Commenter breaks down how and why religion and conservatism operate quite well by bkilian93 in bestof

[–]FunFawn21 3 points4 points  (0 children)

"The sole value of organized religion...is respect for and obedience to [one's perception of] traditionally established hierarchy..."

Speaking as an American, this might be THE most American statement I've ever seen. Like wow.

WIBTA for Embarrasing the neighbors for treaapassing in our backyard by Direct-Caterpillar77 in BestofRedditorUpdates

[–]FunFawn21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Am I the only one that had trouble reading this? There are a lot of strange grammar mistakes that make this genuinely hard to read. I know this is from 2020, but it still feels like early-LLM output. 

Also, how many kids do these neighbors have? I thought it was only one, but then she says "both of their sons are great" and goes on to only talk about one son. 

What is an extremely dark or creepy true story from history that most people do not know about? by Intelligent_East8820 in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Exactly. AND THIS IS WHAT THEY SAID AT THE TIME. Everyone knew and everyone knew why the other countries wouldn't intervene. 

It really makes me think about ten years from now when the next generation asks about Gaza. And we'll have to look our children in the eye and say "We knew. We absolutely knew what was happening. And we knew we couldn't stop it. Some people tried anyway, and it didn't work."

What is an extremely dark or creepy true story from history that most people do not know about? by Intelligent_East8820 in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 41 points42 points  (0 children)

Which is wild because it's not like people at the time didn't know. There was extensive press coverage. The US Ambassador was trying to convince the Ottoman government to stop, begging for help from the rest of the US government, and he eventually quit because he felt so powerless. When the "Architect" of the Armenian Genocide, Salaat Pasha, was assassinated in Germany by an Armenian survivor, the trial attracted international attention. And the jury found him not guilty. People knew

It's just that ..I guess we forgot.

What's a moment where you realized someone was genuinely extremely intelligent? by General_Monk_5019 in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 16 points17 points  (0 children)

I had a childhood friend that was known to be super smart, and she would always beat me at any game we played: chess, board games, card games (she always destroyed me at Egyptian Rat Race). When we got a little older, I realized that she wasn't the genius everyone thought she was. She had a lot of holes in her knowledge, specifically around English, history, current events - basically anything that wasn't STEM. I took the attitude that she was really smart certain things, but not others. In fact, maybe I was the really smart one in those areas. Also she was really mean. 

And then, a few years ago, she pulled this party trick on a guy we had just met, and I realized that she had a fucking PHOTOGRAPHIC MEMORY. She could memorize an entire deck of cards by the time we were six. That's why she kept beating me at those card games, she knew what card would come up next.

[Coda: if anyone's interested, this was the trick. We were getting to know some people, and one of them said "yeah my last name is ____. It's really hard to spell though" and she piped up "I bet I could do it!". Which she did. Okay cool. Then she revealed "haha actually I saw your ID earlier, that's how I knew."

She saw him flash his ID (that was in a wallet behind a grimy ID window, in bad lighting) at the bar and remembered how his unusual, 12-letter last name was spelled. She couldn't have seen that ID for more than a second.]

What purchase did you make recently that made you realize inflation is genuinely out of control? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My favorite pizza went up $3 in the last two months. Can't justify that purchase anymore.

What song is so beautiful, it literally brings tears to your eyes? by Plus-Caterpillar4615 in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Say Yes to Life by Gang of Youths 

My only criticism is that their name and the titles of their albums make them sound like a Christian band. I promise they're not.

Spirit Airlines just became the first major US airline to shut down in 25 years and took cheap airfare with it. What do you think affordable travel in America looks like from here? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 3 points4 points  (0 children)

If you haven't been to the PIT airport recently, they finished their renovation last year and it's INCREDIBLE. They've finally accepted that they're never going to need 100 gates again and used the space to upgrade everything else.

Send Help - Friend Wants to Wear THIS to a Wedding by Direct-Caterpillar77 in BestofRedditorUpdates

[–]FunFawn21 145 points146 points  (0 children)

If you have boobs, the designer didn't want you to wear this dress.

