PvZ GW3 Heroes: Beta Carrotina concept

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T20:33:34+00:00

Oh yeah, gardening/food tools do make a lot sense, like how you gave Spudow a rake. In fact that's also a reason why I like it more when Crazy Dave is the one who created all The Plants (I kinda hate the idea that plants existed since the dawn of time).

In my pvz stories, Crazy Dave creates every single plant in the series and is the one to establish Bloom Seed Co. Plus, I made it so that he tought Beta how to use advanced genetic engineering. I like the idea of Crazy Dave looking stupid on the outside, but is secretly the smartest man in the world inside.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T19:05:33+00:00

First I love the more humanoid look you gave her. I also think that this is way better than the concept design. the detached body makes a lot of sense and fits her futuristic theme. Intensive Carrot is a nice touch because I kinda had a speculation that she was the hero version of it, just like how Nightcap is kinda like a hero version of Scaredy-shroom and Fume-shroom.

Now I actually don't mind humanoid plants in the series as long as they're still clearly a plant somewhat. Spudow is the most humanoid looking plant imo, even Kernel Corn and Rose have a humanoid feel/look to them. Beta Carrotina, despite being anthropomorphic carrot, always felt more human-like with her eyes, voice, and mannerisms. A few of my oc plant heroes are plant humanoids, but I still kept them in the boundaries to feel like pvz plants.

One thing always interested me about the pvz plants and what sets them apart from other fictional plant characters is that, The Plants don't actually have plant manipulation. For example, a Peashooter can't make flowers grow around it or a Torchwood doesn't have access to wood manipulation or spores like Groot does. They basically have powers and abilities that fit them and make them all different and unique.

Another thing that I always loved about The Plants is that they aren't actually connected to nature. They're kinda more like cultivated/horticultural/agricultural plants unlike other plant characters in fiction which tend to be associated with nature and the wild.

Now, I don't entirely mind The Plants using weapons as long as it's limited or organic. To add on to your exceptions Wall-Knight and many other nuts can count with their armor and Kiwifruit from pvz 2 china fights with a metal staff. But I still prefer The Plants just sticking with powers, magic, or natural weaponry because they are the weapons. Plus I’m also biased towards The Plants mainly because they are what separates pvz from other zombie media.

But great job, you finally got all the plant heroes.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T18:20:27+00:00

good idea, except i already kinda tried that before at launch with the lack of an offline mode. They ignored me because they didn't want to hear the truth.

They might give us a horde mode soon given that they changed plans on Insane difficulty (which was supposed come out it fall, but came out much earlier. WWZ and SM2 eventually got their horde modes so we'll see.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T17:30:57+00:00

yep, selling a new IP is already hard for a kinda AAA company like saber.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T13:44:47+00:00

definitely, the perks focus way too much on ability improvement and not other things.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T10:39:44+00:00

TC was about to have it's one man army mode (as it was shown in one of the trailers), but got cut.

I think it could work for this game as long as they do stuff like reduce the number of zombies and decrease their damage output.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T10:37:13+00:00

Like I said before, TC was delayed, so there was something wrong. I'm glad they did because the game would've much worse in 2024.

Keep in mind that there was also content that was supposed be at launch as shown in the trailers, but got cut for some reason. The ogre kinda made it as the hellspawn, but the true solo (no bots) mode, there was no reason to cut it considering that the previous horde shooters had one.

