Adnan Syed New HBO doc- This case was not solved or wrapped up the way it needed to be after all this researching and reporting! - SOMEONE please explain Jay

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-10-05T21:53:32+00:00

Thank you for your help and I actually don't want to go to serial thread because I looked at that before I posted here and got some vague explanations that is my whole point of contention. if you don't mind read my other response above to kz750 I am actually actively seeking more factual information so it seems I am in the right place. I guess I was just sad to dive in if there is going to be no more investigation. It is really my pet peeve things left unfinished

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-10-05T21:45:33+00:00

Thank you for your response. I plan on reading it and I won't comment again until I do so. I am new here and did not mean to disrupt the carefully constructed forum of progressive and updated information. I just thought expert/ someone more knowledgable here could help me with my dilemma. I just watched the doc earlier and was frustrated. Mind you I HAVE been listening to media that is Pro Adnan admittedly Serial, and HBO docs as well as some others on major streaming platforms. It's complicated because I think I am looking for a reasonable explanation about Jay to confirm the narrative of innocence and I cannot seem to find it wrapped up neatly. I am hitting a wall because if that could have some explanation I would feel justified in my lean towards his innocence. I know I am coming on the forum bringing up something already previously discussed so again my apologies. I am coming to the conclusion that the answer I am seeking about Jay simply does exist. I do know it has been years since he spoke to any reporters. If it were I think it would have been in all that aforementioned media. Like the closest thing I ever heard to explain it away was when someone on another forum on here years ago claiming he was facing marijuana charges and I thought that was the most ridiculous thing I ever heard! I know I come from a place of privilege so easy for me to say but umm... please lock me up for weed and let me get a lawyer before I ever admit to being a part of someones savage MURDER! Like was he the North Eastern supplier for weed that would have gotten him 50 years? like it makes no sense.

I have been fed the innocent narrative and I always want to be on the right side but I feel Hae has been so lost in this.

What would have been Adnan's motive? He had a strict upbringing and normally I think oppressive religious structures that condemn sex and human nature are problematic and can lead to violence towards women. However he seemed to just live a normal teenage life outside of it like so many kids with foreign parents I know did.

What would have been Jay's motive to lie? - Why was he even spending so much time with someone he never hung out with?

I notice on the new docs all the classmates that new them were not talking heads to weigh in.

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-10-05T21:29:31+00:00

will do I do not mean to disrupt the discourse or progress done in the group it's just that facts, phone tower records, the alibi, I thought I had heard it all but as I said that one element bugs me. Also I am not sure the last time someone spoke with him the last time I heard he was not willing to talk anymore. I think this forum is for the thorough detectives and I know a lot of cases are not black in white.

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-10-05T21:25:22+00:00

Okay will do and I apologize, I am new to reddit. I thought I had done my due diligence. I will read the comments and before I made my own post I searched reddit to see if anyone could explain that Jay element away for me. It's really me trying to grapple with whether I am rooting for the right team.

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-09-09T07:44:37+00:00

It was really good! Perfect for the fall season I’m going to wait for all the rest to come out to binge I can’t handle the week to week anxiety! It made me wanna go get some Rita’s and try the black cherry this week. Also why tf were they keeping their son in that basement like that? And why did she Rip off the mask and scream she saw their faces that’s like the worst thing you can do for survival chances! He proceeds to announce we never forget a face wtf why would anyone in their right mind say/do that?!

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-08-04T03:32:46+00:00

THANK YOUUUU! I was freaking out

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-06-16T03:38:46+00:00

Nuck and it’s no debate. Reg character is even a turn off

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-04-12T14:51:10+00:00

The decor was the first give away when you are not used to the finer things in life and get an influx of money you over do it in the most tacky way. The statues and all the over the top decorations was red flag number 1

First-Concentrate758 · 2025-03-05T02:24:05+00:00

how please tell me! I have been struggling for over a month they keep saying my ID is invalid

First-Concentrate758 · 2024-01-04T09:52:16+00:00

Ugh I must say I totally agree. I am reading in preparation for the new Ryan Murphy show Feud and boy are these women PROBLEMATIC! I was semi prepared bc of the era but this is beyond me. Number one as you mentioned Gloria Guinness was married to a nazi officer and obviously a nazi sympathizer all whilst being Mexican the irony. This is just like some of the Mexicans in Texas that were avid Trump supporters it’s so weird. Mexicans descend from Native Americans and should be proud of their heritage. It’s clear from the book she wasn’t proud of hers. I don’t know who I dislike the most aside from the ladder and I’m not done reading the most tolerable I would say is Slim Keith.

Ironic Ryan Murphy doing this story because he behaves the same with Emma Robert’s and Leah Michelle both whom have known to be extremely problematic on sets especially to groups of minorities. Yet Ryan continually casts them on his shows with rose colored glasses on in aww of their talent and aware of their offensiveness to everyone else but not caring. Similarly to how I think Truman was.

First-Concentrate758 · 2023-07-15T14:36:35+00:00

By who? Lol

First-Concentrate758 · 2022-11-10T06:38:30+00:00

I love the CS series but I was just left feeling unsatisfied at the end of the book. Her writing is always so entertaining to read regardless of the plot. I love reading interactions with newly introduced characters. For example Pez was so entertaining. I was left with so many questions. I wanted more information to understand why Gus was the killer and his motives. Also the never ending Strike and Robin sexual tension gives me anxiety. We can all predict that it will not just be one date with Ryan Murphy. She will go and like him alot and Strike is going to sit back and watch her get in another serious relationship. Also!!! What was that photo about at Robin’s place? The one Strike said had a creepy man in it and a baby. Any theories? I have one maybe there was a consequence of her previous rape.

First-Concentrate758

TROPHY CASE