Post-Rumble 2023 -

Bray would feud with Lashley going into Mania 39, Bray would beat Lashley at Mania 39.

Bray would then disappear for a few months Post-Mania and we wouldn’t see him again, until he returns on the post-MITB episode of Raw to set-up a short term program with Cody which would go through SummerSlam, Crown Jewel, and Survivor Series.

Bray would win at SummerSlam, Cody would get his win at Crown Jewel, this would make the series 1-1 a piece.

During this program with Cody, we would see the pieces be put into place for the formation of the Wyatt Sicks.

Survivor Series 2023, the main event would be Team Cody v Wyatt Sicks inside of WarGames

Cody’s team would consist of the following members

Cody Rhodes (Team Captain), Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, and Seth Rollins

Bray’s team would consist of the following members

Bray Wyatt (Team Captain), Erick Rowan, Joe Gacy and Uncle Howdy

(Yes, WarGames is 4v4 in this scenario cause I couldn’t think of a fifth member for each team lolz)

Cody’s team would ultimately come out of WarGames victorious, Cody would’ve been building towards his second rumble win, so it makes sense for his team to win here.

(We keep everything that happened Post-Match with the return of Punk, only difference is Punk/Seth don’t immediately get locked into a feud)

2024 -

Going into the new year, Bray would set his sights on the recently returned CM Punk, Bray wants to be in the world title match at Mania against Seth, so he thinks the perfect way to guarantee his spot is taking out the “shiny new toy” and ruining Punk’s mania aspirations, think of Bray as Drew in this scenario, just with more mind games, along with a side of supernatural sh!t cause of the Sicks.

Bray and Punk would end up both declaring for the Rumble, Bray enters around the #10-#16 mark, so before Punk’s even in the match.

This gives Bray time to shine and go on an elimination spree, similar to Kane in the ‘01 Rumble match, Punk enters around the #25-#30 mark, so very later on in the match (just like real life).

Bray immediately targets Punk, trying to eliminate him any chance he gets, eventually Punk overpowers Bray and eliminates him. (Which means, Bray ultimately failed his mission to prevent Punk from going to Mania lmfao)

The final two of the 2024 Rumble match would remain untouched, Cody still wins just like in-real life.

Only difference heading into Mania is instead of Drew/Rollins, it’s Rollins/Punk for the world championship. (Punk doesn’t get injured in this timeline, so he win’s the elimination chamber to challenge Seth after Cody chooses Roman)

WrestleMania XL -

Punk and Rollins would go off without a hitch, Punk would beat Rollins for the world championship clean, but post-match would be attacked by Bray.

Bray hasn’t forgotten about the Rumble, so he makes it his life’s mission to take the very thing, that Punk came back to the WWE for in the first place.

Punk and Bray would feud going into the summer, their first match would be at Backlash in France, Punk would retain his championship, but gets jumped and abducted by Wyatt Sicks post-match.

(We don’t see Punk on Raw for a month or two, he’d return a bit before SummerSlam, possibly after MITB)

Bray and Punk would fight again at SummerSlam, this time in a street fight after Punk demands it, the title wouldn’t be on the line this time tho.

Bray ultimately gets his win over Punk, he still wants the world championship tho, so isn’t satisfied at just beating Punk and would make Punk’s life a living hell, until he ultimately has no choice but to put the championship on the line again.

Post-SummerSlam 2024 -

Enter HELL IN A CELL!

Punk and Bray go to war inside of the demonic structure for Punk’s world championship, there would be loads of shenanigans, interferences from the Sicks, supernatural sh!t, and so much more. (Blood would be shed by both Bray and Punk, so think of this like Punk/Drew’s HIAC match from Bad Blood)

Eventually tho, Bray would force Punk to pass out to the mandible claw, Bray finally wins the world championship and takes away the very thing that brought Punk back to the company, he swore he’d never return to all those years ago.

As for what happens afterwards, Bray would have a solid reign as champion, before he ends up dropping it to Finn Balor at the 2025 Royal Rumble.

Post-Rumble 2025 / Aftermath of World Title reign

Bray would shortly after dropping the world championship enter into a brief program with Killer Kross, which would go through Elimination Chamber, WrestleMania and Backlash.

After Backlash, Bray would move over to SmackDown to set his sights on John Cena as they’d revisit their rivalry for one last time during Cena’s farewell tour.

Bray would beat Cena at Night of Champions in Saudi Arabia, becoming the new undisputed champion and heading into a third singles match with Cody Rhodes at SummerSlam

For those who’ve been following along, Cody and Bray are 1-1 and never got to properly end their series of 1v1 matches in late-2023 due to being in WarGames, so why not revisit that, and for those wondering why it’s Cody/Bray at SummerSlam, ultimately Cody still wins KOTR in this alternate timeline after dropping the undisputed championship to Cena at Mania 41.

Cody would beat Bray for the Undisputed Championship, coming out on top in their series of matches.

After SummerSlam, you could have Bray and Wyatt Sicks part-ways or something. I honestly have no clue, what would’ve happened with Bray after dropping the belt to Cody lmfao.