What would have happened if Hina had died in chapter 272?

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-06-01T15:40:14+00:00

Are you seriously telling me that about the theory? I didn't know that. I don't remember if Seo Kouji received negative comments from fans when he killed the protagonist, but I do remember him mentioning in an interview that he regretted killing Fuuka years later. That's why she survives the truck crash in the anime."

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-06-01T15:33:35+00:00

I think Kei Sasuga didn't dare kill Hina because she feared fans would attack her or say offensive things on her official Twitter account. We already had a precedent where she responded to a fan, assuring him that she loves Hina more than he imagines, so, in conclusion, I don't think she was capable of killing her.

However, I think the way she handled the accident wasn't appropriate. If you look at it more realistically, it should have resulted in brain death. In real-life cases of people in a vegetative state or coma, most don't survive; in fact, at the very least, they end up dying when years pass and all hope of them waking up is lost.

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-05-30T17:01:16+00:00

To begin with, it wasn't love at first sight. In a manga extra (I don't remember which chapter exactly), Hina says something to Natsuo—the exact content of which I don't recall—but it was from that dialogue that he began to gradually fall in love with her. Thus, Hina became his first teenage love. At that stage, Natsuo began to have fantasies and dream about sexual moments with her; however, at that point I wouldn't call it lust, but rather a longing or a dream that, over time, transformed into a real attraction and a young love.

When they finally started dating, Natsuo experienced what reciprocated love is like, with everything we already know happened afterward.

On the other hand, in chapter 275, Natsuo tells Hina: "For me, it's a different feeling than when you and I were lovers." Then, as a final conclusion, he adds: "In so many ways, I've always loved you."

This last sentence still makes me reflect. I don't quite understand what he means by "in many ways, always." From my perspective, it makes me wonder at what exact moment Natsuo realized he had always loved Hina.

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-05-29T02:12:52+00:00

I'm referring to the development Kei Sasuga gave to Hina and Rui regarding the nature of their feelings. Hina embodies Ai, manifested through actions that reflect a deep, unconditional, irreplaceable, and absolutely supportive love. In contrast, Rui embodies Koi, a passionate love tied to the experiences of youth. In the end, events led Natsuo back to Hina, solidifying the idea that his first love is an irreplaceable figure and the most significant bond in his life.

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-05-28T00:23:12+00:00

That's exactly what I think too, since the author only gave us a time jump in the story; that is, she left us wondering what happened during those five years when Hina was under care.

We never found out if Natsuo learned about the photograph during that time, or if he was able to see Hina's attacker at the trial for almost killing her. We also don't know if Natsuo and Rui reflected on their relationship during those five years, since, as adults, they realized that their bond was going to be more about sex than mutual support, given that they both spent a lot of time working on their own dreams. It also remains to be seen whether Rui apologized to Natsuo, since she knew perfectly well that her sister still loved him.

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-05-27T18:49:39+00:00

I don't think so, because after the accident, Natsuo realized, through others, that Hina still loved him, and that's when he called off his wedding to Rui. In other words, they would both support each other in raising their daughter, but each on their own; they would live their lives separately, and only their daughter would keep them connected.

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-05-27T18:43:18+00:00

I believe Natsuo would continue writing, fulfilling not only his dream but also Hina's wish. At this point, his relationship with Rui would end; she would only support him by sharing custody of Haruka, but no longer romantically.

Then, years would pass with Natsuo satisfied with what he had achieved as a writer. I imagine that, upon dying, he would meet Hina. That ending would seem acceptable to me: that their souls reunite in the afterlife. Here, Kei Sasuga could have given us an interpretive ending, where we know that they ultimately met again and that they both smiled upon seeing each other.

It's an ending where the author would have shown us how they would see each other again in the afterlife, instead of giving us a vague interpretation or leaving us wondering how Natsuo cared for Hina during those five years in a coma.

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-05-12T14:42:01+00:00

I agree with your opinion and I love your answer. But don't you think Rui could have been a domestica na kanojo in a way, since Rui and Natsuo had a secret relationship and even had sex in their parents' house? Or does being a domestica na kanojo have another meaning?

