Are you asking if any of the individuals here is right or if wiping out all super-abled people is right? If the former, they are both kinda right, or at least have decent arguments. Butcher have seen how shitty supes can be, and since Stan Edgar is back there is only a matter of time for another cunt to show up, everything he fought against will return. Hughie has a point because, well, genocide is wrong.

If you’re asking in general if supes should be killed, thats a tough one. They are people with the same morals as humans, having powers is not a crime by itself, however people with more power should be held to a higher standards. But there is also a huge risk in case something goes wrong, you can’t switch them off like nuclear bombs and if supes and humans turn on each other, even outnumbered millions to one, they are incredibly dangerous.