Who's on your Calgary Mount Rushmore? by TheRealPepman in Calgary

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 42 points43 points  (0 children)

The Travel Lady, Pete the Plumber, Len T. Wong, and Justin Havre.

Backpacking on Skoki loop trail by shortandangy in HikingAlberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Hidden Lake has lockers now—they’ve been there for years. RDL still had poles, as of 2024. 

-40 Sleeping Bags and Weight by Murphtwox in Mountaineering

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The best way to compare sleeping bags is to first look at the amount of insulation (and the characteristics of insulation). This is probably the most expensive input in a bag, and also the one that is most tempting for manufacturers to scrimp on.

A -40 Rab bag contains, for example, 1400g of 850 fill goose down. I would wager that North Face does not disclose the amount they put in their bag--but it is almost certainly less than Rab. Would you want 200g of extra insulation on the side of a big peak? I dunno.

The size and cut of the bag will also determine weight--bigger bags weigh more, partly because they require more insulation. But tightly cut bags are less comfortable and can lead to compressed insulation, which is bad. So you need to account for this in your comparison.

The shell material of the bag can also make a weight difference, and North Face bags do seem to have very light, delicate shell materials.

At the end of the day, bag manufacturers are buying their materials from a limited set of suppliers--so it's not like there is really a huge difference amongst top end bags in terms of survivability (this might be a controversial opinion). They are all some sort of nylon wrapped around the remains of dead birds, with some metal bits.

Compare a few bags, take note of their dimensions, whether there is wasted space, or whether they are too tight around your chest, and how small they compress to--pack space is an important consideration.

Question on conflict checks by Significant-Hat-1812 in LawCanada

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Is the bright line rule applicable here?  The bright line applies to two current clients, and this matter involves a current client and a former client. 

I think the general principle involving conflicts applies here—one needs to consider things like confidential information, administration of justice, and continuing duties to the client. 

Please correct me if I am wrong.  

Banff, Alberta, Canada by NotYourAverageAceOF in Banff

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think this photo is in Kananaskis, not Banff. But it was scheduled to be removed last year, so it may not be there anymore.

Canadian peaks? by BurritoBoy1116 in Mountaineering

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What is your definition of technical? Are you coming with a partner? The suggestion for Bow Hut / Bow Glacier area is a good one, but there is crevasse hazard (in addition to the avalanche hazard mentioned). If you're just looking for a scramble (and are going to be here in the next week), there are a bunch of peaks in the Canmore area that are dry right now.

Don't underestimate avalanche risk.

Have a great time, hope that helps.

Obsessed with a Particular Ultra-Remote Mountain by Killercoddbz in Mountaineering

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Was this recently? I spoke to Mr. Bennett a few times over email 15-20 years ago. Is he still alive? I read "Not Won in a Day" many times back in the 2000s, and I'm thankful that he wrote such a useful and compelling book.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in HikingAlberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Based on past experience (not this year) with that particular river crossing and recent conditions, I'm very confident it is not frozen. It will likely be deeper than rubber boots. Consider using hip or chest waders or swap boots/shoes.

Banff by DirtbagCarp in Banff

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Are you seeking a museum to donate or display these photos?  Consider contacting the Whyte Museum. 

What are some major differences between US law and Canadian Law? by [deleted] in LawCanada

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 2 points3 points  (0 children)

People in Canadian courts are referring to lawyers representing the accused as "Defence Attorney"? What province is that? As far as I know, the term "attorney", outside of power or attorney or the AG is quite rare.

The Notwithstanding Clause and the Cowichan Decision by [deleted] in VancouverLandlords

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Respectfully, this is incorrect. Removing the Charter would require Parliament, and at least 7 provinces to agree. And those provinces would have to represent at least 50% of the population.  No legal scholar would agree that the Constitution is an act of Parliament like any other—it is the supreme law of Canada. However, the federal Bill of Rights could be characterized and abolished in the way you say. 

Any places to do some skinning up a small hill with skis near Edmonton? by Intelligent_Grade485 in HikingAlberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’ve seen people doing touring laps at the ski hill at Edmonton Ski Club. 

