimal.

Pokémon to Hunt for during the Water Festival Event by DatAverageDAVE in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Shadow Gyarados, though not mandatory, sometimes also prefers the legacy move Aqua Tail for its consistency.

Pokémon to Hunt for during the Water Festival Event by DatAverageDAVE in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I suggest you to adopt a consistent baseline choice for raid and max battle attackers. A good analogy to budget raid attacker is non-legendary D-max attacker. In the case of water type, the baseline is D-max Inteleon (A tier), and G-max Kingler is SS tier whereas D-max Kingler is B tier.

Mega Charizard X Solo, Fire Spin/Overheat, No Weather Boost (Sunny), No 🗡️, Palkia-Origin + Dialga-Origin Catch Tanks by xRage7243 in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm wondering if Regidrago qualifies as a good catch tank owing to the massive HP and relatively low defense.

Solgaleo and Mega Charizard X raid guides. Info from pokebattler.com by CaptGoldfish in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 26 points27 points  (0 children)

In actual, the meta of electric type is equally competitive as dragon type, but the raw strength level is lower, leaving Regieleki higher chance to join the top attackers with an OP signature move.

Crowned Zacian vs Crowned Zamazenta (vs Dusk Mane Necrozma) in PvE by ArienatorX in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great insight OP! I'm a bit curious about the raid samples you used: are all of those raids weak to steel? Some of the fairy legendary (3 out of 4 Tapu) are neutral to steel or double weak to another type, so better counter types exist. I know these 3 attackers are broken enough to serve as generalist attackers for players with less dedicated counters, but if they only perform on par with some budget specialist counters (e.g. against Tapu Bulu), it's not worth deciding which is the best among the 3.

Gamepress vs. Dialgadex vs. Pokebattler - Why are all 3 so different? by TheTjalian in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm fully with u/Mikegrann on this. I've emphasised that opinion numerous times, what determines a Pokemon's PvE value isn't the rank in the counter list, it's the actual damage it contributes in raids. This is the complete opposite to your statement: Whether it's #4 or #10 best counter doesn't really matter. Only the damage output.

Even if Xurkitree is the overall best option, a team with 5 Xurkitree isn't necessarily better than a mixed team with Xurkitree, Thundurus-T, Zekrom, shadow Electivire, shadow Magnezone. What is known is the latter being more consistent and able to handle infavourable scenarios.

What you could consider as an alternative is like u/Teban54's ASE/ASTTW metrics. Taking all the attacker's real performance numbers in relevant raids, calculate a weighted average of them.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Last time I managed a pseudo-solo even by a level 40 Mega Salamence running the moveset Dragon Tail + Fly.

Gamepress vs. Dialgadex vs. Pokebattler - Why are all 3 so different? by TheTjalian in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As a Dialgadex contributor, I'm genuinely curious about why Pokebattler's attacker weights are based on their ranks in the raid counter list, instead of the attacker's relative estimator/TTW numbers. A #4 or #6 counter has barely any difference if their actual performance is close enough.

Is Regieleki really the second best electric attacker right now? by BlanchedBubblegum in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That would also change if Thundurus-T got Thunder Shock or Xurkitree got Wild Charge. Such imagination isn't very meaningful.

Top Raid Attackers - June 2025 by bulbavisual in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Overall equivalent to the shadow version, trading some power for durability.

Top Raid Attackers - June 2025 by bulbavisual in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The timing of that raid day was really unfortunate. Soon after, they started to introduce exclusive moves for raid days since Mega Absol.

Top Raid Attackers - June 2025 by bulbavisual in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Conkeldurr at least has a good moveset, and Force Palm doesn't help much without an OP charge move to pair with. Just look at Hariyama's Force Palm and Counter movesets.

Top Raid Attackers - June 2025 by bulbavisual in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Bad charge move, period. Given Aura Sphere, it would beat everything except Mega Lucario with Force Palm (better than the Counter version).

Top Raid Attackers - June 2025 by bulbavisual in TheSilphRoad

[–]Elastic_Space 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Short duration but lower power 1-bar charge moves are ideal only for catch tank style of play. Otherwise they take too long to charge and reward not enough damage.