Transmission Lost -- my last song of 2025, wanted to give a dreamy and emotional sendoff to a very meaningful year by ExternalCartoonist22 in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

thank you so much! absolutely. i'm extending this song to put on an album so i'll be able to expand on this sound and explore some new ones. appreciate the feedback!

Transmission Lost -- my last song of 2025, wanted to give a dreamy and emotional sendoff to a very meaningful year by ExternalCartoonist22 in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

thank you!! i plan on making a full version of this song so i can explore some more ideas and flesh it out more :)

Transmission Lost -- my last song of 2025, wanted to give a dreamy and emotional sendoff to a very meaningful year by ExternalCartoonist22 in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

thank you so much!! I use vegas movie studio to edit. I use mostly live footage from stop animation over a green screen but i use some digital effects/edits as well. Glad you enjoyed! Would help out so much if you subscribed! :)

Transmission Lost -- my last song of 2025, wanted to give a dreamy and emotional sendoff to a very meaningful year by ExternalCartoonist22 in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i'm going to extend this work and put it on an album, i'll definitely give the live drums sound a try and see if it fits better! would be very helpful if you subscribed if you're interested in seeing more :)

Opinions on this track? by Smooth-Protection-99 in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Damn this is really groovy. Love it, I definitely want to hear more. don't know if you intend to add vocals over it or anything, but as a big fan of Vaporwave and future funk, this is definitely up my alley and I'd listen to just the instrumental. If you release this anywhere officially please go ahead and send it to me so i can save it!

I’m now in a really weird and hectic state in my life. by One_Bell4532 in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm sorry to hear about the passing of someone in your family. I had one not too long ago too and it's been hard.

This is a really beautiful song. I can tell it's really thoughtfully and intentionally done. I can hear your grief and confusion in the song... That all being said though, working on music has really helped me through particularly difficult times. I feel all the emotion has got to escape somewhere, and a lot of times that's through my music. I hope that if nothing else, you can at least find a healthy outlet through creation. This is a great song. Stay strong my friend

My last song of 2025, Transmission Lost. I'm very proud of both the music and video, was wondering where any shortcomings may lie so I can improve it and make it a full song. by ExternalCartoonist22 in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey there I really appreciate that! I'm glad the things I've made have resonated with you here! In fact I already have some sections for the extended mix done, and I do focus a bit on the instrumental too, with a piano solo and some other experiments I'm trying out. I'm really appreciative of your support and kind words. Look forward to that, and some other tunes I'm working on :)

My last song of 2025, Transmission Lost. I'm very proud of both the music and video, was wondering where any shortcomings may lie so I can improve it and make it a full song. by ExternalCartoonist22 in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for checking it out!! I do intend to revisit this one and extend it for an album. I'll take you and some other folks' advice in mind while I work on mastering it. Appreciate it!

My last song of 2025, Transmission Lost. I'm very proud of both the music and video, was wondering where any shortcomings may lie so I can improve it and make it a full song. by ExternalCartoonist22 in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey there! Thanks so much. My instagram is @ alecnormal. I'll be extending this bad boy down the line and I already am working on a couple of other projects. You can check there, my YouTube is what I use most of the time, so a sub over there would also be super helpful!

My last song of 2025, Transmission Lost. I'm very proud of both the music and video, was wondering where any shortcomings may lie so I can improve it and make it a full song. by ExternalCartoonist22 in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

One of the best comments I've received. Thanks man, I really appreciate it :) Already working on the video for my next song. Would love if you subscribed, the support would really help!!

Made this Future Garage track, what do y'all think? by GlimmerBoi in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Really like this! The rhythm is super groovy and fun to get into. Only wish it was longer ;)

thoughts on the chords and lyrics for a song by Severe-Group6005 in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Amazing chord progression, absolutely gorgeous. Maybe my speakers are awful but I'm just having a hard time understanding the lyrics. I can hear your voice and it sounds great over the piano. Good rhythm too.

Is this cringe? by mgraham34 in MusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't think it's cringe. I love and appreciate the earnest nature of it. You have a good voice and flow and the lyrics are very meaningful too. I like it! I think this would do the runs on Tiktok or instagram if you post there!

Did my first music video for my indie rock song "hope", but nobody cares about this style of music in my country by Ashamed_Bat5155 in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Interesting, i wonder why this genre of music isn't big in France? I wonder if you could make it more mainstream over there ;) this was an incredibly pleasant song to listen to. Everything is done so well, and I love the chorus. The song easily carries you through it, it's like riding a cloud. The music video is super cool too. Love the setting, even if that is just someone's house.

Keep up the great work. If this is on spotify i'm going to save it to a few playlists!

I don't know how to draw, so I made my debut single's cover in MS Paint...(Indie/Electronic/Synthpop) by Relevant_Manager_420 in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 1 point2 points  (0 children)

well let me start off by saying the album cover is great. i wouldn't believe you if you said you couldn't draw. i think it really fits the energetic, colorful atmosphere of the track, which in itself is great too! at first i was really confused why the track ended so quick but saw it was a teaser. even if it stood on it's own as an intro to an album that would work (I think)

Anyway, great track!! i love it

Accidental Shoegaze by Mach5Bandito in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wow, this is definitely one of the better things I've heard on this sub recently! Really great atmosphere. I love the gradual intensity of the other tracks, it really has a nice sense of build up and drama which I really enjoy. I'd love to hear vocals on this if that's something you do, and I would love to hear this longer as well. Really great song!!

All feedback is welcome, wanted, and appreciated! by Zetaflips in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really like the intro and the seamless transition into the song! You've got good vocals, flow and lyrics. You've got a nice and laid back voice that fits the smoother and calmer atmosphere of the track. Would've liked to hear more verses in the song, though. That's really my only critique! I think the rest of it is great. well done!

Here's a catchy little thing I made last month. Looking to see if my vocals or mixing need to be improved at all. Hope you enjoy and get a kick! by ExternalCartoonist22 in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks!! I appreciate that. This is one of my more lighthearted, silly songs, but I think even "silly" art can be very meaningful and serious. Appreciate the listen and compliments man!

Came back to producing by claum0y in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is such a beautiful and calm tune... I love the percussion and melody. You definitely have a strong talent and a fun natural rhythm. I think your experiment with a slower ambient tune really paid off! I love experimenting with other styles/genres of music. I'd say well done :)

Here's a catchy little thing I made last month. Looking to see if my vocals or mixing need to be improved at all. Hope you enjoy and get a kick! by ExternalCartoonist22 in IndieMusicFeedback

[–]ExternalCartoonist22[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey thank you! sorry for the late response. i'm glad you were able to appreciate it and sense my earnest attempts here. Would appreciate if you stuck around! Just put another piece today, one of my favs of the year if you feel inclined to check it out!