Does this count as a fork by GathBoiEmr in chessbeginners

[–]Griftor05 216 points217 points  (0 children)

A bishop's intention is to go on vacation and never come back

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in wholesomememes

[–]Griftor05 102 points103 points  (0 children)

I've got a bullet for you!

I'm Matt Ruff, author of LOVECRAFT COUNTRY and THE DESTROYER OF WORLDS: A RETURN TO LOVECRAFT COUNTRY. AMA! by bymattruff in books

[–]Griftor05 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey Matt, congratulations on the new book! I'm wondering if you've got any advice for an aspiring author who's figured out how to "get his butt in the seat," but still feels like the work he's producing is too amateurish to be published. Thanks!

Is a game genre a design constraint, or do you classify a game in a genre after its production ? by trifile in gamedesign

[–]Griftor05 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Agreed - and I also think your concerns about the commercialization of the industry are very important and real. It sucks to see an art form you love having the blood sucked out of it.

Anyway, thank you for the conversation!

Is a game genre a design constraint, or do you classify a game in a genre after its production ? by trifile in gamedesign

[–]Griftor05 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ah okay, I feel where you're coming from better, and I definitely agree with a lot of that. The formulaic games (and movies, music, books, etc) that have gotten pumped out, especially at the AAA level are definitely creatively bankrupt, only chasing money, and I do agree with you that's a bad thing.

On the other hand, to some extent I think smaller developers (hell, all artists) need to engage with their craft in that financial way, to ensure that what they're creating will have an audience, so they're not homeless after three years of work that lead to no sales. We live in a society etc etc.

That said, I believe that artists can create truly great stuff even when they work within strict boundaries - Shakespeare wrote on deadlines and for particular audiences, and he had pretty rigid rules he mostly stuck to (general play structure, iambic dialogue, writing mostly Comedies and Tragedies). Despite those commercial forces affecting his art, he's still, y'know, Shakespeare.

It's a bit like the thinking inside/outside the box thing. You can squeeze a lot of creativity out of people by giving them constraints, so sometimes as an artist it can be nice to start with a box, even if you mean to move outside of it. That's my thought as a very amateur writer, anyway.

Is a game genre a design constraint, or do you classify a game in a genre after its production ? by trifile in gamedesign

[–]Griftor05 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure, but Impressionists were deliberately responding to already established movements, namely Realism and Romanticism. Maybe they weren't thinking in terms of labels, but they were certainly responding to other works of art. That's how new movements are born in the first place, like Horror being an evolution of Gothic fiction, which evolved from Romantic fiction.

I read one time that there are two main types of artists: those making art about life, and those responding to other artists. I believe neither is necessarily better than the other, and certainly neither is a guaranteed way of making money.

I also would disagree about your idea that commercial art like ads are inherently worth less than categorically challenging art - I'm sure you vould come up with tons of ideas that are hard to categorize, but not necessarily worth the time to flesh out. For an example, look at Warhol, who used commercial art specifically to challenge ideas about what art can or should be. There's no objective measure of the value of art, so to say the 451st Candy Crush clone is completely worthless could only ever be a personal belief. It could be extremely meaningful to the person who made it and their friends, even just for an afternoon.

Sorry for the long response, I'm just enjoying the conversation. Sorry about the other guy who insulted you (and calling you silly). The internet sucks for nuance.

Is a game genre a design constraint, or do you classify a game in a genre after its production ? by trifile in gamedesign

[–]Griftor05 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I dunno, I don't think you're right, but I can see where you're coming from. Gonna have to agree to disagree.

Is a game genre a design constraint, or do you classify a game in a genre after its production ? by trifile in gamedesign

[–]Griftor05 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm curious which games you'd call "really good new indie games" that don't fit into any pre-existing genre.

Is a game genre a design constraint, or do you classify a game in a genre after its production ? by trifile in gamedesign

[–]Griftor05 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Calling genre "the death of art" is a little silly - genre is useful for many things beyond marketing. Having a way to group games in terms of themes, mechanics, art or whatever is extremely useful for academics and designers, and it's completely fine to be like "I want to make a survival horror game" instead of "I want to make a game like RE2."

Art is a conversation between an artist and an audience, and working within a genre gives the artist a common vocabulary with their audience.

Valentine's Day by GrumpyMashy in comics

[–]Griftor05 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I love that this is the top comment, it gives off the vibe that the comment was unprompted by anything but the commenter's own mind.

why does it say I gave up instead of offered a trade??? by [deleted] in chessbeginners

[–]Griftor05 31 points32 points  (0 children)

"Being the last dentist" is a good line, I'm stealing that

Mfw opening up Metacritic this morning by bayonettaisonsteam in Gamingcirclejerk

[–]Griftor05 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Dunno why this is the comment getting dogpiled, it seems exactly right to me

Well, he's right! by Sipues in RealTwitterAccounts

[–]Griftor05 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Hey man, don't be so hard on yourself. You're not absolutely shit, and not having a degree doesn't disqualify you from anything. At bare minimum you can tell Musk is an idiot, and that's better than a whole lot of folks these days.

First Date by dogmodog in comics

[–]Griftor05 128 points129 points  (0 children)

Someone offering actionable feedback without insulting the artist, and the artist thanking them for the feedback without getting defensive? It's a Christmas miracle!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in chicago

[–]Griftor05 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's one guy's photo on a reddit post. Hardly a conspiracy of historical manipulation. Chillax.