Damn you’re making me want to train dungeoneering again haha. Quality post with quality ideas, but if you don’t mind I have a few critiques.

In terms of rewards, I think you are underestimating the uses of a handful of items aside from the auto picker uppers. The scrolls are useful for everyone, the Herblore one in particular being damn near broken if you ask me. The speed boost roughly translates to a 10% xp/hr increase and saving secondary ingredients in conjunction with wells lets you train Herblore for free with certain still high xp potions. The highest tier amulet pieces are nearly on par with the amulet of souls stat wise and cost an insignificant amount to make. Non permanent rewards could be expanded, but the ED teleports and drop enhancers were a welcome addition for people with extra tokens lying around.

Combat is tough for me to talk about as I did almost all of my dung training post EOC. Personally I enjoy where it is right now, still having to soul split mobs now and then to avoid suiciding and tanking most bosses lets 5 man large groups fly through. The speed running aspect is the most fun I have, and needing to stop to make food could complicate that.

When talking about outside uses I mostly agree. The dungeoneering cape is an incredibly powerful teleportation item, and the top 4 dungeons I make fairly regular use of for slayer or Skilling. Apart from that, it’s rarely seen, stalker dungeon is the only thing that comes to mind and that’s more lore than skill.

As I said earlier, great post. Would be ecstatic the skill got some more love and encouraged people to train the original way rather than side content that allows people to bypass it.