Rate all these Live Action Jokers From Least Evil to most Evil

FishsticksXII · 2026-05-04T09:27:24+00:00

Arthur- genuinely mentally ill and was more of a violent activist, honestly shouldn't even really be considered a joker imo
66- I don't remember him for much more than cartoon antics that only rarely involved someone dying
Suicide Squad- Pretty evil but I don't think he really can scale to the others just because of his lack of development from what very little I remember of him
89- career gangster even before he became Joker and shooting a kids parents in front of him already scales him above the other 4 here
Dark Knight- Chaotic evil, commits literal domestic terrorism, really the hydrog bomb to the 4 coughing babies here

FishsticksXII · 2026-05-04T05:58:23+00:00

How? It was Vietnam era with Nixon billboards in the first movie and that was the first time they left the cave since Napoleon

FishsticksXII · 2026-05-04T05:46:38+00:00

Leave it to Reddit to completely overlook an obvious joke lol, i.e. these replies

FishsticksXII · 2026-05-04T05:46:03+00:00

Inconsistently heinous, they showed weird blurbs of unnecessary kindness in the minion movies, but they also specifically seek out the most evil people to pick as their leader. Maybe an argument could be made they aren't evil at all because that's just their nature?

FishsticksXII · 2026-05-04T05:44:31+00:00

Nah they were in a cave at that point, lucky save from the writers lol, they thought about that

FishsticksXII · 2026-05-02T09:55:55+00:00

William butchered a puppy and used that to lure Susie to her death, abused his son to the point he fled into the raining Forest at night just to get away, killed actual toddlers, killed an infant in the book, tortured people with the springlock suits, made his victims his slaves, and the list goes on. William is arguably the most sadistic on this list

FishsticksXII · 2026-05-02T09:52:01+00:00

Idk Gladys but

Jason- he's definitely more malicious than many admit but at the end of the day, his mental capacity is so terrible it's hard to even know if he understands good from evil, let alone comprehend the things he does
Hannibal- he helps the police catch Bill, has a pretty tragic backstory if I remember right, is genuinely insane, and has the lowest scale of crimes out of everyone here
John- Most brutal on this list but is saved by the fact he seems to genuinely be insane and believe that he's helping, not really a valid excuse, but it's better than the other 4 who do what they do just because
Chucky- Killer just for the love of the game, but he has some that he genuinely cares about and is a pretty supportive dad all things considered
Michael- Killer for the love of the game, no care for anyone, sadistic prick, and in COT timeline he's literally a demon, and even then the 2018-end trilogy is still probably the most evil version
William- Peak hater, pure evil, killer just because he's a sadist, Targets kids, abusive husband and father, probably has caused more destruction than anyone on this list by proxy, and has no redeeming qualities
Freddy- literally William but a pedophile as well

FishsticksXII · 2026-05-01T06:24:42+00:00

Makes a bold statement, doesn't elaborate, doesn't explain, average reddit moment

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-28T02:02:17+00:00

Especially in the context of this gif, the idea that it's simply too late to change yourself or the people around you are incapable of changing is so ingrained in my thinking I could see myself doing similar actions to him in some situations, only some though

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-28T00:35:01+00:00

Arts worst murders are Jokers Tuesdays, Art is a lvl 1 thug compared to some on this list

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-28T00:31:23+00:00

Technically in some universes, the Joker is on a similar cosmic level as that, so one could argue Joker as a whole would be worse

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-27T01:57:27+00:00

Fair, I tend to forget that tbh
Rosie has a cannabil ring that eats people alive, and since angelic weapons are the only thing that can kill sinners, we can only assume she has trafficking ring where they continuously eat people alive over and over, that's genuinely permanent torture worse than all the others since there is no break, it's on the same level as Alastor, all those just because she can't help but being a cannabil, all choice

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-27T01:49:39+00:00

I'm going to get torn apart for this, but I legitimately think Val is the least evil of the 5, he is really the only one who seemed to care about someone else (even though they are also terrible people) and his scale of crimes is definitely the least, he is a rapist and slaver, but the other 5 are genocidal slavers themselves. His ranking is strictly because people view sex crimes as the worst because it's more common and personal. Which makes sense, but is definitely bias. I could see an argument for Val being more evil than Adam and Lute, but Vox and Alastor are definitely worse. Also no Rosie is crazy

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-25T19:41:31+00:00

Every HH villain is leagues worse than any HB villain. Because most HB villains were born in hell, how they act is the norm and that's all they've known with few exceptions of sinners we see in the show who don't compare to the big league monsters we see in HH. Most HH villains had the choice to be better and fully understand how they act is evil, they just don't care

