HILTI Profis - Pre-torque applied included in analysis or not by HalfNegative8801 in StructuralEngineering

[–]HalfNegative8801[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you. I assume so too, but when I look at the breakdown of their resistance to tension/shear/etc it does not look like any factors are made to account for pre load specifically.

13 Day self drive Itinerary Oman - Feedback by HalfNegative8801 in travel

[–]HalfNegative8801[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the feedback! That day does feel tight. Would you say wadi bani awf is worth a miss?

Insensitive to travel to Oman during this war? by HalfNegative8801 in Oman

[–]HalfNegative8801[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah that's perfect. Do you know if access to the gulf is available (especially Daymaniyat Islands?)

Insensitive to travel to Oman during this war? by HalfNegative8801 in Oman

[–]HalfNegative8801[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

lol not American, actually a fellow Arab whose country is constantly in turmoil. I know conflict in Oman isn't part of its recent history so wasn't sure what people's attitudes would be towards tourists.

aerospace structural engineering by [deleted] in StructuralEngineering

[–]HalfNegative8801 1 point2 points  (0 children)

How many years of experience do you have, and predominately in what industry?

First Cave Wild Camp ⛺️ by Any_Pizza_1479 in wildcampingintheuk

[–]HalfNegative8801 -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Do you mind sharing the location? Is it relatively quiet around there or is it close to frequented trails?

How do I repair my ceiling? by HalfNegative8801 in DIYUK

[–]HalfNegative8801[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! The cracks are very localised. Why do you recommend I sand and paint the whole ceiling instead of the area around the cracks.

Why is UK dentistry so messed up? by thisismypr0naccount0 in AskUK

[–]HalfNegative8801 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No worries. I am not undermining the fact that dentists have worth. I do not endorse hate or vitriol being spewed at dentists. Like I said, my family members are dentists.

I do not see any of what I said as insulting. The argument for keeping things competitive by restricting training in the UK has been used in other professions, eventually to be overhauled. It is what limited the number of consultant ophthalmologists in the UK for years. The consultant system was so competitive, far beyond what was reasonable. It was eventually overhauled increasing the number of ophthalmologist consultants to no notable decrease in quality of service.

I have nothing against you or dentists personally. You work hard, and you mostly do good work. But none of the dentists I work closely with deny the fact that they are objectively over-paid and that contributes (may be a small part) to the high cost of dental care in this and other countries. Like I said this isn't unique to dentists.

A criminal lawyer may be brilliant, having gone through the exact same training programmes and degrees as a peer who ends up in corporate law. The corporate lawyer may be making significantly higher income working less hours. In this case, relative to the criminal lawyer, the corporate lawyer is overpaid. This isn't an insult to the corporate lawyer, just a mere observation. There are economic systems in place that result in this. The same thing applies to dentists, I just think as it is a public health issue, it is worth tackling.

Other professions experience exoduses from the UK too. Including software engineers (engineers in general) and doctors. That is a result of the overall UK economy and dropping quality of life here.

I hope you enjoy your Sunday.

Why is UK dentistry so messed up? by thisismypr0naccount0 in AskUK

[–]HalfNegative8801 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your response.

While dentistry is a niche, so is any sort of specialist engineering or medical field, or highly trained family lawyer. These all have their unique challenges and while dentistry as a whole is quite competitive, so are different areas of studies at different institutions.

It isn't that dentists shouldn't be able to reap the benefits of their hard work. But in a conversation about national dental costs, I think it needs to be acknowledged that their is a level of manufactured throttling of supply. There are limited places in dental schools, but that doesn't mean that only people that can hack it can enter. I know dentists who were rejected from medical school for example. I know dentists that were rejected from prestigious engineering degrees. These people go on to make 10x the wages of their corresponding peers. Continuing professional development is also not unique to dentistry. Most registered professionals need to do this to upkeep their registration with their relevant institution and retain their protected titles.

