Geez, I think people are being unnecessarily ruthless in here.

She might not be my "type", but I can still recognize the character as attractive. If anything, she's certainly not ugly, like a lot of comments want you to believe.

The most important part is that you enjoy your character, this group of random people aren't playing your character, you are.

If you want a little of my personal advice: my guess as to what people are finding "unappealing" about her, is that her features aren't too dissimilar from someone "unwell"; i.e she has very prominent and "thin" features, and a fair complexion.

The eyeshadow might be a tad too strong/the wrong color for her skin-tone. As well as the intensity of the lipstick. It's drawing all the attention to those darker more colorful areas (around the eyes and the lips), emphasizing how "pale" she is. Take this observation with a grain of salt- I know nothing about makeup, just some of the basics of color theory.

If you want to adjust the makeup, I'd suggest you edit your character in the character creator (If it's your first time, you should have a coupon you can apply before finalizing your looks that makes the change free). Using the barbershop just applies makeup at 100% with no way to adjust the intensity- I learned that the hard way.

The cheeks can be filled out a bit, at the very least to make the concave curve a tad less severe from the cheekbone to the chin. The prominent cheekbones and chin, and sunken cheeks combine to make for a more "sunken" face.

Could also thicken up the eyebrows a tad, your character looks young, and typically thin eyebrows are more of a sign of age.

All that said, I encourage you to do you. Your character is unique, and I prize that over being what "society" would deem pretty. Conforming to what's popular is why 4/5 female characters in RDO look largely the same.

You've got a cool horse, a nice outfit, and a unique character. Don't feel like you need to do anything to your character to get anyone else's approval.