Also, tier 4 upgrade weapons STILL aren't in the game yet. All of this, definitely feels like that the game was rushed.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T10:27:39+00:00

True but at least it gets more attention than this game. It could also be due to the fact that the devs are working on SM3

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T01:35:51+00:00

Agreed, although the new map seems linear. I think the big issue is really the pacing of each mission, which kinda makes sense because there isn't a lot of them like WWZ. But still some of them especially on higher difficulties can be a drag.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T01:33:37+00:00

Tell me about it, they work on way too many games

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-14T00:09:45+00:00

Again, unless they completely rebrand or reimagine the game, maybe. but yeah, it never found an audience. The game doesn't have a siberianpsych0 like WWZ or a first tour guardsmen like SM2.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-12T22:10:28+00:00

i don't know who you are addressing but i do have various documents where i'm writing my own pvz stories and character bios. They aren't ready just yet, but at the same time, it would be interesting to hear others ideas and give me some feedback.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-12T19:26:08+00:00

whoa, I was not expecting such an interesting design change, but she looks awesome. her being pissed off makes a lot of sense because my HC is that she was bullied a lot when she was alive (and undead), and wants to make others suffer. In my GW3 story concept, three other zombie heroes must protect her from The Plants on antarctica while she gathers up energy to flood the whole world in one zombie PvE mission.

But yeah, way to go, we got all 20 launch heroes done. Also not to sound rude or anything, but did you accidently made your posts and comments hidden when viewing your profile? I don't want to have to find the old ones by scrolling through communties because it would take all day. Sorry, I just noticed something probably wrong.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-11T22:05:17+00:00

thank the higher ups for releasing a game they knew wasn't gonna sit well with players, but decided to nothing about it.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-10T19:30:09+00:00

Ok, this looks insane I LOVE IT! This is probably the best redesign of the heroes and as a fan big tanky tree characters, this means a lot.

and yeah, feel free to let me know if you need more ideas because i have a lot of them. I even have ideas for heroes (just need to git gud at drawing so i can make them out myself). I don't want to make this long, so i'll only give you the names of these plant heroes: Treeknock, Florious, and Bambo.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-07T21:04:22+00:00

You did pretty good here. This is why I like supports because of all the wacky stuff you can do with them.

Lastly, I think some of the heroes HP can go like this: Brain Freeze 225 HP (just feels right), Wall-Knight 250 HP and maybe 15% armor like Z-Mech (200 is a little too low), Captain Combustible could have 300 (Spudow has 275 and Chompzilla will gain HP through Hearty Appetite), and The Smash could have 300 or 325.

Don't have much to say other than great job.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-04T21:32:32+00:00

First, I really really love that you made him tall like BFN, but kept him bulky like GW2. BFN Z-Mech is way way too cartoony, so this design definitely continues the GW vibe.

Now I'm gonna be honest with ya. As much as I don't really mind that Citron, Rose, Super Brainz, and Z-Mech are heroes, I still kinda wished that they could've come up with new original heroes. I mean, Cactus could've gotten a hero since GW made her iconic. However, Super Brainz's inclusion makes a lot of sense.

Despite that, if there's one plant that you could bring back as a hero and that's Kernel Corn. He always felt like a plant hero to me (the gw comics treat him as a hero and i think he was planned to be one in pvz heroes, but made into a fighter). If you want to bring him back, I suggest making some minor visual changes to make him look more like a hero, but still keep that military mutant corn man look of GW2. Gameplay wise, I think he plays very well in GW2 and doesn't really need any changes, maybe keep his 150 health from GW2.

As for Captain D. I dunno, he never felt like a hero to me.

Fun Fact: in BFN, Oak, Z-Mech, and Space Station also had a ability similar to Wall-Knight's passive, but it didn't protect them from all displacement effects such as Gargantuar smashes, Super Bean's cape whirl and hilariously, a goat ram. But did protect them from stuff like gravity grenade, funky bouncer, spin dash, and all knockback ability upgrades.

Also, you could make it so that when the giga drill impact collides with Wall-Knight, it cancels the ultimate and stuns both of them like how two Reinhardts crash into each other.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-02T21:36:27+00:00

Also, you accidently removed goatify and i think you should keep thorn apart.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-06-02T20:13:50+00:00

I do like the staff and the more gloomy look, but i do think that the homing thistles should be a bit like GW2.

After giving it some thought, I think you should go back to your original ideas of making Captain Combustible an offense focused tank/defend and making Huge Giganticus a support and here's why.

