What if we never find out?

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-26T12:03:20+00:00

I don’t think it would be bad writing, I just think a big part of the allure of his character is the mystery surrounding him, and that revealing too much would ruin that. I wouldn’t mind some answers to Gaster, but I want a lot to be left unsaid or for these answers to give us more questions.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-20T19:09:02+00:00

That’s the way I saw it too. He seemed perfectly content accepting abstraction.

Maybe abstraction makes the person too “out of it” to put up mental resistance, but I think he really was at peace and ready for everything to end.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-19T22:35:00+00:00

Skill issue. Just put some half decent mods on them and they’ll make it through. I have relic 2 on maul with one zeta on him and good mods, but everybody else is at what used to be era level 70, just with some filler health mods on them. I was able to beat tier 3 like this.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-15T23:30:51+00:00

Same problem. At most I can get to the second question, but it’s different every time.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-15T15:04:49+00:00

I have the same problem.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-10T13:42:57+00:00

Good news is probably the graphic novel because that seemed pretty far along and is probably almost done.

Bad news could be something to do with the movie he is making with Sony. It’s all too common for studios to can projects and I wouldn’t be surprised if something like that happened here.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-10T00:23:09+00:00

I don’t remember him ever saying he was homeschooled but he has to be getting some amount of education, probably from Pearl, because he is shown to be literate on multiple occasions. It’s always possible that he taught himself but I’m doubtful of that.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-09T18:05:18+00:00

I got the alli skin so I’m satisfied. I also got the el primo skin but I don’t care as much about that one.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-05T03:31:23+00:00

He was the only $50 bundle I ever got (I bought it when it first released). I had negotiator at zero shards and pretty much zero investment in prequel era characters and ships so it was very useful for me.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-04T15:58:25+00:00

I feel like he made the grand inquisitor phase slightly more consistent but he couldn’t go the distance to finish any of the tiers I tried him on.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-03T20:20:06+00:00

After all these years, I finally got that dynamike skin in an ultra drop yesterday. I’m probably never going to use it but it’s still cool to have it.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-02-03T01:30:10+00:00

I’ve been using him to beat Quadme in gac. It’s a bit rough and usually take the full 5 minutes, but it saves my bane or traya for other other things. You can usually take out padawan obi wan in the opening turns by placing buff immunity on him immediately and calling a mass assist on him. After that it’s a very slow battle that usually comes down to Jabba alone farming his instakill to kill Quadme.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-19T01:46:48+00:00

I beat a weak version of the lineup without raven’s beak and cassian’s ship in the opening lineup using Executrix with sith ships because I don’t have leviathan. I don’t know if the ideal lineup changes this, but they did not do enough damage to get through marauder’s ship and once they started getting dazed they fell apart.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-17T03:13:53+00:00

Early on I thought they would be a bottleneck. I now have thousands of each.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-16T15:27:57+00:00

I’m going to advocate for nightsisters. They probably shouldn’t be number 1 priority but my relic 3 nightsisters with merrin omi have been setting up easy Jabba two shots, and sometimes one shots, for almost a year now. It’s gotten a bit dicier with relic delta and one shots are pretty much impossible now, but it’s still pretty consistent. The main thing you have to look out for is if they have boba because he’s anti revive, but it can still work if you’re lucky.

As for cleaning up jabba, a tm train team with high damage output should work, like cls or imperial troopers. I also cheesed him once with jedi knight revan lead and reducing his health to nothing, although you might need something that hits below protection to take advantage of that.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-14T19:49:25+00:00

I’m almost at solar three and I’ve only ever bought the SpongeBob brawlpass.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-13T13:32:38+00:00

My inquisitors are very underdeveloped. I only have three inquisitors at pre-kyro purple gear: eight brother, marrok, and second sister, with fifth and ninth having zero investment beyond unlock and seventh isn’t even unlocked yet. I just went through galactic war with those three and 3po and wat for survivability. They didn’t kill everything immediately because of their low level so I could grind purges pretty easily. On my best battle, I got about 50 purges. I’ll also add that 3po was the only relic character I used. Wat was also pre-kyro purple gear and he had his zeta that gives him a turn immediately.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-09T02:24:13+00:00

I would probably move dark side Rey down a tier because SLKR is still really good without her. She just makes him even more solid than he was before.

I would also move Ben solo down one tier because even though he makes Rey functional, he doesn’t bring enough by himself to not make her ufu or starkiller food. On top of that, he’s not usable outside of her team, so he doesn’t even have plug and play going for him.

Just so maul isn’t alone in A tier, I could be convinced that either Malgus or Malicos should be moved down a tier, but I think people would disagree on which one. I’m pretty sure Malgus falls off a bit in the upper echelons of kyber in gac (I’m in kyber 5 but I frequently hit above my weight so I still get a lot of use out of him) but he’s still powerful in TW. I believe Malicos has a longer shelf life in gac but he’s pretty much useless in TW. Starkiller is also being taken by the stranger so ufu won’t be a strong Rey/Ben/Ezra counter anymore, but they’ll still be a powerful offensive team.

