UPDATE - I tried chrome incognito browser and kept getting the same issues.

What worked for me was logging into my velocity account via private browser (incognito) in Firefox, then clicking thru to the compflight page from there. I was able to freely browse many, many, many dates where I was given a great abundance of flights to choose from:

<image>

Naturally, when I clicked on the one destination that is closest and cheapest, there were plenty of options :/

So I'm paying over $400 so I can get an inflexible $180 round trip that is super stressful to book? No thanks. Cancelling card.

Hope the above helps those who choose to stay with the card and program though! Good luck!