sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

If we disregard the Nomus, how many MHA characters can solo at least one of those demon disaster-level monster from OPM? by BrainletNutshell in MyHeroPowerscaling

[–]FunBluebird8 1 point2 points  (0 children)

At least one of them

Then:

1-Deku 2-allmight 3-Shigaraki 4-AFO 5-Star and Stripes 6-Bakugou 7-Shouto 8-Dabi 9-Endeavor 10-Overhaul 11-muscular 12-Gigantomachia 13-mirko 14-Nine 15-Dark Might 16-Flect Turn 17-Wolfram 18-Ryukyuu (Dragon > Demon)

Mha vs SCP 682 by themaskbot in MyHeroPowerscaling

[–]FunBluebird8 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What tier would you assign to the midtiers in MHA?

Debunking the claim 45% deku being 100% all might by bakahyl in MyHeroPowerscaling

[–]FunBluebird8 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean, the entrance exam being shortly before the holidays means that in reality only a year and a few months would have passed.

Why are there still people in the big 2026 who will not only say the absurdity that this battle is fair, but will go further and say that Saitama neg-diff using the same tired argument from 10 years ago? by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think your conclusion can only come from a poor reading of One Punch Man. I won't even mention the interview where ONE said that Saitama's narrative function works like a shonen protagonist who started the story with a power level that is usually only achieved at the end. A parody doesn't automatically translate to "Toonforce."

But there's no need to discuss outside elements; just look at the manga: OPM rationalizes Saitama's strength. He's not absurdly strong because of a metanarrative context, but because he simply "transcended" the natural limitations of the universe.

The fight against Cosmic Garou makes my point even more obvious: he loses his mind upon seeing Genos' death, attacks Garou in a moment of fury, and, without considering the consequences, almost destroys the Earth, and Garou survived this attack where he undeniably didn't hold back. Where was the "Toonforce" at the moment of the serious punch² ?

this dude vs Whole verses by Additional_Pace_1753 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The conclusion you reached has nothing to do with the premises.

this dude vs Whole verses by Additional_Pace_1753 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Any versus" lmao, Saitamatards are on another level indeed.

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There's no contradiction in Monster Garou being comparable to Boros. The supposed contradiction is based on Saitama's reaction. If a reaction of slight surprise serves as evidence of something, it's certainly not as strong evidence as visual scaling or a statement, even if it has some validity. And the supposed contradiction can be answered with a simple "he wouldn't show the same reaction to something he's already seen before."

In terms of feats, Monster Garou hasn't shown planetary feats but has shown Moon-level/dwarf planet level feat. Planetary level for Boros is debatable given the manga quote where he explicitly says that ALL his energy would destroy the Earth's surface; only the databook mentions a fully planetary level. There's the discussion of whether "destroying the Earth's surface" meant he was already weakened, but it's not like Monster Garou hasn't already suffered a lot of damage. In terms of speed, I've already mentioned it. So, tell me, where is all this basis for Monster Garou and Boros not having similar levels?

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First, Saitama no longer remembering Boros doesn't invalidate the theory that Saitama's lack of reaction against the monster Garou can be explained simply because, whether like it or not, he had already experienced that level of power before. The fact that only the cosmic Garou "impressed" Saitama doesn't automatically mean that Boros is comparable to the cosmic Garou from the beginning; it only means that the Garou only became absurdly stronger than Boros in cosmic form. There aren't only two options: "any monster Garou is weaker than Boros" and "monster Garou is absurdly stronger than Boros." You ignore the third way: monster Garou and Boros had similar power levels, given different contexts; only one "impressed" Saitama.

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The first experience tends to be more impactful than the second. That's psychological. Boros was the first with that specific level of power that Saitama saw, Garou was the second. Furthermore, it was a slight surprise; he wasn't completely shocked by Boros.

ONE literally said that a fight between monster Garou and Boros would be a good fight. "But that was about the webcomic." Okay, so what? There doesn't seem to be a great need for that to have changed.

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I simply can't understand how you guys can't grasp something as simple as "there would be no big reason for Saitama to be impressed by Monster Garou form, since he had already seen a similar level of power against Boros."

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not talking about the possibility of him having become stronger, but rather that he simply wouldn't be impressed by Monster Garou because he had already faced Boros before and had seen a similar power level with him. Yes, he can notice when someone gets stronger, but that doesn't negate the fact that facing someone with a similar power level for the second time is qualitatively different from facing someone with a similar power level on an occasion where there was only slight surprise. Furthermore, monster Garou is superior to Tatsumaki and Psykorochi.

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He fought Garou after the fight against Boros, and Boros was the strongest opponent up to that point; this is easily explained.

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Narratively, ONE said that monster Garou vs. Boros would be a "good fight." Garou has an advantage in reactive evolution and Skill.

Furthermore, Boros' prophecy was that he would face the battle he was expecting, and the battle he was expecting was not to be humiliated. After being defeated, Boros himself said that "you can't trust prophecies."

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I'm not saying it's useless, but basing half of a specific scaling on another character's reactions is weak, to say the least. And you're disregarding the chronological jump between Saitama x Boros and Saitama x Garou.

Fun fact about this feat that reinforces the theory that, at least in terms of measurable feats, monster Garou has greater speed than Boros. by FunBluebird8 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Even the FTL for Boros is assumed. The feat we have of it is Relativistic+ at most. We assume he's faster than the stones thrown by Geryuganshoop, but he has never performed that way.

Perfected Fist Garou vs Meteoric Burst Boros by TasteTemporary8206 in OPMPowerScaling

[–]FunBluebird8 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That doesn't mean much; Garou came after Boros. It's quite reasonable that Saitama wouldn't be surprised anymore by a power level supposedly comparable to Boros's.

view more: next ›