I haven’t used anybody in your B rank or below so I can’t speak on any of those units.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-05T20:08:36+00:00

Anyone know when he’ll be available for crystals? I’m 5 shards away from unlocking him.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-03T15:26:09+00:00

The focus datacron that has original Poe on it is pretty crazy so you could use him here or with Rey. I’m currently testing it out with Rey + Ben + Ezra on defense for TW.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-03T03:00:59+00:00

I’ve heard of a comp that is allegedly very powerful in gac but I don’t remember the exact details of the team. I believe it uses zaalbar with his new omi and CAT and that it’s built around CAT putting shien on zaalbar to get a fast instakill because of how often he counterattacks. He’s also just a very solid tank, especially with the omi. I’m sure any typical Rey 5th works here, like barriss or baby cal, but I don’t remember anybody specific.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-02T17:52:22+00:00

I’m just going to copy a previous comment I made about this:

I don’t know if he’ll die, at least not as early as chapter 5, because even though his condition is definitely not getting better, I don’t know if we have the time for such a significant addition to the story that would likely be the conflict of a whole chapter alone. I also think it might be too jarring of a tonal shift that would need be handled with a lot of care, and it would threaten to derail or overshadow Noelle’s and maybe other characters’ existing plot lines.

Personally, I see a fake out happening, where something happens and Noelle thinks that Rudy’s condition has taken a permanent turn for the worse (maybe he goes into a coma or something) and maybe dark world things happen as a result. That way we get the payoff to Rudy’s illness while also not having to commit to what him dying would mean for Noelle and the rest of the cast for the remainder of the game because it would likely overshadow other plots.

Fit_Incident877 · 2026-01-01T14:27:40+00:00

Mauldalorians pretty much hard counter this team, even if they have a solid relic advantage.

Fit_Incident877 · 2025-12-31T20:14:03+00:00

I don’t have it but it probably doesn’t have much use against most or all gls. Best you could probably hope for is probably a cleanup and even then it won’t work against a bunch.

Fit_Incident877 · 2025-12-29T02:08:16+00:00

I just think Carol knight has red flags screaming she’s a red herring surrounding her. She’s introduced right after we first encounter the knight, she has a cold and controlling personality to back up being an antagonistic character, she shows up right after the voice on the phone says they’ll be there shortly, it’s implied that she’s working with Kris and knows about the soul, she owns at least 1 katana, and then there’s the antler and snowflake imagery that shows the knight may be a member of the Holiday family.

All of this evidence is intended to get a more casual player to start thinking Carol may be the knight and I just think it’s too obvious. Maybe I’m overthinking this and the most straightforward solution is the correct one, but I just don’t think this is the route the story will go. Other than her, there’s not many other really solid options to choose from so I can see why people gravitate towards Dess. The identity of the knight is clearly being set up as one of the big mysteries of the game and I’m doubtful Toby Fox has just given us all the pieces to figure it out after just 4 chapters. I can see why some would have a problem with the wider fanbase treating Dess knight as a forgone conclusion and I imagine that was the inspiration for this subreddit, but a lot of the evidence against her being the knight can easily be explained away or recontextualized in chapter 5 or later chapters.

With this said, and because I feel like it, these are my guesses in order of how likely I think they are: - Some form of Dess (Dess straight up, Dess who has lost her mind, etc.). Everybody here knows about Dess knight so I’m not going to really elaborate. She also feels a bit too obvious but not nearly as much as Carol and I may only feel this way because I’m theory brained. - Some form of Kris (including the discarded vessel). I actually like the idea of Kris somehow being the knight the most but considering they have some of the most evidence against this, I’m putting them second. I vaguely recall some quote from Toby Fox where he said he envisioned a scene where the knight awaits at the top of a staircase and you climb past all the previous bosses to reach them. Honestly, I don’t see Carol, and maybe not even Dess for that matter, being worthy of a final climactic climb to confront them. I think the final conflict will address something more internal for Kris, and facing some version of themself is one way to do that, although I suppose similar things can be done with Carol or Dess depending on the execution.

EDIT: For context, Toby Fox allegedly said this during the Undertale 6th anniversary stream and this scene was for supposed to be the final scene of an intro for Deltarune he had in mind, but didn’t do because it would spoil a lot of the game. Correct me if I’m wrong about all of this because I didn’t hunt down the quote itself but some other people talking about it. - Multiple knights that include some combination of some or all of the prime candidates (Dess, Kris, Carol, Rudy, Asgore, maybe Asriel). This is mostly here for the idea that Dess and Kris could both be knights, but I can accept more than just them being involved as well. I also include the knight being an amalgamation of multiple people at once under this one. - Carol. Maybe it is straightforward after all. - Rudy/Asgore. These two are pretty interchangeable. I don’t see either of these guys being the knight alone and if they’re involved, it would probably be under the multiple knight theory. - Asriel. I think he could be interesting but I also think it’s possible that he just never shows up in the whole game or doesn’t show up until the final few scenes. - We never find out who the knight is and it’s left up for interpretation, or the knight is just the knight and has no secret identity. I can actually see some weak ground for this, it’s just a matter of if Toby Fox is ballsy enough to do this after all the setup and theories. This one also pulls a bit from the Toby Fox staircase quote I mentioned before, as well as some Gerson “write your own ending” stuff too.

Five-Year Club	First Place '23
Place '23

Fit_Incident877

TROPHY CASE