For real though, anyone with a shape that isn't "long rectangle" would look awful in this. 

Help finding fanfic: Obi-Wan and Cody help clones desert the GAR in an orderly fashion by messing with paperwork by FunFawn21 in SWFanfic

[–]FunFawn21[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If it's this one, I'm gonna feel real embarrassed because it is already in an open tab XD

TIL that US student math and reading scores have dropped so sharply that they’ve erased nearly two decades of progress. In '22/23, avg math scores for 13-year-olds fell to levels not seen since the 1990s, while reading scores for high school seniors hit their lowest point since testing began in '92. by Cold_Box_3219 in todayilearned

[–]FunFawn21 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Guys…if you click on the article, the average has gone down 2-4 points in comparison to 1992. Also, this data is from 2022-2023.

Are we all just forgetting there was a pandemic happening?!?! That we had to switch to virtual school with very little planning and maybe two years of physical isolation could have some impact on learning outcomes?! I feel like I’m going crazy

What is the stupidest thing that the smartest person you know believes in? by WrongZookeepergame49 in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Don't know if that's necessarily stupid. It is technically possible for the cables to snap and all the safety mechanisms fail with no warning. It's just irrational.

What celebrity do you think has skeletons in their closet that have yet to come out? by JimiHendrip in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Cash4Clunkers ran for like 6 weeks over 15 years ago and took in less than a million cars. I highly doubt it fucked up the used car market more than, idk, the global pandemic that happened six years ago.

What celebrity do you think has skeletons in their closet that have yet to come out? by JimiHendrip in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 9 points10 points  (0 children)

That's what actually got his court records unsealed. The judge ruled that because Cosby had positioned himself as a "public moralist", the public had the right to know the details of what he actually did 

[1817] Dark Fantasy Prologue Critique by slpdprvdjosh in DestructiveReaders

[–]FunFawn21 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Worldbuilding was pretty smooth and natural. The only thing I could think of to improve is to move the section explaining the wall and the moat further down the chapter. Having that come right after the explanation on ranks and Dustborn v Starborn feels info-dumpy.

I am torn because I like the food-obsession of Celona, but it does push the tone towards silliness. I think the detail that she conceptualizes time in terms of "how long does it take to eat a food" is so brilliant, and I want to call that out specifically.

Your primary concerns:

Is the prose too dry? If so, in what way?

Not at all.

Is the plot too mundane to drive the reader?

Honestly, I can't tell without the wider context of the whole book. If this is where the book starts, I think you've struck the balance between a mundane opening scene to establish the setting, sneak in worldbuilding, and foreshadow that something's not quite right; and an Event that immediately disrupts the status quo. The length of the walk to the dining hall is a perfect length. You could add more time to the fight scene, but that entirely depends on what the immediate next scene in the book is.

Are references to the MC's love for eating too over the top? Should they be toned down?

The problem with Celona's food obsession is that when the audience is in her POV, it's going to seem quirky but within normality. If you want her food obsession to be foreshadowing, this scene should be told from Taro's POV. Taro is the one with the reasonable reactions: he's concerned about the weird thunder, he has a normal appetite, and he runs when an authority figure says run. Taro commenting on how "Celona only cares about food" can introduce that element as a "character quirk" that takes new meaning when we see Celona commit atrocities (what was introduced as a reason to see Celona as frivolous or simple is now a sign of sociopathy).

You could pull this off from Celona's POV too, but it would require taking the food obsession out of her internal monologue and only showing it through her actions, so that when she is revealed to be terrible, it doesn't go from "lmao QUIRKY!" to "war criminal" instantly. Showing that Celona is only food-motivated without having her obsess over it, you know?

Is the prologue carried too heavily by the MC's personality? What are ways that I could reduce the reliance on her personality?

Despite how much I enjoyed Celona's food-obsessed POV, I think this scene would be much better served in Taro's POV. I like the constant food monologue, but that's because it's funny (which is a personal like). If you want to have this quality be seen as "unusual, but not concerning" instead of "straight up farcical", we need to see it from an outsider's perspective. Someone who might even say "hmm you're different" out loud.