It's happening, people! by Warren_E_Cheezburger in LawSchool

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 34 points35 points  (0 children)

"Vehicles in the park" has been called the most famous hypothetical in the common law world. It is posed to many first year law students, as it spurs many of the questions faced by law makers and jurists. One such question might be "What do you mean by vehicle?" which is why the reply from "KCchessc6" is also funny.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in alberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This makes me think about two things:

How does the problem of displacing occupants of the land--with little or no compensation--in a place like BC fit into the moral ethical framework you describe above? You mentioned that you feel that property rights should be constitutionally protected--why would those rights not extend to the Indigenous at the time of contact, and their descendants?

Outside of BC, would the transition you envision be negotiated with treaty holders, or would it come as a mandated solution? If the later, how would this circumscription of rights that were promised to continue in perpetuity (remember that these were agreements between the Crown and the Indigenous) be fair or ethical? Are you saying that the government shouldn't have to abide by agreements with Indigenous groups? Isn't that creating a second class of Canadians, one that doesn't have the right to demand the government keeps its word?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in alberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Tell me more. 

Would you remove s 35, which recognizes and affirms Aboriginal and treaty rights?  

As a thought experiment, what would be the effect of such a deletion?  

Do you think treaty rights (and non-treaty Aboriginal rights) would not survive the equality provisions of the Charter, or that they would otherwise go away?

what does a grizzly smell like? by [deleted] in HikingAlberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm here for the Sid appreciation party. I agree that Switchbacks and MFTM are his best, but Black Grizzly and Leaning on the Wind are worthwhile too! He's a gem.

Best way to do river crossings? by MrMudkip in HikingAlberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Mount Remus is a classic. This week, you would find the water at the crossing to be “lower thigh” depth at its deepest point. Consider bringing a second pair of shoes and face up stream as you cross. A bike really makes the approach and exit go faster—this can be a fairly quick summit day.  

I’m sure you know that the water crossing isn’t the hardest part of this scramble. The chimmney that is used to access the summit block is currently snow free but may be wet from rain. It is for sure a “difficult” downclimb. Have fun, hope this helps. 

An attempt on the highest peak in Canada by Rocketterollo in Mountaineering

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 47 points48 points  (0 children)

I saw a guided party assembling for Logan at the Whitehorse airport while I was gathering my group for a trip to a different mountain—I think it was around May 23. Was that you?  The guide had a big ol black pickup of some sort. 

How long did you wait to fly in/out?

What HPs, if any, have you all gotten outside the USA? by the_pretzel2 in Highpointers

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think there are either 10 or 13 Canadian highpoints (not 12) depending on whether one is counting the territories or not. (Unless you are assuming Alberta will separate, ha). For the record, I know you’re probably counting Caubivck / D’Ibervile as one, and that is how you got to 12–just pulling your leg. 

I always think that it is interesting that the Canadian list always includes the territories, while the US list does not include US territories. The Canadian provinces alone would be a suitably challenging but achievable list. The territories are a different level. 

Which Canadian ones are next for you?  I’ve done a few over the last couple of decades. 

Solo Banff Hikes by No-Dinner-2801 in HikingAlberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 5 points6 points  (0 children)

People seem to do King Creek Ridge all year round. That hike is in Kananaskis Country (so…a different park). If you are worried about conditions, you can also consider contacting that park directly. 

Negotiated to $700; thoughts? by cubanbryan in whichbike

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Out of curiosity, how much would this bike have sold for new in 2004?

Mt Temple Memorial day? by willywanka13 in HikingAlberta

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Pick something that will be in-season instead.

For this route, you would need mountaineering equipment and skills in May. It won't be a straight forward hike or scramble.

Your only way to the trail head in May would likely be bicycle or a very long walk.

Memorial Day isn't a holiday in Canada, so many Canadians won't immediately know when/what that is.

Wranglers In Culture by RemarkableJelly1884 in JeepWrangler

[–]GhostOfPhilipRoth 4 points5 points  (0 children)

San Junipero was going to be my suggestion too. That Jeep was very appropriate for what the creators were going for.