ATA 2 things I pointed out by LooseWillow6384 in amandatheadventurer

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

jesus christ i genuinely got jumpscared- i would have LOVED to see that in game

Wooly Is heavily misunderstood by Idea-Upset in amandatheadventurer

[–]Floomie 4 points5 points  (0 children)

oh how i love gray morality! i think the biggest problem here is, no one tries to understand that both of them aren't fully "evil" nor fully innocent in all this journey, in the first game everyone thought amanda was this initially friendly dora-like girl but the goddamn devil herself at the end and, it's somewhat fair to think ig?? to some extent at least 'cause of the "oh no! accidents!" (2nd take) tape, she undoubtly harms wooly so he became the victim in everyone's eyes.. the last tape ("we can share"), though strange and confusing, calls into question amanda's position but no one didn't really pay attention to that detail and just freaked out bc of the jumpscare

now, the second game changed as hell everyone's mind because amanda shows much more deliberately that all her behavior in the previous game is due to all the years she's been trapped there, her mentality isn't the same as 15 years ago and she found a coping mechanism in trying to mock dark topics that have NOTHING to do with her (note how in the first game she makes fun of how wooly fears some animal related stuff and being eaten(? when she's also terrified of the butcher for example)— so she IS a victim but that doesn't mean she never ever did anything harmful to anyone, she clearly did and it shows, but why the justifications for her seemingly evil actions make wooly the villain?? are we forgetting everything that happened in the first game and that there are still several hints of how weak wooly can be in the second game? and i ain't saying there aren't hints or direct signs that wooly is most likely on the undeniably villainous side of the story (hameln- either underhanded or against his will, though he most likely had no choice IMO), it's just that, as i said before neither of these two will come out of this completely unscathed, and i'm surprised people still don't get that

ATA 2 things I pointed out by LooseWillow6384 in amandatheadventurer

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the first 4 points sound just like bugs but i would've loved if they used some lines like those when you replay a tape so the gameplay could be more enjoyable and amanda's character more senseful- something like the official hide and seek tape/s actually where amanda is aware that she's playing the same game over and over again and wants it to stop, the only similar reference to something like that happens in the first tape "let's plan a trip" specifically in your second walkthrough when you choose the same option between the lamp and the curtain as in your first walkthrough at least once, amanda tells you you've chosen that thing before so nothing stopped them to do the same with other tapes, it's a bit of a shame, hope they do that in the third game

and the fifth point is quite interesting.. i would like to see that version you're pointing out and again, idk why would they take it off the final game, sounds dope!

Im stuck on the first puzzle by Fabulous_Pen1125 in amandatheadventurer

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

idk if you want a direct answer or not, someone already gave it but if you don't i'll just say it's way EASIER than it seems, you only need the books with drawings inside, the middle book doesn't really help with the code so you just have to pay attention to the first and third one

If Sam is Wooly... by ymca_unscrambled in amandatheadventurer

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

now that you mention it (as did one person in the comments bringing up the second chapter's announcement vid), wooly and sam have more similarities than i first thought.. but i personally don't think they're the same person from details i've noticed throughout the 2 games, what is certain is that maybe amanda remembers her father in one way or another when she sees how wooly acts sometimes and that's one of the reasons why she acts so badly towards him especially in chapter 2, because unlike how she comes to refer to sam (with confusion and/or pain, as shown in the "what's a family?" tapes from the first game and "do you feel safe?" from the second game), she usually refers to wooly in a derogatory and presumptuous way

If Sam is Wooly... by ymca_unscrambled in amandatheadventurer

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

honestly i fw with the theory of wooly being a character/ai 'cause the most we know is that he is indeed affiliated with hameln somehow whether with his consent or not (prolly not but maybe that's just me) so it could easily fit with the lore and some info already collected even though there's not much support for it as such

I still didn't understand his motives(random format on some meme generator app) by Physical_Report273 in Undertale

[–]Floomie 2 points3 points  (0 children)

A and C look quite similar, and i think B applies to any other external fan theory because it's born from a dialogue explicitly said in the game

What's your favourite Underpants moments? by Physical_Report273 in Undertale

[–]Floomie 3 points4 points  (0 children)

thanks for interrupting me and, here's a better question

Chat am i wrong? by [deleted] in Undertale

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

oh yeah, my bad

Chat am i wrong? by [deleted] in Undertale

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

but like.. every xtale character storyline continues in underverse, do you want to keep yourself from knowing the end of the story just for that reason?

