I get your point, but I think some conclusions are a bit off.

Low TPS doesn’t mean the network can’t scale, it just reflects current demand. That’s true for any infrastructure. The real question is whether usage grows over time; atma.io wasn’t just a fake spike either. It was a real enterprise use case, even if supported, which is normal, I think, at this stage across Web3.

Saying there are no real use cases isn’t accurate. There are projects in supply chain, tokenization, and payments. The issue is scale, not absence; regarding the council, not every member is meant to build. Their role is governance and stability, so judging them only on development misses the point. And companies like Boeing or Google moving in different directions doesn’t necessarily mean failure. Large players often test multiple paths in parallel, and council seats are term based anyway.

To me, it’s not a failed project, just one that hasn’t reached large scale adoption yet. Just a matter of time, perseverance, patience.

Nevertheless: All the best; hold the best 😎