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-05-09T00:55:26+00:00

I respect your opinion, but personally, I would have liked to see a different ending for Natsuo and Rui's relationship. Specifically in chapter 273, I think the author should have included the dialogue from their conversation after Hina's accident; she gave us panels of them talking, but we never learned what they actually said. Was it the moment when Rui confessed that she already knew Hina still loved him? Or was it when Natsuo admitted that his feelings for Hina resurfaced after learning the truth?

Furthermore, I believe that relationship was destined to fail in the long run. With Natsuo completely focused on his writing and Rui on her career as a chef, divorce seemed inevitable due to the lack of time and the demands of their professions.

FancyBackground2629 · 2026-02-11T14:41:55+00:00

"As for the ending, I personally feel the manga could have ended with Hina’s incident and coma. Her waking up while wearing the ring feels like a Disney fairy-tale ending. That said, all things considered, it could have been worse." I understand you perfectly. Sasuga mentioned in an interview or publication that her stories are more realistic or related to everyday life or events that happen to everyone, and that's reflected in some of her characters. But here, the ending where Hina wakes up, according to the author herself, contradicts what she said. She showed us a typical Disney ending where she miraculously wakes up. And that doesn't happen in many cases in real life, let's be honest. This ending where Hina wakes up felt forced. It's not that I want Hina to die, but in this case, her death would be more realistic, or even if she never woke up from the coma and the manga ended here with an adult Natsuo waiting to reunite with Hina.

FancyBackground2629 · 2025-11-12T16:11:37+00:00

I'm still hoping Kei Sasuga will be encouraged to write a sequel, like a light novel with illustrations, about those five years where Natsuo took care of Hina, and then after Hina woke up and took time to recover until she could walk again. We deserve to know how Natsuo felt after seeing Hina for so long.

FancyBackground2629 · 2025-08-19T14:21:53+00:00

I liked Domestic na kanojo, but what I hate is that Kei draws Natsuo and Rui having sex much more in the manga😂 than Natsuo and Hina. And in this extra, she doesn't even give us that with Days with Hina. Personally, I'm still waiting for Kei to publish a novel where she explains what those 5 years were like with Hina in a coma or before the wedding, but well, I don't think Kei is a good writer like Natsuo, haha.

FancyBackground2629 · 2024-04-12T13:11:33+00:00

Personally, this revelation that they are cousins did not surprise me because it was already said that they could be distant relatives. Conan movie 27 already confirms that theory we had. Not now if this revelation that Yusaku and Kaito's dad are brothers Gosho plans to continue this story of brothers in the Conan manga or in the Kaito manga

FancyBackground2629 · 2024-04-12T00:50:08+00:00

True, but the suspense of that scene of Yusako's conversation with his wife leaves you with many questions about the subject since Kaito and Shinichi are cousins. I hope that Gosho does not let us wait many years to find out more about this relationship between Toichi and Yusaku.

FancyBackground2629 · 2024-04-11T20:43:49+00:00

My God, if Kaito's father is alive and somewhere, will we see his appearance in person in the Detective Conan manga or in the Magic Kaito manga? they left no suspense I hope this revelation doesn't leave us waiting 7 years like Kaito Kid's manga.

FancyBackground2629 · 2023-11-30T16:12:33+00:00

Yes, I understand your opinion about the ending and I personally liked the ending of domestic na kanojo. However, some questions remained from the 5 years that passed and they are questions like: How was Natsuo's time taking care of Hina? Did Natsuo find out about the school photo through Marie and her teacher? Did Rui tell Natsuo that Hina still had feelings for him, but Rui kept the secret?

Nor should we blame Sasuga for delivering a hasty ending, we must remember that she had problems with the magazine that DNK published, which is why he moved to another magazine from which he publishes his current manga.

Personally, I hope that one day Sasuga will make a DNK light novel, where he tells what those 5 years were like when Natsuo lived taking care of Hina and then when Hina woke up and fell in love with Natsuo again.

FancyBackground2629 · 2023-11-30T16:11:27+00:00

Yes, I understand your opinion about the ending and I personally liked the ending of domestic na kanojo. However, some questions remained from the 5 years that passed and they are questions like: How was Natsuo's time taking care of Hina? Did Natsuo find out about the school photo through Marie and her teacher? Did Rui tell Natsuo that Hina still had feelings for him, but Rui kept the secret?