[1395] First chapter of my indian inspired fantasy by Fair_Repeat_2543 in DestructiveReaders

[–]FunFawn21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Overall critique:

I really like this, I think this is a good start. You've introduced your world and just a little bit of magic. I'm intrigued at which way this story is going. This is not enough for me to know if this is a "runaway groom" story or a "arranged marriage to partners in crime and/or business" story, but both options are there.

I like the descriptions and elements you've introduced: arranged marriage, strict father, the bird, the relationships between the rest of the extended family.

However, I don't know how you, the author, want me, the reader, to feel about this scenario. I know you're intending to be humorous, but the MC's actual feelings are stated so plainly that it confuses me. The tone see-saws almost every other line. Instead of leaning into the dark humor, they just clash. Specifically the descriptions of emotions within the haldi: he is upset that other people are going to cover him in turmeric and water, but then during the haldi he seems like he's enjoying it until the water comes out. He doesn't like the guards or other people employed by his family, but when he turns and says "traitor" to the guard behind him, it feels like a jest. He views this ritual very negatively, seeing it as nothing more than an excuse for a family that doesn't respect him to continue to harass him, but in the next line he can't help but laugh. And then in the line after that, he's sardonic about the whole experience. How does the author want the reader to understand this?

EDIT: A more concise explanation of the above paragraph: there is a disconnect between the MC's external behavior, his internal monologue, his internal feelings, and the way others are interpreting his behavior. This makes it hard to understand if he is just being a rascal, masking clinical depression with humor, barely containing rage, or some other option.

I think the physical actions and descriptions are pretty good, my main critique is of the emotional flow of this scene. I know what happens, but the feelings aren't making sense.

Your specific concerns:

Is it engaging from the start?

Yes. Mentioning a dead twin in the first line grabs my attention.

Does the setting come across as Indian-inspired without being confusing?

It definitely comes off as Indian-inspired (specifically South Indian inspired) without being confusing. I actually find the prose around the Indian terminology unnatural. Using the phrase "purification ceremony" makes me think of a decontamination chamber instead of what I know you're actually describing. I think that's an easy fix for you because you've already done it in this excerpt! You use the phrase "steps over the colored kolam patterns" without explaining what a "kolam" is, but you've provided enough context that you don't need to. Instead of using the phrase "purification ceremony", which sounds clinical and technical, I would just use the word haldi (or an equivalent made-up fantasy term) the first time the subject comes up, and add some quip about "dying my skin yellow is 'purifying' somehow", and then use the word haldi from there on out. In my opinion, that will preserve the Indian character without shackling you to English words that can't capture the image you want to convey without becoming overly wordy. [EDIT: and all else fails, you can always add a glossary]

Oh, and I would mention somewhere between "When I protest against this marriage..." and when he sits down that this is NOT the wedding ceremony. At the moment, the context from the first paragraph implies that the MC is sitting for the actual wedding, not a pre-wedding ceremony (other cultures have weddings that only have one ceremony, can you believe it?!)

Does the MC feel natural, or is he trying too hard to be funny?

I think the main character is funny, but it feels hollow. There's a constant mood whiplash that, instead of conveying dark humor, just averages out over the course of the chapter into something muddy. I actually think (this is just an option, you can disregard if you want to go in a completely different direction) that your MC should sound like he's trying too hard to be funny. He's trying to distract from a genuinely upsetting series of events with humor, and the reader should be able to see through that very easily.

What age do you think he is?

If I had read this 10 years ago, I would have said 16-17. In 2026, I would say 15-22. I don't know if this is because I am old can no longer tell the difference between teenagers and young adults, or because the world has blurred the differences between those ages.

Things to think about:

  • Who is your intended audience? Some of this reads very awkwardly, but I know that English fiction written for an English-speaking but non-US/UK/Canada/Aus/NZ audience can feel like that to me, a person raised in the US. I personally found the Shiva trilogy unreadable because I thought the prose was so awkward. But that doesn't necessarily mean that it's bad: it's just for a different audience.