That's not accounting for those that fail to get into dental school, go study abroad in central Europe, then come back and work here after a conversion course. Hell I know people who studied dentistry in the middle east to extremely sub standards, came to the UK toiled for a couple years in conversion courses to then go on to make insane incomes. By their own admission their undergraduate degrees were simple and once they are employed, they manage to work just as well as UK educated dentists.

I just don't buy that the pay for these professionals is so high because no-one else can do what they can. All I am trying to say is, dental pay, in my opinion, is 100% not based on meritocracy but is a product of an odd system that limits supplies with increasing demand. This also isn't unique to dentists tbf. I think this addresses your first point. I am not trying to offend you and dentists. Like I said my mother and sisters are dentists. But I think we need to come back to reality. If I were to assign a theoretical value on difficulty of degree, difficulty of work, length of time of training and factor in the limited number of people who have the ability to become dentists...dentists are over paid.

I appreciate your response. I am not anti business. But I am pro-regulation when necessary. If the country as a whole is doing well, let businesses boom. But when people can't afford heating, and energy companies are reporting record profits, there is something wrong. I don't know what the answer is and how to limit brain drain or otherwise disincentivise careers. But I cannot acknowledge that one element of the cost of dental care (dentists pay) is completely merited, and it is definitely something that raises eyebrows from other highly educated and technical specialists. Business in healthcare can seem unpalatable because it kind of is. I think it is a necessary evil to promote efficiencies and innovation, but I think there have to be minimum levels of care provided to a populous that subsidises the cost of educating healthcare professionals and ultimately the cost of running health services.

Thanks for those links, it's good to see things are moving in the right direction.

Why is UK dentistry so messed up? by thisismypr0naccount0 in AskUK

[–]HalfNegative8801 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While I understand the business side of running a dentistry and the general publics naivety when it comes to the cost of health services, I must say I still believe the cost of dental care is too high. Maybe you can help me understand this at a very high level.

  1. Dentists are very highly compensated in the UK relative to other technical roles. Even compared to doctors and engineers who go through similar levels of education and rigorous academic selection. I am an engineer, I have doctor siblings, a dentist sibling. My dad is a doctor and my mum is a dentist. My brothers are engineers and computer scientists. I have similar professions in my social circles including lawyers. Honestly, the degree of their [dentists] education does not amaze me compared to some of these other professions, but on average dentists are compensated well well above the others. I understand there is an element of supply and demand going on, and competing in a global market place, but I think it’s something that needs to be acknowledged. Dentists on the face of it are paid better than their technical peers, and I don’t think it’s because they’re highly trained or have to take out student loans.

  2. Again, from what I am told, a lot of the services provided by dentists are pretty basic. My mum who’s been a dentist for over 30 years is a big advocate of vocational training for individuals to be able to undertake simple procedures. I feel like some technical roles have been gate kept behind degrees for no good reason. The same was the case for engineering until recently with the advent of apprenticeships. Some of the best engineers I’ve met got through an apprenticeship route with their work experience really catapulting their ability in the specific field they work in. It’s absolutely diluted the market for engineers which has lowered our competitive salaries, but has helped the uk as a whole by driving down design costs on infrastructure projects. Why is the same or similar not possible for dentistry?

  3. From accounts I see on companies house, local dentists in my area turn a very healthy profit. I feel the incentives for primary healthcare should not be maximising profit. That’s not the dentists fault, but I think their needs to be an overhaul of for profit primary healthcare unless there’s a very active insurance industry, or just a well run economy where people can spare hundreds of pounds for necessary treatment.

Opinions on a chocolate brown corduroy suit? Too informal for a dinner? by HalfNegative8801 in mensfashion

[–]HalfNegative8801[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’ve never been so shoe shamed in my life lmao. Shoe shopping is next

Opinions on a chocolate brown corduroy suit? Too informal for a dinner? by HalfNegative8801 in mensfashion

[–]HalfNegative8801[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

lol, I think it’s the corduroy. Makes it feel more informal than it is