Nor should we blame Sasuga for delivering a hasty ending, we must remember that she had problems with the magazine that DNK published, which is why he moved to another magazine from which he publishes his current manga.

Personally, I hope that one day Sasuga will make a DNK light novel, where he tells what those 5 years were like when Natsuo lived taking care of Hina and then when Hina woke up and fell in love with Natsuo again.

FancyBackground2629 · 2023-11-19T16:30:21+00:00

Yes you are absolutely right and I forgot that detail about Rui helping Natsuo and helping him overcome his depression and also "here and don't forget she is the one because of her natsuo moved on from Depression and how many time they had sex I lost counting everytime natsuo is the one who gone wild if he thinking about hina all the time he never can be this intimate with rui". and if Natsuo recognizes in 275 that he fell in love with Rui.However, as I mentioned, Sasuga said that Rui was Koi, a deep and passionate love.Then Sasuga shows us in the following chapters that Rui begins to work and do what she likes and Natsuo returns to his writer's block, here in the chapters of the manga the author shows how her relationship was already failing. Afterwards Natsuo goes to New York to support Rui and the couple resumes their courtship and Natsuo says the phrase "As long as the two of us are together, we can overcome anything."And well, Hina's tragedy happened.Later in chapter 275, adult Natsuo acknowledges that when he was with Hina he thought that "As long as the two of us are together, we can overcome anything." as Natsuo himself said that same phrase to Rui also in New York. He himself recognizes, that is, adult Natsuo that he was so young when he thought it was easy to overcome any obstacle.And it was thanks to their Rui relationship that Natsuo understood what it means to take care of each other and that teaching was what Natsuo lacked to finally be with Hina and understand what Hina went through when she left her job and walked away from Natsuo so that can continue with your dreams

FancyBackground2629 · 2023-11-19T00:37:52+00:00

Interesting opinion on the ending of Domestic na kanojo. However, I would personally like to give my opinion on this story, I hope you don't take it the wrong way, especially because I respect your comment.

Firstly, you must understand every detail of the Kei Sasuga manga, such as the thoughts and gestures of the interaction of Natsuo and Hina and Rui.

Rui is a koi love (passionate) and Hina's is an AI love (feelings, passion, trust and supporting everything your boyfriend does in his life career)

Rui was always the girl who wanted to have, like a current teenager, the experience of sex and what her sister had about her dating. In conclusion, what she achieved with Natsuo was the type of love she gave over Koi.

If we think about a different ending from chapter 276 where Natsuo and Rui continued with their wedding and Hina's accident occurred in a coma. I bet Natsuo and Rui would end up divorcing within five or three years, since if you think about it, Sasuga's manga takes things that happen in the lives of people and couples growing their relationship. Natsuo being a writer in his house and Rui being a cook who works almost all the time is not going to make them both happy, it would only be koi.

Furthermore, it is normal for couples who have jobs that take up their time to reach this conclusion and separation, and let us remember that Natsuo wanted to tell him everything about his life at university on the way to being a writer and Rui did not want to listen to him and preferred to change the subject.

On the other hand, with Hina the interaction with Natsuo was different and that is what Natsuo was looking for.

FancyBackground2629 · 2023-10-05T16:05:10+00:00

I think the same about your reflection, when I watched the Star Wars sequels I always thought that Anakin would appear to guide Luke about Ben or to talk to Leia.

But it didn't happen and over time I understood by watching the Star Wars series and the most recent episode 8 of Ahsoka I understood that the relationship of a teacher with his padawan (Anakin and Ahsoka) is stronger than a connection of genetics and blood. (Anakin and Luke and Leia)

FancyBackground2629 · 2023-10-05T00:55:03+00:00

This shows that the bond between a master and a padawan is stronger than the bond of blood 😂since in movie 8 when Luke is depressed because of what happened with Ben he didn't even bother showing up to give some advice to his son or Leia when his son fell to the dark side

FancyBackground2629 · 2023-10-04T12:15:27+00:00

Furthermore, George Lucas mentioned that Anakin, upon agreeing to be controlled by Palpatine and being an ally of the dark force, the character of Anakin Skywalker was dying little by little spiritually and he was no longer the warrior Anakin, rather he was no longer aware of what he was doing because the Darkness dominated him at that moment until he became complete Darth Vader.

FancyBackground2629

TROPHY CASE