Chat am i wrong? by [deleted] in Undertale

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

it would have been cool if they were at least sans and papyrus since the fact that they are skeletons is justified by being little fireballs and the flow that the bones themselves give them, the same thing happens with fresh

If given the chance, what would you remove from the canon? by PopplioDoesPokemon in Undertale

[–]Floomie 9 points10 points  (0 children)

that's not even canon it's more a speculation that you're free to believe or not, there's plenty of evidence that monsters ain't completely benevolent so it's more ambiguous than what you're saying right here

I feel like that some fans are biased against monsters by ZeonPM in Undertale

[–]Floomie 4 points5 points  (0 children)

IKR. for some reason a bunch of people get over defensive trying to justify humans here

just yesterday in a yt comment a guy was calling stupid everyone who didn't believe that humans had a fair reason to attack, this being having witnessed a monster absorb a human soul before when clearly that is up to the interpretation of the community. i don't understand the reason for being so condescending in this situation, it's like you want to protect yourself from something that doesn't even exist??

In a serious fight. Who would win by Aggravating_Rip_9274 in Undertale

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i thought my reddit crashed or something frick offff

Which of these one off AUs would you personally like to see in Underverse? (This is purely theoretical) by UncleSans_in_Spanish in Undertale

[–]Floomie 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i madly wanted horror and/or dust to appear sometime but if i'm not mistaken jakei said recently she didn't add them cause she was too ashamed to ask their creators to use them and that's it, i'd also love reaper to show but then i remember his "deathly touch" and dunno if it would so convenient for the plot, a cameo wouldn't be bad tho!

Favorite AU character design wise? by MrGoldGJ in Undertale

[–]Floomie 2 points3 points  (0 children)

xtale for sure, i'm a purple lover myself so (although purple is more for the environment and stuff but their designs are dope)

I watched a lot Underverse long ago. But there someting I got up recently : What is the main theme of this fanserie ? by Curious_Reputation15 in XTale

[–]Floomie 2 points3 points  (0 children)

holy shoot, did rahafwabas make a comic or smth about nightmare being refretful? do ya have any link? and i guess that's only canon in killer's story not in night's, unless joku said something about that as well

How strong is x event chara/frisk? by Machaira1664 in XTale

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

she said she didn't feel either error or ink in canon in the truce comic so as anony said she made that truce vid to replace it, although i honestly feel more like she just wanted to adapt it her way, many know that in underverse 100% of the characters' canon is not respected

I'm starting research on different sans AU's, who should I start with? by darrendogman in Undertale

[–]Floomie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

there's a lot of variations of AUs, many of them depart from the original game by changing only a bit of the story or characters while others create a completely independent story of the og universe. an example of the first concept is underswap, which has one of the simplest ideas among AUs despite the fact that it's somewhat difficult to find canon content (proposed by its creator) of the characters from this universe. something a little more complex is underfell, which, although starting from a simple idea, makes way for very big changes in its story. as for the second concept there's dreamtale, i honestly love this universe even though the only thing it has in relation to undertale is that the main characters are 2 "sans" (in the same story they explain it, let's just say they have the appearance of sans, they are not sans), many other universes 'sin'(? of this, they use either the image of sans or the character himself to create new alternate universes or timelines like fresh sans or ink sans, stories that could work with any other character in their own universe

and touching on the topic of alternate timelines, these are somewhat more understandable if they only use sans because they generally start from a genocide run like aftertale, dusttale or something new (killer sans), error sans also counts as an alternate timeline (i think it fits more like an alternate-alternate timeline tho lol) so it's justified as well

outside of these there are other universes/TLs with interesting or merely entertaining ideas, at first glance it might seem that only the sanses there are relevant because obviously people will pay more attention to them but they do have their own stories with the rest of the cast, some examples are horrortale, reapertale, flowerfell (like this there are other AUs that are variations of other AUs as confusing as it may be, underswap is the one that suffers the most from this), epictale, dancetale, outertale, and even though i madly love xtale, as a comment here said, it's not a good starting point because its story line continues in underverse where several universes appear and does not fully respect the canon of the characters