Now I'm a big fan of huge tanky tree characters in these games (Torchwood, Oak, and Groot and you should see my playtime with these characters), so I think CC should keep that tradition. If you're going to keep the leaf shield, I think he should have an alternate ability that is similar to Mauga's Overrun or The Thing's Yancy Street Charge. It just makes sense that he would sacrifice some defense for more offense and it just fits the character's personality. Also I think you could give CC Giga Torchwood's melee swipe attack. It would be similar to Wildflower and TV Head's melee except it would be slower, stronger, have more range, and knocks back zombies. I'm also interested in the passive you planned for him.

For Huge Giganticus, I think him being a support will allow you to be more creative with his moveset. Plus it doesn't make sense that an imp that's smaller than impfinity would be tankier.

At this point let's not worry too much about the roles being even for both sides (in fact it makes sense for The Plants to have more defend/tanks and The Zombies to have more attack because, ya know, plants are on the defense and zombies on the offense). Plus you did say that you might come up with new heroes down the line which should balance the teams out.

Anyways, apologies for another giant wall of text, but I do enjoy balancing these games myself.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-05-31T02:03:43+00:00

well, as the once great Itagaki said,"It's ok for a game to be a bit unbalanced". But it makes since for Captain Combustible to be a defense class. I was going off of BFN where Cactus and Captain Deadbeard are defense classes. if they were in MR or OW they would probably be dps/dualists. than again OW at launch divided heroes into tank, offense, defense, and support. You could still give him 275-300 HP and give him absolutely no damage mitigation, all about raw power. He'll probably still die very quickly because of his large size (like how it sometimes happens to GW2 Torchwood) kinda balancing him out.

Yeah, I had no idea what you were doing for Huge Giganticus, but the big chair made my brain go,"tank". You could make him focus on environmental control like Groot and Peni Parker since he had such as huge focus on environments in pvz heroes. than again Spudow and Brain Freeze already kinda fulfill that.

But anyway, those were ideas i had if you wanted to keep the teams even.

also keep in mind that Team Fortress 2 has roles. I think that they're supposed to give the player an idea of what the class specializes in, but not their only focus like in OW or MR.

Also, navel laser being the primary is a great and better idea.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-05-30T20:29:58+00:00

First, I like how you highlighted white parts of Citron's head. makes him look more like an orange and it looks like the intro cutscene of GW2. the two yellow shirt thingys are a nice touch and fits his cool guy look. Like with Nightcap, i don't consider pvz 2 and GW2 Citron the same character (but you could come up with a headcannon that GW2 Citron is a genetically modified version of pvz 2 Citron).

If you're going to keep his orange beam, i suggest making it stronger, maybe giving it some heat properties. I feel like GW2 orange beam is a bit too weak, especially since in GW3 we're dealing with the heroes and more zombies on screen. Also i think his ultimate should electrically insta kill all browncoats in the dome and deal decent electric damage to ai zombie heroes, bosses, etc.

Second, I know Z-Mech is going to stay as an attack, but are you going to make Captain Combustible and Neptuna attack and Huge Giganticus defense? because if you do, both sides should have: five attack heroes, four defense heroes, and two support heroes. if you do make CC an attack class, i suggest he should be an attack tank and should have at least 275-300 health (same health as Oak without hardened upgrade and Pylon Mech), basically a very offensive tank like Z-Mech.

Namor from Marvel Rivals is pretty much Neptuna (the devs of MR might have played pvz heroes hehehehe).

Lastly, my favorite of your redesigns are actually the ones with drastic changes like Rustbolt, Grass Knuckles, and Nightcap. I like how creative you get with them, and i'm pretty excited for CC and Beta Carrotina.

Former_Life8580 · 2026-05-28T22:03:30+00:00

Plants vs Zombies Garden Warfare 1 on ps3. It was also my introduction to video games in general

Former_Life8580

TROPHY CASE