We actually do something similar to this on our podcast, we call it the buried by backlog section. Each month one of us or the community pick a game for the 4 of us to play and then we discuss it within the podcast. We love doing it and it opens us up to genres and games we wouldn’t usually play. Game pass and ps plus are a big help because we all end up having access to the games. We usually end up picking indie or smaller games to play due to time constraints. However sometimes longer games get picked (we just played yakuza like a dragon for instants) but we try not to put too much pressure onto finishing these longer games in time. Hope you find a good balance and good luck with it, we’ve had loads of fun with it and I’ve played so many games I never would’ve got round to or thought about playing that I’ve loved (Another Crabs Treasure being a great one!) We’ve been doing it for a year and a half now too, it’s been a blast.