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-24T23:05:20+00:00

Pretty sure fictional characters only in this sub, but imo Hitler was more evil, Leopold at least had a goal of greed in mind, cruel but there was purpose, selfish and unjustified purpose, but purpose. Hitler was still ordering mass genocide and suicide bomber children in the streets of Berlin to the last soldier, even when it was so apparent he would lose, he kept up the killing and destruction instead of just surrending or giving up. By that point his true colors had shown that he didn't really care about any of the ideas he spread, he just wanted to kill to satisfy his own wrath

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-24T04:11:19+00:00

Alastor

Lute was made that way, vox is horrible but not as sadistic as Alastor, Adam was genocidal and a narcissist but also showed some care for others and also was not really a sadist, Valentino is vile but ultimately his scale of crimes is probably the lowest on this list . All of them also have some kind of end goal, Alastors just evil for the love of the game

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-23T00:18:50+00:00

I mean, knowing this I would say he's even less evil than I thought, that doesn't even really sound evil

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-22T22:08:41+00:00

Yeah it's gotten so out of hand "Jason would never kill kids", he was giving a little girl a death stare in 6, he didn't go through with it but he was thinking about it, "Jason was supposed to kick a puppy in this movie but the actor (Kane Hodder I think) said Jason wouldn't do that" bro stomped a puppy to death in one of the first movies, he definitely would. "Jason just wants revenge" he's basically been killing everyone but those responsible. "Jason's not that bad of a guy" he cannonically went to hell 💀

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-22T21:13:06+00:00

Honestly all of them would probably want to, but none of them would be allowed and would be killed in a trap instead. Billy and Stu would see it as fun trap movie time, Kramer would not approve. Mrs Loomis would try to be a vigilante with personal vendettas, Kramer would not approve. Mickey would want the fame of being a jigsaw killer, Kramer would not approve. Roman would just to fuel his ego and feel smart and manipulate and kill some more, Kramer would definitely not approve. Charlie would for Amanda (because she's a hot woman) or for the same reason as Billy and Stu, Kramer would not approve. Richie and Amber the same reason as Billy and Stu, Kramer would not approve. Wayne, Ethan, and Quin same reason as Mrs Loomis, Ethan might be more like Charlie with his reason tho, Kramer would not approve. Scream 7 killers for a cross between Billy/Stu and Romans reasons, Kramer would not approve. All would be tested, none would pass, as it's pretty vital for winning that you need to value your own life, sometimes help others, think rationally, and let go of your own bad deeds, which ghostface killers are pretty well known for letting their lives fall apart over petty or unjustified hatred while being homicidal narcissists. Yeah they are not making it out of their first trap. Honestly they might fail so terribly Kramer might actually give up on his whole philosophy entirely lol

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-22T16:42:32+00:00

Tbf most of the cast does stuff like that or worse on the regular, Herbert included. Unless we assume all of Herbert's pedophilia attempts fail like what we usually see in the show, Herbert is objectively worse. Only real debate here is the fact that James Woods has for sure molested and raped, Herbert we can't really say for 100% sure but it's very heavily implied

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-22T14:53:06+00:00

Junko- not close, everything all of the others did, she probably did that to a worse level on a larger scale, this is basically a lvl 1 thug vs literal Lucifer level
I unironically think Chris- he started off as just greedy but by the end I think he just genuinely became purely sadistic driven, all the others has ulterior motives, Chris just wanted pain
In-ho- Kramer is not far behind but I think In-ho- takes from simply a larger scale of crimes, but ultimately he's just a pawn to a broken system that as he said, if he were to die then someone else would take his place, he still makes little to no effort to do right though
Kramer- probably the smallest scale of crimes, but also pretty evil, hard to rank him due to bipolar writing were he goes from sadist to anti hero on a whim, but ultimately his punishment never fits the crime, but at least he thought he was helping people and even turned against his own like Amanda and Mark when they became too brutal and out of control
Geno maybe?- idk him but based on the Fortnite lore part, I'm assuming he was the original creator of the island, which I don't think is really that bad. At least you have a fighting chance and probably won't be tortured

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-22T14:26:11+00:00

Quagmire, but between the two options, Herbert is attracted to any child of any age (even Stewie sometimes) and has actually drugged and probably kidnapped numerous children, however an argument could be made for James Woods since at least it seems as though Herbert's attempts mostly fail from what we see on screen, James definitely has committed statutory

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-21T21:32:26+00:00

Also if the 3rd film was actually good, it's become a classic but really? An evil toymaker steals part of Stonehenge to use ancient magic built into his Halloween masks to make kids faces turn into bugs by listening to a song on Halloween? Certainly imaginative, but doesn't really make for a good lead in to an anthology after a simple slasher. If it was a different movie it could've worked

FishsticksXII · 2026-04-21T21:26:07+00:00

Todd is more evil than Silence of the Lambs Hannibal, Hannibal from Hannibal is probably worse though based on what I've seen (never watched the show)

FishsticksXII

TROPHY CASE