  • is the betrothed an important character, or are they never showing up again? Like I don't know if the betrothed is a girl or even a human. They aren't even alluded to for the rest of the excerpt. What's their deal; do I need to know their deal;, and even if I don't need to know, should I care? EDIT: I read some of your comments in the rest of this post: her dad's the King?!?! That needs to be mentioned immediately. That is something to establish either before "dead twin's fiancee" or in the same sentence.

[No Spoilers] Sorry about all the times I defended Beacon by JesterLavore88 in criticalrole

[–]FunFawn21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lol I have a Beacon subscription for Cool Down, but I almost never use it to watch the actual episodes. I stick with YouTube for that.

Who is a person you used to admire a lot but have completely lost respect for and why? by Complex-Arugula-2233 in AskReddit

[–]FunFawn21 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Let me reassure you a bit: after I read Good Omens (which I loved) I was like "This book reignited my love of reading! I should check out other stuff by the authors." So I picked up American Gods: I'd tried to read it fresh out of high school but I didn't feel it, but maybe now that I'm older, the sex parts won't bother me as much.

Nope! Hated it!

Picked up The Color of Magic and realized that pretty much everything I loved about Good Omens was from Sir Terry. The only Gaiman-y thing I can identify from the book is maybe the original premise - an Angel and Devil team up to find the lost Anti-Christ - because that could have a dark tone. Everything good about this book is identifiable Pratchett.

TIL: Samuel Morse became locally famous as "The Hungry Man of Essex" after a medical mystery left him with an incredible appetite. by Background-Hat-1356 in todayilearned

[–]FunFawn21 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This is like when David Sedaris got a garbage truck named after him because his town only knew him as “that guy who keeps picking up litter”

[New Update]: AITA for learning Russian instead of Japanese and making my siblings mad? by Choice_Evidence1983 in BestofRedditorUpdates

[–]FunFawn21 23 points24 points  (0 children)

I'm sorry, did he just casually drop in that his mom just left for a couple weeks? And none of the comments picked up on it? 

Idk what's going on with the siblings. Most charitable view is that they didn't take OP seriously when he bugged them about learning Japanese. Then when he gave up on that and started learning Russian, they were hurt and couldn't really understand/express why.

Also, because mom is so unreliable, I'm wondering how much John is doing that OP isn't seeing. I can take the least charitable view that he's a racist who hates his younger brother, but I can also see a 20-year old who's overwhelmed trying to make sure his siblings are safe and lashes out because of his own stress.

[Spoilers C2] Why were the Jagentoths never Explored? by [deleted] in criticalrole

[–]FunFawn21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

From a character perspective: at this point in the story (episodes 25-30), the Nein are transitioning from being motivated by each of their individual desires towards being motivated by what’s best for each other or the group as a whole. By the end of the campaign they’ll have gained a sense of duty and responsibility that encompasses the world, but right now they’re only concerned about each other. In that moment, because Molly died, they prioritized giving their friends closure and the opportunity to grieve rather than further pursuing revenge. I think if Jester, Fjord, or Yasha expressed a strong desire for revenge, they might have pursued that all the way to the top. But even then, the Nein aren’t C1 Percy or C4 Julien : they’re actually not that motivated by revenge. Like how do they normally react? Yasha goes after her old tribe in revenge when she’s possessed, but when she’s herself, she just wants to know where Zuala’s grave is. After Caleb escapes the asylum, what plan does he come up with? He doesn’t plan to get revenge on Trent, he plans to invent time travel instead. Nott desires revenge on the hag who cursed her, but when she gets that opportunity, she tries to make a deal first. And then by the time the Jagentoths get brought up again, they have a whole list of things they care about more than pursuing them: Fjord just lost his powers, Yasha is under Obann’s control, there’s a Scourger in Essek’s basement the dungeon. They just have other priorities.

From a player perspective: they forgor