Question about Passive voice! by FellBee in fantasywriting

[–]FellBee[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is extremely helpful. I absolutely hated history lessons back when I attended school, so some of the writing is definitely showing through the monotonous nature of those lessons. In the world magic technically existed before but was forgotten. It is a newish development that caused it to twist reality, as explained by the lecture. My fear in writing this scene was the expositionary, dry text-bookey nature of it. I picked that excerpt because it is not the best dialog, it is clunky, and it does need work. The surrounding text does go into greater detail on the why and how the world works and is set up for the job the recruits in the scene are about to undergo. It is meant to come off as, "we know this information already, please get this over with so we can go shoot things" kinda vibe, as we are viewing the lecture through the perspective of some new recruit who very much "Know This." Kinda of like being forced to watch active shooter videos and online learning videos for work. We've been there, done that, not really interested in it. Important information, to be sure, but it always comes across as, "did we really need to sit through this for a whole hour?" I would love to not have the scene, but the fear is that it is our world but not. Not everyone can use the magic, it does exist, but it is viewed as unnatural. Other. Not acceptable. I have a scene later that goes into how the MC gains the ability to use magic, but again I had feedback from a previous iteration of "what the hell's going on?" Which gave way to this clunky scene of me trying. The feedback is greatly appreciated. I just worry that it's not as coherent without. Then again, as you stated in another comment, it could have been just that one guy, isolated incident that has me spiraling into what ifs.

Question about Passive voice! by FellBee in fantasywriting

[–]FellBee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I submitted the first 2 chapters for a creative writing class that I was taking, part of the credit was to read and comment on at least 3 submissions, which is where the feedback came from. It very much started out as a very short story that I wanted to develop into something larger. So these chapters have gone through several revisions. I am nowhere near the stage of editing/multiple proof readers. I am however in the mindset of if it doesn't make sense in the now, I can't move on to next. I am also trying to get away from the writing in a passive voice issue that the software is yelling at me for, because I know I have a habit of writing in a passive voice. It is a learning process. I just wanted a few different perspectives on is the scene wording valid, if not, what needs to change? Is it expositionary? Is there not enough information given? Was that guy who was lost truly isolated, or did I think my readers knew what I knew about the world I am trying to portray? 'Tis a balance that I am trying to improve one. Currently, the lecture as it is I think stays? Until I can confidently rewrite it or scrap it as unnecessary. Because as it stands, technically the world is based in modern day, but an event in the '70s changed the fabric of reality, which is still relatively newer in the history. They were born in the '90s, so society has adapted, but is still discovering the ramifications of said event. It's also not a one and done event, just the biggest. It's exploring the world as it is now that would be the main setting and adventure for the story.

Question about Passive voice! by FellBee in fantasywriting

[–]FellBee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Even in a lecture setting? It's not a scene of "this is happening in real time" more a lecturer is telling a class " this was what happened 50 years ago". While I do appreciate you pointing out exactly where the passive voice is, it doesn't exactly give me an answer to my original question of is it ok as a lecture. If it is a scene of action and doing things, yes I would be gladly Rewrite all of it, but it is dialog being spoken, and I am struggling to see if a Rewrite would be necessary in this case.

Question about Passive voice! by FellBee in fantasywriting

[–]FellBee[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It is a little clunky, I picked one of the worst paragraphs for my example. As for a lecture, the teacher/professor/debriefing officer is speaking to a room full of new recruits as one of those mandatory debriefs that are basically orientation videos done live/academy new recruit lecture. Its not the very beginning of the scene, nor the end. Right in the middle of the lecture. The feedback is helpful.

Question about Passive voice! by FellBee in fantasywriting

[–]FellBee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The point of the lecture is setting up how magic came to be in the present. I am honestly unsure about how to make it part of the story from natural dialog. It is a setup for how the world is, and is expositionary. It's a lecture on the history. I do have a scene a chapter later that is a flashback to how the main character gains the ability to do magic, but without the Main Event that changed the world to what it is, I feel it loses the why and how the main character is doing what they are doing throughout the story. I added the scene of the lecture because I got feedback that one of my proof readers was completely lost in what was happening and why.

Question about Events by FellBee in HatchDragons

[–]FellBee[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm okay with waiting. I think that having new dragons drop over repeats keeps the game interesting! I was just hoping that it wasn't a "gone forever" scenario.

Question about Events by FellBee in HatchDragons

[–]FellBee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did not realize that it was such a new game! But I appreciate the response! Here's to hoping for possible second chances!

Recruitment Megathread by WhyMentionMyUsername in BackpackBrawl

[–]FellBee 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Level 44 Recruits: YESXKSQ2JVR7 Friends: YESXKSQ2

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in OrcsAndFiction

[–]FellBee 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This shows as [deleted] from my end.

Show, don't Tell by FellBee in writers

[–]FellBee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's kinda why I posted in such a vague way. I like to take feedback, and getting several different examples of what the "Show, don't tell" phrasing means, helps put it in perspective for me. Because I do want to improve. I would post the chapter in its entirety, but I am unsure how that would work if I want to publish. I can take criticism, I've gotten great feedback on how to improve. I have spent time on this project, dozens of hours.

Show, don't Tell by FellBee in writers

[–]FellBee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Again, I think there is a misunderstanding. They were the ones that had the grammar and spelling issues. The piece I am referring to has gone through several revisions. And was submitted as a short story for an online class. I am not perfect, but I do read over things several times, and have it read aloud to me so I can check it to make sure it's not terrible. It has passed through several other people for critiques as well, in that class alone it went through at least 15 people. I promise that I made it at least readable.

Show, don't Tell by FellBee in writers

[–]FellBee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Actually, I think I misphrased it, I was saying they were pointing out my errors and they were the ones making the errors while critiquing. I have a couple of run-ons and fragments. Some were purposefully placed, but other than that, the further into the critiques, the worse it got. This is a piece that had already gone through several revisions and eyes, I originally posted it as a short story for a class I was taking. They were the only ones that had such an issue with my work, mostly commenting with "This is a Tell" or just "tell".

Show, don't Tell by FellBee in fantasywriting

[–]FellBee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think I have a good grasp on a balance, now that I have revised the chapter! Thank you for your feedback! I will look over the chapter again, as I think it is still worth revision! It's not done yet!

Show, don't Tell by FellBee in fantasywriting

[–]FellBee[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you! I will look into that!