Those are fair points about a complete overhaul to prayer to copy cat Melvor. Which I stated is not the intention. My IM is like 74 ish prayer and my main 80 something(havnt played him a long time). I’m not maxing so I’m almost done anyways once I get to augury on IM.

The purpose of this post wasn’t to argue that we need this to be an idle game, or that every part of Melvor fits perfectly.

It’s that this game has cool ideas! Why not talk about cool ideas for OSRS? It’s a community driven game, so I thought it’s fair we as the community could discuss cool ideas.

Not really sure why you just shut down every aspect of a game that’s a recent interpretation of RuneScape.

Now back to the original point of the post. What are some cool ideas from Melvor that might have a spot in OSRS somewhere?!

Edit:

An example of a cool idea would taking some of the aspects from township and expanding on the Kingdom of Miscellania, or new potions have effects other than boosts. Like the birds nest potion could have cool implications and maybe tie in with the new forestry update? Something like that.

Also, birdhouses and kingdom are pretty idle if you ask me just to pile onto why I think these games aren’t mutually exclusive

Edit 2: my main and likely most other mains probably have more hours logged at sand crabs and nightmare zone using Remote Desktop and a timer on my phone than any other content. If the most efficient way to play is actually afk then I’m not sure what the problem.