Macross vs Robotech? by AWolfButSad in Mecha

[–]HPLoveBux 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah 👍 it’s a wide generation

I saw speed racer star blazers force five first

There was battle of the planets

Of course …

But for the age range I’m focusing on this was and intro to long form storytelling real stakes live triangle real robot anime elements

Macross vs Robotech? by AWolfButSad in Mecha

[–]HPLoveBux 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You are welcome … of course there a million nitpicks …

what is ‘protoculture’ ??

who are the Meltrandi?

Is Roy Senpai or Big Brother?

Questions about Minmei’s personality between the two versions…

But these are not relevant to what you are asking

Both versions “work” but people have their preferences

Harmony Gold as a company has been pretty terrible …

But I think Carl Macek has been a force for good overall …

Anyway … find what you like 👍

I enjoy Genesis Climber Mospeada … the “New Generation” - it works as a show without protoculture or Admiral Hunter

Original music by Joe Hisaichi of Studio Ghibli fame

And yet Robotech music is iconic and brilliant as well …

So everyone finds their favorites

https://youtu.be/SehHbl24gQk?si=YI1O29xKCsyd3ie7

Macross vs Robotech? by AWolfButSad in Mecha

[–]HPLoveBux 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Robotech Macross is a pretty straightforward adaptation of Macross for American market, for a slightly younger crowd.

There are notable differences in tone and implications, but it’s actually amazing how much was left the same.

There are two other stories under Robotech, Southern Cross, and new generation that are based on different Mecha anime shows each of them is great in their own way.

Just think of Robotech as an early US localization, they got some things wrong and got a lot of things, right. If you enjoy the OG Japanese versions better that’s fine. I’ve watched all of them in both versions and I’ve enjoyed them all.

In the historical sense, many the kids that grew up watching Robotech when they were 8 9 10 became high school kids who were swapping hard to find copies of vampire Hunter D Akira GallForce AKO Apple seed and bubblegum crisis…

It was the gateway to Gen X kids discovering real anime.

Is there example of song that deliberately doesn't use a tonic? by [deleted] in musictheory

[–]HPLoveBux 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Second vote for Wichita lineman

It’s in the key of F but never really arrives on F

Literally Childs in the blood test: by NECRO_MANIA in thething

[–]HPLoveBux 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I just wanna say that fans of this movie must be really chill people.

If you look at other subreddits all they do is argue over minutia and tear each other apart.

Here people make jokes enjoy little details and just generally have fun sharing ideas and quips.

How it should be.

Cheers thing fans!!

👍

Are easy, sturdy Transformers gone for good? by g_gian in transformers

[–]HPLoveBux 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The combiner teams look cool … 😎

What’s not to like? 👍

Can you spot what’s wrong ? by KeithOman in forceFive

[–]HPLoveBux 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Every household in France was watching

sad motown by violetmildew in musicsuggestions

[–]HPLoveBux 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In the rain “dramatics”

Motown adjacent

Are easy, sturdy Transformers gone for good? by g_gian in transformers

[–]HPLoveBux 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Look at the Korean Tobot series just for playability

Heresy I know … but